Skip to content

EASING THE TENSIONS: Civic Engagement and Participation as Avenues of Social Conciliation

Introduction

Is there a relation between the lack of participation in institutional decision making and protests? If so, how can we subvert that equation? In this paper, I will explore the relationship between civic engagement and the exercise of First Amendment rights. I’ll also explain how some institutions have dealt with tensions associated with the intensive exercise of these rights. I’ll focus on the particular experience of the University of Puerto Rico (UPR), where after years of violent conflict, a Política de No-Confrontación (i.e., non-confrontation policy or PNC) engaged members of every sector of the campus community in the prevention of violent incidents in protests. I’ll also comment on how recent student movements in the island have implemented radical democratic governance as an alternative to models of representative democracy that limit participation and discussion about issues of public concern. I call for co-governance of institutions as a way of building inclusive, vibrant, active and civically engaged communities.

The case of the UPR. From the top down.

There are approaches to social conflict that help ease the tensions associated with the intensive exercise of First Amendment rights. There are also other approaches that exacerbate those tensions. After brutal clashes in the 1970s and 1980s between students and police forces (which had resulted in the burning of the ROTC headquarters in Río Piedras and in casualties on both sides), a policy of non-confrontation was put into place in the UPR. It followed the Latin-American tradition of autonomous universities and barred uniformed ROTC cadets and state police from campuses (except in extraordinary circumstances, when the university’s chancellor could ask for state intervention). Internal UPR security personnel was allowed on campus, but unarmed (Oduardo-Sierra, 2014).

This Policy of Non-confrontation was the institutional product through which the University made a commitment for advancing freedom of speech, respect, tolerance and peaceful coexistence (Ramos Rodríguez, 2008, p. 14). The four fundamental principles of the Policy of Non-Confrontation (PNC) were the following:

  1. Dialogue is the substance of University coexistence;
  2. Trust is the key to establish a mutual relationship of security, honest communication, and interaction;
  3. Respect implies deference for difference; and
  4. Organizations are successful in the measure that they can establish a culture of peace (p. 17-18).

Bravo Vick and Ramos Rodríguez (2008) explain how the PNC has worked in situations of institutional crisis. They provide strategies, within the principles of the PNC, used by the Administration to face institutional crisis. In promoting dialogue as the substance of University coexistence, they emphazise in the importance of promoting rational dialogue within all sectors of the campus community, the importance of basing arguments in empirical facts, the importance of listening to dissent, showing openness to negotiation, giving the opportunity to opposing parties to obtain some benefits, invoking mutual responsibility and the creation of rules of coexistence even in times of institutional crisis (p. 200). In promoting trust as a way to establish a situation of mutual security, communication, honesty and interaction, Bravo Vick and Ramos Rodríguez stress the importance of acting with honesty, showing availability, facing the situations directly, and promoting the flow of information (p. 207-210). The University Administration must be an active promoter of mutual respect among individuals and sectors on campus, it should show deference for difference, dissidence, and diversity within campus groups. It should perceive the conflict as a learning experience and understand its social function (p. 211-213).

In explaining how organizations are successful in the measure that they can establish a culture of peace, the authors explain, that many of the strategies used within the PNC are directed to promoting peace within campus and with the final goal of promoting the University’s academic objectives (p. 213). Some of the strategies employed by the administration in promoting peace include showing restraint in the exercise of authority, promoting participative democracy, the strengthening of representative organizations and the promotion of multi-sectorial organisms, like the Junta Coordinadora de Seguridad (Security Coordinating Board). This Board had members of every sector of the university’s community; workers, students, faculty, security, and administration were given the task to prevent violent incidents in protests, and to enforce the rules of coexistence agreed upon by different groups, in times of institutional conflict. The PNC principles also advised against the intervention of external agents in University affairs, this meant keeping the police off campus (p. 219-220).

It was in 1985, amidst a strike that disrupted campus activity, that then Chancellor, Dr. Juan Fernández, was asked if he would call on the police to intervene. He said “No, in this campus we have implemented what I call a Policy of Non-Confrontation” (p. 144). The Policy of Non Confrontation was thoroughly discussed in the deliberative forums of the university and was unanimously endorsed by the Academic Senate in 1992. The Policy was ratified by the Academic Senate in 2003 and has been accepted by Chancellors throughout the years. Although it is true that the University of Puerto Rico has not always adhered to this Policy1, the guiding principles of the Policy of Non-Confrontation have served as a guide for the Institution since the early 80’s. During the last student strike of 2017, the Administration opted for negotiation and adhered to the policy of non-confrontation to the extent that it was almost found in contempt of court for not acting on a Court Injunction that required police intervention with students that were occupying campus. No disciplinary action was imposed to striking students. No blood was shed.

