Skip to content

Political correctness, campus orthodoxy, and online free speech

*This includes previously unpublished work that was submitted after the publication deadline.

Late stage capitalism has greatly influenced free speech in America. The current form of free expression present on modern campuses and in the United States at-large is much closer to the British common law version of free speech governed by laws of libel. The key difference between the free speech speech practiced across the pond and the puritanical version that took root in America is the value of the truth. Libel laws protect the citizenry from speech that might cause violence. The parallel for contemporary America is the role of hate speech, while there are no official laws forbidding hate speech, the court of public opinion handles these cases. The issue with this lies with control over the definition of hate speech. To define hate speech in the court of public opinion creates many blurred lines. The recent Jussie Smollett incident demonstrates this. His manipulation of “hate speech” as the precursor to alleged violence was defined by the quote attributed to his alleged attackers “this is MAGA country”. The catchphrase of our sitting president is associated with literal violence for many within our country. Critique of Smollet from the left is that his act serves to undermine a legitimate cause of concern over the treatment of Black men and gays in America. The issue for the right is his willingness to potentially incite racial violence. Speech in and of itself cannot technically be a crime but statements serve as the precursor to an act of violence becoming a hate crime. In his speech at UC Irvine conservative commentator Dennis Prager declared that “there is a civil war in America” between the left and the right. Conservatives like Prager would contend that their viewpoints are policed through protest based on the grounds that the temperament in and of itself promotes hate. Campus protest though are also an act of free speech and college campuses have ensured to facilitate protest without technically impeding conservative speech. Conservative viewpoints are in reality marginal on campus and they only manifest with clandestine student groups and their invited speakers. The campuses are a left-wing orthodoxy which presents a problem because they are not representative of the diversity of opinion present in America.

The country by and large is 50% liberal and 50% conservative. There are many explanations for this glaring demographic disparity around the presence of vocal conservatvism on campus. This of course presents a slew of challenges, the most glaring of course being the reality that some portion of the conservative viewpoint is truthful. The unabashed truth seeking that has defined the American version of free speech has fallen to political correctness. The American version of free speech in its totality now only exists online. The truth has become secondary to maintaining homogeneity on campus. This is undoubtedly a product of the capitalist realism that has ensured that higher education is in principle a high priced commodity designed to produce uniformity. Political correctness policed by the populace plays the role of libel here in the states, and this is the reason why maligned students on campus are more interested in the ideas of internet thinkers than their own professors. Even if the students themselves disagree with many of the ideas espoused by these online luminaries, it is the reckless pursuit of the truth in a confused age that aligns these right leaning students with their digital teachers. This phenomena is a product of what Jordan Peterson characterizes as “the search for ideas moving online.” Internet forums are in effect the wild west for idea exploration and this manifest as unrestrained critical thinking. Free and critical thought doesn’t necessarily work as a commodity because it is not good for stability hence the restrictions that are enforced upon it, whether these restrictions are instatitated the government or the populace. The reason politically correct culture is more effective for capitalism than libel enforced by the state is that the populace themselves act in the interest of the plutocratic the ruling class. It is not in the best interest of neoliberal elite to foster critical thinking.

The enlightenment ideas that have served to define the western thought process for free speech only exist on paper and the “collision with error” based interpretation of speech that John Stuart Mill proscribed is a far cry from present reality. What we have is hardly a marketplace of ideas but instead conflict with no clear victor. Thought mavens use the internet to escape the ideological rules of the game. While some dissenting students initially bandied behind the Milo Yiannopoulos brand of shock jock opposition, this sort of trolling has died down while the more reasoned stance of the Prager types has managed to take hold of the conversation around political correctness on campus. Ben Shapiro is a good indicator for the views that are allowed on campus. He has had more innocuous appearances at Berkeley than controversial ones. The security requirements of his last visit to Berkeley, caused by raucous community members, did more to stir the Black and Brown students, faculty and employees on campus than the content of his message. Of course this is the reality of our contemporary political battle between the left and right. In line with what Malcolm X had said, the racial minorities in America are caught in the middle of ideological battles largely confined to white people. America’s minorities though should be aware of the larger cultural shifts taking place in America and the rest of the west for that matter. Racial minorities require this knowledge in order advocate for their own respective interest. While Jamaican, American philosopher Charles Mills misses the mark on how the enlightenment applied to racial minorities in the west, he is correct about the maladies of liberalism. The fruits of liberalism and the universalism it promotes have been few and far inbetween particularly for Black people. In spite of Audre Lorde’s lamentation though the tool of free speech did prove valuable to an extent for racial minorities gaining rights in the west, particularly during the Civil Rights Movement. The bend of the west though has taken on more class oriented forms of oppression predicted by French, Marxist philosopher Frantz Fanon. He said “what matters today, the issue which blocks the horizon, is the need for a redistribution of wealth.”

The contrasting point to the oligarchical nature of modern society is the class based revolt taking place on both sides of the aisle. The right has its populism and the left has its socialism. The rising tides of populism and the differing view on immigration are the most pressing issues being discussed but I fear the university is too blinded by orthodoxy to genuinely contend with these matters. Unfortunately academia has been corroded by insularity and the radical use of free speech in the American tradition is best upheld by comedians and other online artist. A few professors have been able to commit to performing in this manner by building an online audiences but I am weary of the predictions that the future of formal education is online. Online platforms are facing a complex battle considering the pressure they are receiving from the left and the right. This has caused many to call for government intervention in how these platforms are allowed to present information. It is important to consider the role that those that control the algorithms play in what is presented to us when we go on the internet. The course of our history has already been changed by how social media has influenced the way we interact with information. It is unclear going forward how this will continue to play out but platforms must allow free speech to flourish or risk exerting undue influence on politics and discourse.