“FREE SPEECH IS WHO WE ARE” The University of California and the Struggle to Preserve Berkeley’s Free Speech Tradition in the Early Trump Era*
*This paper will be merged into one of the chapters of my forthcoming book American Student Protest and Free Speech in the 21st Century
The ascent of Donald Trump and his hyper-polarizing politics to the White House sparked at Berkeley the most serious free speech crisis since the Free Speech Movement of 1964. Emulating Trump’s nativism and liberal and Left-baiting, Berkeley’s right wing students invited to campus the most divisive far right speakers, beginning with the Islamophobe and anti-transgender troll Milo Yiannopoulos and later the extreme nativist Ann Coulter. These invitations inflamed the panicky far Left in the Bay Area, at a time when it was at its most chiliastic – viewing Trump’s authoritarian political style and Muslim travel ban as signaling that the US had entered its Germany 1933 moment when fascism loomed, necessitating the banning from campus of such far right bigots as Yiannopoulos so as to deny a university platform to purveyors of fascism. When the UC Berkeley administration insisted on free speech grounds that Yiannopoulos be allowed to speak on campus, a major Antifa (mostly non-student) riot ensued in February 2017, which did $100,000, in property damage on campus, more than $500,000 in property damage in downtown Berkeley, forcing the cancellation of the Yiannopoulos speech. This was only the start of months of heated controversy over free speech, in which Left and Right feuded, and the media and the White House bashed the UC Berkeley administration despite the fact that its leaders persisted against all odds in preserving Berkeley’s free speech tradition.
Grounded in student sources, testimony from the Berkeley chancellor’s Free Speech Commission, local and national media coverage, social media, police reports, and oral history interviews with UC Berkeley officials, including both chancellors who set policy for the campus, this paper offers the first historical account that goes beyond the headlines to explore how the UC Berkeley administration navigated these months of political crises. The study also raises important free speech questions that emerged from these months of conflict at Berkeley, most notably what higher educational leaders are to do when their legal and moral obligations to uphold the First Amendment and free speech conflict with university’s educational mission. Indeed, the months of tumultuous conflict over the invitations and appearance of far right speakers, with their assaultive rhetoric and bigotry, left many students disillusioned with what they saw as UC’s free speech absolutism that resulted in building closures, police invasions of the campus, and academic class cancellations over security concerns. Many students at Cal came to loathe all this as a “political circus” that disrupted their education for the sake of crude and cruel speakers who lacked educational value, a disruption that seemed to them all the more irritating in that it was largely ignored by the media. This student view was worlds away from the media fixation on and insistence that the university be open to all speakers regardless of how loathsome students found them or how the protests and security wrought by unpopular speakers impacted the university and its academic mission.