Skip to content

FREE SPEECH IN THE TRUMP ERA A Mixed-Methods Investigation of K-12 and University Faculty

Paper accepted for presentation at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association. Toronto, Ontario, Canada, April 4-9, 2019

Abstract

This paper presents the findings from a mixed-methods study conducted in the spring of 2018 investigating “speech controversies” in K-12 schools and university campuses since 2015. Data were collected in an online survey and through follow-up interviews with volunteers. Participants reported an increase in oppressive speech acts in their institutions and backlash for trying to advocate for marginalized students who are being targeted by right-wing political groups and initiatives. Participants experienced a variety of backlash and supports as a result of the reported incidents. Issues related to advocating for LGBTQ rights, immigrants, and people of color were prevalent and themes of fear and silencing were discussed. Implications for professional development, activism, and practice in the current political climate will be discussed.

Objectives

The past two years have been challenging ones in terms of freedom of expression-- particularly on college campuses and in K-12 schools. Since the 2016 presidential campaign there has been a rise in extreme viewpoints represented in mass media, in public spaces, on college campuses, and K-12 schools (Rogers, 2017; Southern Poverty Law Center, 2016). President Trump’s campaign modeled such expression and empowered many individuals who align with far right, anti-gay, anti-immigrant, and White supremacist ideologies. The increased visibility of such viewpoints emboldened individuals and organizations to act out in individual and collective acts of expression that resulted in many people feeling threatened, scared, at risk, and unsafe. There have been renewed debates about what constitutes “hate speech” and what sorts of expression can legally and ethically be limited on college campuses and in K-12 classrooms.

Recent research indicates that pre-service teachers have an under-developed knowledge of the First Amendment and its application in K-12 settings (Call & O’Brien, 2011). There have also been calls for faculty on campuses to be more active in responding to “low value speech” by “embracing honest disagreements” (Waltman, 2018), promoting “safety” and “dignity” in campus dialogue (Callan, 2016), as well as the pedagogical uses of anger (Mayo, 2016). This study aims to understand educators’ experiences with speech controversies in their educational contexts since 2015 and make recommendations for practice.

Theoretical Framework

This study is grounded in social justice (North, 2008) and anti-oppressive theories of education (Kumashiro, 2002) which argue that educational institutions should be actively working to address social inequalities and challenge oppression. As a result, educators who align with this viewpoint are called to take proactive steps in their pedagogy and practice to ensure students in their school communities have equitable access to learning and are fully supported and integrated in the educational community. This study seeks to gain an understanding of how educators who are invested in improving diversity and equity issues in their institutions experience the tensions that emerge between legal, ethical, and pedagogical perspectives when controversial speech acts occur. This analysis is informed by legal (McCarthy & Eckes, 2009; Warnick, 2009) and philosophical (Callan, 2016; Mayo, 2016) analyses of free speech and First Amendment issues in educational contexts. While the design of the study was to understand how educators respond when oppressive speech acts occurred in their classrooms, the data told a different story. Several of the incidents were actually about educators and campuses being surveilled and impacted by outside organizations (Liberty Council, Campus Reform, Fox News, Turning Point USA) and how progressive educators were scrutinized and required to defend their actions to their administration.

Methods & Data Sources

This paper draws from two primary data sources: an online survey and follow-up interviews with a sub-group of survey respondents. The survey invitation was distributed using email, Twitter, and Facebook. We also worked with Gay, Lesbian, and Straight Education Network and the American Association of University Professors to distribute the survey in their networks. The survey included 31 multiple-choice and open-ended questions and asked about a recent “controversy or challenging incident related to free speech at your institution” as well as educators’ experiences with this event and the context of their institution. Survey Data were collected between March 13, 2018 and May 30, 2018. As an exploratory survey, we were not seeking a large representative sample. We were using the survey to identify case studies of various incidents nationwide and recruit participants from diverse educational contexts to participate in the interview portion of the study.

The second data source includes interviews that were conducted with survey respondents who volunteered to complete a follow-up interview. 25 survey respondents agreed to be contacted and a total of 11 participants (3 K-12, 7 higher ed, 1 higher ed/K-12 hybrid) spoke with the research team about their experiences. We used a semi-structured interview protocol to learn more about the specific incidents, institutional contexts, and repercussions resulting from the incident. Interviews were conducted between May 1 and July 19, 2018 and were recorded and transcribed then read by two members of the research team to identify emerging themes and cases for deeper analysis.

Results

Results embargoed until presentation at the AERA annual meeting (April 4-9, 2019). Please contact the author if you’d like a copy of the paper after this date.

Significance

Social justice and anti-oppressive theories of education argue that for educators to be able to teach effectively, they must be able to take actions to promote educational equity and affirm the lives and experiences of all students in their curriculum. In our survey and interviews we found that K-12 teachers and university faculty were targeted for efforts they had made that aimed to support LGBTQ youth, immigrant youth, and students of color and design learning activities that teach and promote civic engagement. While most respondents reported that they had “some” or “strong” understanding of the First Amendment, they still reported experiencing fear and silencing as a result of these incidents. Our study indicates that K-12 teachers and university faculty are vulnerable to attacks from outside groups and they are often left on their own to navigate the repercussions of these incidents. School districts and universities need to do more to support educators teaching in these difficult times. Institutions can work with unions, community organizations (such as ACLU, GLSEN, AAUP) and other groups to ensure educators are informed of their First Amendment rights and responsibilities and should develop resources to support them when they come under attack for doing pedagogical work designed to support and strengthen democracy.

Works Cited

Call, I., & O’Brien, J. (2011). Secondary Preservice Teachers’ Knowledge of the First Amendment. Teacher Education Quarterly, 38(4), 115-133.

Callan, E. (2016). Education in Safe and Unsafe Spaces. Philosophical Inquiry in Education, 24(1), 64-78.

Kumashiro, K. (2002). Troubling education: Queer activism and antioppressive pedagogy. New York: Routledge Falmer.

Mayo, C. (2016). Anger and Pedagogy. Philosophical Inquiry in Education, 24(1), 86-90.

McCarthy, M., & Eckes, S. (2009). Silence in the Hallways: The impact of Garcette v. Ceballos on Public School Educators. Public Interest Law Journal, 17, 209‑235.

North, C. (2008). What is all this talk about “Social Justice”? Mapping the Terrain of Education’s Latest Catchphrase. Teachers College Record, 110(6), 1182‑1206.

Rogers, J., Franke, M. Yun, J.E., Ishimoto, M., Diera, C., Geller, R., Berryman, A., Brenes, T. (2017). Teaching and Learning in the Age of Trump: Increasing Stress and Hostility in America’s High Schools. Los Angeles, CA: UCLA’s Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access.

Southern Poverty Law Center. (2016). After Election Day: The Trump Effect // The Impact of the 2016 Presidential Election on our Nation’s Schools. Retrieved from Montgomery, AL: https://www.splcenter.org/sites/default/files/the_trump_effect.pdf

Waltman, M. S. (2018). The normalizing of hate speech and how communication educators should respond. Communication Education, 67(2), 259-265. doi:10.1080/03634523.2018.1430370

Warnick, B. R. (2009). Student Speech Rights and the Special Characteristics of the School Environment. Educational Researcher, 38(3), 200-215.