Critics of the PNC might argue that policies like this promote disruptive action among labor and student groups that from time to time find themselves at odds with the University Administration. That these policies promote doing nothing in the face of disruption of Campus activity. Facing these criticisms, José Jiménez Oxios, former Director of the Office of Security and Risk Management of the UPR stated:

Of course, the PNC…does not mean… as many people are saying, that nothing is to be done, it’s the other way around. It is not that nothing is to be done, in fact, a lot more is done[…] one has to do a lot, you have to go to meetings, you have to be aware to prevent confrontation, I mean, you have to work for real. (Bravo Vick, 2008, p. 107 )

Amidst various free-speech controversies that have affected UC Campuses and other universities throughout the United States, institutions must find their voice. The University of Puerto Rico in Río Piedras has found hers in the Policy of Non Confrontation. I am also very interested in studying how communities find theirs. Minorities, including latinxs, blacks, women, Native Americans, and others; students, labor groups, environmental groups and the LGBTTQI community, have found their voices and turned their indignation and anger into organizations, cultural agency, education programs, online debates, votes, protests, performance arts, and the likes. They have spoken out, denounced, and put their bodies upon the wheels. Racism, patriarchy, sex discrimination, homophobia, xenophobia, ableism, and other forms of discrimination can all be fought in ways yet to be discovered. We saw earlier how groups that have made leaps against inequality, have been denied First Amendment protection. Their expression has been deemed too disruptive to be protected.

From the bottom, up.

I will now turn to discuss a process that occurred in the outskirts of first amendment protection: the disruption of academic activities during the UPR student strikes. I will explain how disruptive conflicts can be seen as signs of democratic maturity, and how today’s social movements have potential to dream and act upon the possibility of a more democratic society. In the next pages, I intend to elaborate on ways in which democracy can and should be radically transformed, from the bottom, up.

Contemporary debates about democracy seem to reject the representative models that have predominated in political systems around the world. The discussion seems to have tilted to more inclusive models of participation and better processes of collective decision-making. Social movements have played a pivotal role in this new balance. The case of Puerto Rico has not been the exception.

In their groundbreaking book, Democratizing Democracy: Beyond the Liberal Democratic Canon, Boaventura de Sousa Santos and Leonardo Avritzer (2005) explain that representative democracy inevitably leads to stages of “low democratic intensity”. They explain:

[t]he global expansion of liberal democracy coincided with a serious crisis in the core countries where it had been most consolidated, a crisis that became known as the crisis of double pathology: the pathology of participation, especially in view of the dramatic increase in levels of abstention; and the pathology of representation- the fact that citizens feel themselves less and less represented by those they have elected. (p. xxxvi)

While citizens abstain from the political process, and economic forces strengthen their hold on democracy, we risk entering a period in which our society could be considered politically democratic, but socially fascist (p. lxvi).

Within the colonial context, Puerto Ricans in the island are subject to what constitutional law Professor, Efrén Rivera Ramos has called “partial democracy”, under which American Hegemony holds sway through an interplay of coercive and persuasive mechanisms (Rivera Ramos, 2007, pp. 195-199) (Oduardo-Sierra, 2014). The scope of this partial democracy has been seriously undermined by the recent PROMESA Law that creates a Fiscal Oversight Board. This is a board of unelected officials that oversees and even has the power to veto, economic and social laws and regulations passed by the local government, and the financial budgets of all of the government institutions. The Board has imposed economic austerity measures, in order to guarantee the payment a public debt that many argue is odious and was illegally acquired (Medina Fuentes, 2017). This democratic deficit has serious implications on the rights and liberties of society in general. Puerto Ricans have been alienated from their own political process. This concept is the key to understanding the relationship between lack of participation and the proliferation of social conflicts such as protests.

In the case of the University of Puerto Rico, legal alienation meant that if before management decisions like tuition-fee hikes fell upon the hands of its administration, which included at least a nominal participation by students in governance, now all of the decisions were taken by an unelected board that responded to exogenous ultra-conservative economic interests. As tuition fee hikes were announced, services to students were undercut, professor’s salaries were reduced, and pension funds were put at risk, the community would inevitably take a stand.

In El derecho de Resistencia en situaciones de carencia extrema, Roberto Gargarella (2007) described legal alienation as a situation in which law serves objectives that run contrary to those that justified its existence (p. 7). Alienated groups have serious difficulties to satisfy their most basic needs, to get their points across, to successfully demand changes in the laws or to make their representatives accountable for their actions (p. 17). If this is so, Gargarella argues, these alienated groups do not have a duty to adhere to strict legality, because it is precisely the legal system that causes them harm. Certain forms of resistance should be seen as morally permissible for them (p. 20).

