“Free Speech Is Who We Are”: The University of California and the Struggle to Preserve Berkeley’s Free Speech Tradition in the Trump Era
It is no accident that the most serious free speech crisis at UC Berkeley in more than a half century exploded less than two weeks after the start of the Trump presidency. I am referring, of course, to the disgraceful antifa riot on the night of February 1, 2017 that did more than $100,000 in property damage to the Berkeley student union building, preventing the bigoted, foul mouthed, far right provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos from speaking there.1 Lefists, liberals, and conservatives in Berkeley who see eye to eye on little else do agree that this violence wrought by a coordinated force of some 150 club-wielding, masked, black clad antifas, would not have even been imaginable had it not been for the extreme political polarization unleashed by Trump.2
Donald Trump’s openly nativist, Islamophobic, white nationalist presidential campaign, his authoritarian political style, and his late January ban on Muslim immigrants emboldened the far right, legitimated the alt right, sending the far Left into a panic. This left antifa acting as if America was in its Germany 1933 moment, on the verge of going fascist. And so “by any means necessary” fascistic speakers like Yiannopoulos (linked to Trump via the white nationalist alt right Breitbart News publication where Yiannopoulos had been a protégé of Steve Bannon, Trump’s campaign manager and strategist), had to be denied a platform from which to spread hatred and bigotry. All the more so since it was rumored that Yiannopoulos intended to out undocumented immigrant students at Berkeley just as he had harassed and mocked from the podium a transgender student at the University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, whose image he had projected in the lecture hall and on Breitbart’s website.3 This was a moment when the far left and far right fed off each other in their frenzied politics of hatred and demonization as the bigoted and newly empowered Trump administration set off an almost incredible wave of political tension and turmoil.
Of course campus free speech disputes and violations did not begin with Trump; they have been present throughout the history of American higher education. For much of the 20th century these violations were visited primarily upon the Left by anti-radical university and college administrators.4 It has only been since the closing decades of the 20th century that such violations began impacting those on the right, who ran afoul of overly broad (and unconstitutional) campus speech codes, with their hate speech restrictions.5 But even these violations were almost exclusively non-violent and on individual campuses small scale, compared to the major riot that disrupted Yiannoupolos’ speaking engagement at Berkeley last year at the dawn of the Trump era.6
Most commentators on that riot noted the irony that this massive free speech violation occurred at UC Berkeley since Cal was the birthplace of the most famous and victorious student-led struggle for free speech in all of American history, the Berkeley Free Speech Movement of 1964, which established the principle that the university must not restrict the political content of speech or advocacy on campus. Yes, that Berkeley was the site of an anti-free speech riot was indeed ironic. But it is simplistic and inaccurate to read the anti-Yiannopoulos riot – as it was by Trump, Fox News and rightwing critics both in Berkeley and nationally – as evidence that UC Berkeley had committed a free speech violation, abandoning its vaunted free speech tradition.7 The riotous free speech violation, after all, had been caused by violent and mostly non-student militants who invaded the campus not by the university itself (though the rioters were masked, the campus police and other eyewitnesses noted that most did not know their way around the Berkeley campus and neither looked nor acted like students or members of the campus community. Only 1 or 2 out of the 150 or so rioters have been identified as Cal students).8 So the Berkeley-bashing response of right wingers to the riot, epitomized by Donald Trump’s demagogic tweet suggesting that, since UC Berkeley did not support free speech and promoted violence against dissenters, its federal funds should be cut off, was a blatant case of blaming (and threatening!) the victim.9
In fact, the UC Berkeley administration consistently stood up for free speech, refusing to accede to demands from the Left that Yiannopoulos’ speech be cancelled. Had it not been for the riot, which UC Berkeley’s administration condemned, the speech would have taken place.10 It was only after the riot erupted and public safety was endangered that UC Berkeley reluctantly cancelled the event. Actually, the administration of UC Berkeley Chancellor Nicholas Dirks (which ended at the close of the 2017 academic year) and his successor Carol Christ (whose chancellorship began at the start of the 2017-18 academic year) would make the preservation of Berkeley’s free speech tradition a top priority, spending millions of dollars for security (despite Cal’s budget crisis and deficit) to ensure that right wing speakers could be heard on campus and that the February riot was not repeated. Indeed, Christ declared that her first year as chancellor would be “Free Speech Year” at Berkeley –complete with forums on campus free speech controversies, and speakers from all parts of the political spectrum -- because free speech was “who we are” at Berkeley.11 This deep commitment to free speech and willingness to foot astronomical bills for security to protect unpopular speakers made it possible not only for Yiannopoulos to experience a peaceful return to Berkeley in fall 2017, but also for other controversial rightwing speakers, including Ann Coulter and Ben Shapiro, to be accommodated for campus speaking engagements so long as they agreed to speak at a time and location where campus police could assure that their speaking events could occur safely (which Shapiro did and Coulter did not).12
Much as the political polarization of the Trump era makes it a challenge to protect the free speech tradition at Berkeley, it also makes it difficult to reach a consensus across the ideological spectrum on the state of that free speech tradition.
