Senior Legislative Counsel, Electronic Frontier Foundation
The most powerful impact of the internet has been its capacity to distribute knowledge and culture at virtually no costs to the speaker. This has dramatically enhanced speech, which in turn has empowered democracy by enabling even the smallest voice to have an impact on our political discourse. Many of the major debates we have today stem from individuals who previously would have absolutely no means of communicating to the public. In other words, online speech remains vital to a 21st century democracy.
In the era of mass media that preceded social media, only those in positions of power would have a voice to reach the public. These elite few traditionally came from the same backgrounds in education, wealth, and were often white. The internet democratized access to the public by giving every person this power. The distribution of power though has also enabled speakers of disfavored and unpopular content to share their ideas at scale. Our initial instincts reach for censorship of these speakers on the misunderstanding that suppressing ideas will force positive outcomes. In reality, democracy is built on openly confronting contradictory ideas in order for society to advance together.
Institutions, such as higher education, must foster an understanding of the value and importance of online speech including disfavored and unpopular speech. Often past disfavored speech becomes the majority opinion through debate. Sanitization of internet speech will only prevent this critical process, which in turn only serves to make us ignorant of our fellow citizens.