This idea is rejected by traditional understandings of legal thought, as it is a direct challenge to the rule of law. Hurgen Habermas (2002), on his part, has given some clues about how the state should address these situations of conflict keeping in mind that civil disobedience could be the cornerstone of democracy:

Civil disobedience derives its dignity from the high aspirations of legitimacy in the democratic state. When prosecutors and judges do not respect this dignity, when they persecute people who break the rules as if they were common criminals, when they impose penalties as if these were common crimes, they incur in authoritarian legalism[…] they ignore the moral foundations of a fully developed democratic community. (p. 90)

Habermas stresses the importance of speech that might be deemed too disruptive or incompatible with First Amendment principles as a measure of a country’s democratic maturity. If the State prosecutes disruption, for example, as it does any other criminal offense, it is clear that even though the state may call itself a political democracy, its legal tradition reflects its totalitarian tendencies. This approach is an approach that will most likely exacerbate the tensions underlying the conflict at hand. Elswhere I have argued for the implementation of a therapeutic law enforcement approach, that includes the adoption of an orientation based, non-confrontational law enforcement policy that avoids the use or show of excessive force by all means in these situations (Oduardo‑Sierra, 2009).

In the past I have also described in detail the democratic values that have inspired student movements in Puerto Rico. The movement today, even when faced with a greater democratic deficit in the island, has taken these values to heart. In my 2014 article for the Berkeley Journal of Sociology, I described the democratic potential developed within the student movement:

Students saw their participation in the movement through a uniquely postcolonial lens: They attempted to enact a prefigurative politics within the university, and thus outside the constraints and practices of Puerto Rican partial democracy. The student movement practiced radical democracy internally and in its interactions with the rest of the student body, for example through general assemblies where collective actions were discussed and decided upon. As professor James Seale Collazo, who stood in solidarity with the student movement during the whole of the strike, points out: “Students developed and implemented an entire theory of horiziontalidad (horizontality), with issues discussed at Action Committee meetings (usually some twenty to fifty participants) before being brought to campus- wide plenary sessions.”(Seale-collazo, year, p. ) There was an explicit attempt to go beyond the liberal-democratic model of representative democracy, and to practice participative democracy by placing the emphasis on the deliberative process. There was, too, an overall conscience of the importance of this new democratic paradigm for the development of future radical political actions in the island: The practices of the student movement directly challenged the existing “partial democracy” of Puerto Rico.

My experiences as a social justice activist has led to the conclusion that only opening our institutions to governance methods that promote mutual respect and respect of diversity, that only through collective processes of dialogue and deliberative discussion, can we overcome the political stagnation that affects discussions and decision-making with regards to our island’s public affairs. I have come to the same conclusion as to institutions in the United States.

It is true that traditional legal thought in the United States does not recognize a right to community co-governance in public institutions2. Nonetheless, current debates on democracy assure us that deliberative democracy can be incorporated structurally through progressive constitutional and institutional changes that shake our countries out of the low democratic intensity they experience. Lucas Arrimada (2008) explains that participation and deliberation should be enforced in social institutions that provide public services, in order to promote civic engagement within the community and a more democratic political culture. Universities are a great place to start.

Conclusion

In this paper, we have seen both top down, and bottom up approaches to ease the tensions associated with the intensive exercise of first amendment rights. The top down approaches are grounded in the importance of the preservation of a culture of peace for the self-preservation of institutions. The bottom-up approaches have a more structural focus, that calls into question traditional legal thinking, imposing the idea of legitimacy over the authoritarian legalism that is common to current First Amendment understandings. In both cases, the tensions related to the intensive use of First Amendment rights have been used as opportunities for empowerment and change.

