Skip to content

Berkeley Conservative Students, Milo Yiannopoulos, and the Far Right’s War Against the Liberal University in the Early Trump Era*

*This paper will be merged into one of the chapters of my forthcoming book American Student Protest and Free Speech in the 21st Century

UC Berkeley made national headlines in the early Trump era when on February 1, 2017 a riot instigated by masked Antifa invaders of the Berkeley campus did $100,000 in property damage to Cal’s student union building and forced the cancellation of a speaking engagement there by far right provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos. The media responded by focusing on the riot and the free speech violation it caused, but neglected to probe the transformation of right wing student politics at Berkeley that paved the way for the most serious free speech crisis and the worst political violence at Cal since the 1960s. This paper explores that transformation, assessing why the leadership of the Berkeley College Republicans and the staff of far right student publication The Berkeley Patriot proved so eager to welcome Yiannopoulos, antagonize liberal and left-leaning students, and to discredit the UC Berkeley administration itself.

Using right wing Berkeley student op-eds, social media posts, testimony in Cal’s free speech commission hearings, TV interviews, correspondence with the campus administration, and oral histories with UCB officials and faculty who interacted with these right wing student activists, this study documents a process of profound student alienation. While it has often been challenging being a conservative student in the liberal and left-leaning Berkeley milieu, Left-Right political tensions reached new heights in the fall 2016 presidential race. Though Donald Trump’s campaign polarized much of the nation, Trump’s xenophobic themes proved especially controversial on the Berkeley campus, with its high percentage of immigrant students and tradition of progressive politics – whose activists saw the campaign as a direct threat to Berkeley’s undocumented students and also viewed Trump’s embrace of the evangelical far right as a precursor to an assault on LGTBQ+ rights. Incidents of verbal abuse and even physical intimidation left Berkeley College Republican leaders alienated, viewing themselves as an oppressed minority, embittered from their classmates and the university – which they did not view as theirs. It was this bitterness, more than any free speech concerns that motivated their embrace of hateful far right speakers, beginning with Yiannopoulos.

This process of conservative student alienation was expedited by the support it received from the adult right wing off campus, whose own hostility to the university – demonized as a left wing cultural fifth column – was a regular feature of right wing media, most notably Fox News, and was shared by President Trump himself. Berkeley’s right wing student leaders found an eager, appreciative audience from conservative media outlets and quickly realized that gripes about the Berkeley administration, even if untrue, could lead to media celebrity. Funds from right wing sources, especially the wealthy Young America’s Foundation, paid lawyers to escalate campus political tensions into law suits against the university. False charges that the university administration sought to suppress conservative speech and coddle left wing disruptors were made repeatedly by right wing Berkeley students in connection with the controversial Berkeley speaking invitations of Yiannopoulos, Ann Coulter, and Ben Shapiro.

The paper also reveals that the far right student leaders who gloried in this politics of polarization and university-bashing constituted a very small group, not even representative of most Berkeley conservatives. This embittered faction would lose control of the Berkeley College Republican when its key leader was scorned as a troll and impeached in fall 2017. But until the political fever had broken, right wing student alienation together with the intolerance and violence of the far Left made Berkeley into a political war zone, embodying the worst of the tribalism wrought by the Trump era, doing considerable damage to the university’s reputation.