In the context of Puerto Rico, the colonial situation has led to a context of partial democracy and legal alienation. Through radical democratic governance, students in the University of Puerto Rico have gone from being mere spectators of administrative action, to civically engaged citizens who are active in University and state-wide politics. Their radical democratic governance directly challenged the understandings about liberal democracy that have caused the island’s democratic deficit. Following the lead of the Puerto Rican student movement, young activists around the United States some years later, were involved in the rise and development of the Occupy movement. In their public discussion sessions and decision-making processes, they had a call to order. “Mic-check!”, activists would say. “Mic-check”, the crowd around them would answer, assuring the speakers that they had everyone’s attention. From then on, all of the phrases in the activist’s message were repeated by the crowd. This was a way of going around public ordinances that prohibited the use of megaphones, and also a way of illustrating the magic of validating the voice of “the other” in the course of public discussion. Radical democracy and deliberation are the best ways to ensure valuable collective dynamics of discussion, understanding, and respect of difference. The full recognition of diversity is the first step towards easing the tensions inherent to a fractured society. Social movements championed by this generation have had the courage to dream and act upon the infinite possibilities of a more democratic society. I can only hope that we dare to take the next steps in the reform of institutions so these possibilities can take their course. I call for co-governance of institutions as a way of building inclusive, vibrant, active and civically engaged communities. Only through the widening of our democratic expectations can we find true avenues of social conciliation.

References

Arrimada, L. (2008). Constitucionalismo, Concepciones de Democracia y Diseño Institucional: sobre Frenos, Puentes y Motores en la democracia deliberativa, Homenaje a Carlos Nino. Argentina: La Ley.

De Sousa Santos, B. & Avritzer, L. (2005). Introduction: opening Up the Canon of Democracy. Democratizing Democracy: Beyond the Liberal Democratic Canon. London: Verso.

Bravo Vick, M. (2008) La Política de No-Confrontación en Tiempos de Cotidianidad Institucional (1985-1992). Lucha y Conciliación en la Universidad: Contexto, Desarrollo y Proyección de la Política de No- Confrontación. San Juan, PR: Publicaciones Puertorriqueñas. (pp. 101-147)

Bravo Vick, M. & Ramos Rodríguez. (2008) La Política de No-Confrontación en Situaciones de Crisis Institucional. Lucha y Conciliación en la Universidad: Contexto, Desarrollo y Proyección de la Política de No-Confrontación. San Juan, PR: Publicaciones Puertorriqueñas. (pp. 149-222)

Ramos-Rodríguez, I. (2008) Conceptualización de la Política de No-Confrontación. Lucha y Conciliación en la Universidad: Contexto, Desarrollo y Proyección de la Política de No-Confrontación. San Juan, PR: Publicaciones Puertorriqueñas. (pp. 9-33)

Rivera-Ramos, E. (2007). American Colonialism in Puerto Rico: The Judicial and Social Legacy. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener Publishers.

Oduardo-Sierra, G. (2014). Neoliberalism, Partial Democracy, and Resistance in the Colonial Context. Berkeley Journal of Sociology. Retrieved from: http://berkeleyjournal.org/2014/12/the-puerto-rican-student-movement-resistance-to-neoliberalism-and-partial-democracy-in-the-colonial-context/

Medina Fuentes, N. (2017). Deuda pública odiosa colonial: la fleche dirigida al Minotauro norteamericano. 80grados. Retreived from http://www.80grados.net/deuda-publica-odiosa-colonial-la-flecha-dirigida-al-minotauro-norteamericano/

Habermas, J. (2002). La desobediencia civil. Piedra de toque del Estado Democrático de Derecho. Ensayos politicos. Barcelona: Ediciones Península. pp. 71-101

Gargarella, R. (2007). El Derecho de Resistencia en situaciones de carencia extrema. Astrolabio: Revista internacional de filosofía. Núm. 4. Retrieved from http://www.ub.edu/astrolabio/Articulos4/ARTICULOgargarella.pdf

Oduardo-Sierra. G. (2009). Preventive Law Enforcement and Therapeutic Police intervention in Río Piedras. Sentido Común. Retrieved from http://reevolucionenaccion.blogspot.com/2009/11/preventive-law-enforcement-and.html

  1. I have discussed elsewhere the case of backlash to student expression in the University. Oduardo-Sierra, G. (2014). Neoliberalism, Partial Democracy, and Resistance in the Colonial Context. Berkeley Journal of Sociology. http://berkeleyjournal.org/2014/12/the-puerto-rican-student-movement-resistance-to-neoliberalism-and-partial-democracy-in-the-colonial-context/ ↩︎
  2. “Where a rule of conduct applies to more than a few people, it is impracticable that everyone should have a direct voice in its adoption. The Constitution does not require all public acts to be done in town meeting or an assembly of the whole. General statutes within the state power are passed that affect the person or property of individuals, sometimes to the point of ruin, without giving them a chance to be heard. Their rights are protected in the only way that they can be in a complex society -- by their power, immediate or remote, over those who make the rule[…] There must be a limit to individual argument in regard to matters affecting communities if government is to go on”. Bi-Metallic Investment Co. v. State Board of Equalization, 239 U.S. 441, 445 (1915). ↩︎