As intimated earlier, if you think about it objectively, the fact that in the first year of the Trump era UC Berkeley administrations spent millions of dollars on security, brought in an army of police, and endured denunciation from the far Left all to enable right wing speakers to hold public events on the Berkeley campus, you’d have to say the university’s free speech tradition is alive, well, and upheld vigorously by UC’s leadership.13 Yet this is not the way Trump supporters and others on the right see things. Hostile to the liberal university, which they view as a site of political correctness and leftwing indoctrination, they see UC Berkeley as complicit with those on the far Left who seek to suppress right wing speech on campus.14
Perhaps the most striking example of this Berkeley-bashing narrative was the right wing media suggestion in February 2017 that Berkeley officials coddled the anti- Yiannopoulos rioters. The rightwing media popularized the claim that during the riot the Berkeley campus police were issued a “stand down” order, and supposedly cowered in the student union building rather than go out on the plaza to confront and arrest the rioters. This claim, which provoked a flood of irate e-mails to UC Berkeley Campus Police Chief Margo Bennett, was not merely untrue, but ludicrous. There was no stand down order. Outnumbered and taken by surprise by the startling and unprecedented invasion of the campus by a disciplined para-military force, the police’s mission was to save lives, defend the building the antifas were besieging and protect those inside of it, including the speaker, Milo Yiannopoulos. Since the antifas had embedded themselves in the crowd of non-violent protesters on the plaza, there was no way for the police to have waded into the crowd to make mass arrests without risking serious injury to innocent students outside since bloody confrontations between club-wielding antifas and the police would have certainly occurred had the police opted to prioritize arrests. The reality, according to Chief Bennett, was that the police acted in a disciplined way to prevent the antifas from entering and destroying the student union building and harming Yiannopoulos, his entourage, and student hosts.15 But this went unnoticed by right wing media so eager to bash Berkeley’s liberalism that it made even the Berkeley campus police out to be coddlers of radicals who supposedly would not stand up to leftwing forces of political disruption and intolerance.
Just how crazily inaccurate was Trump’s tweet alleging that UC Berkeley suppressed free speech and fomented violence against dissenters can best be seen via the experience of Chancellor Dirks the night of the riot. Dirks’s strong free speech position had made him such an object of scorn among the antifa rioters (since in their view he had provided a platform of the hateful fascist speaker whose event they would riot to shut down) that campus police – concerned about his safety – advised him not to go to Sproul Plaza, where he could easily have been a target for physical attack. And once the rioters had forced the shutting down of the Yiannopoulos speech, reports came in to the police that they were planning to besiege Chancellor Dirks’s residence on campus – leading the police to suggest he be ready to evacuate his residence.
Indeed, after word of that threat from the rioters, police came to Dirks’ residence in case the evacuation was necessary. It was only because the rioters (as mostly non-students) were unfamiliar with the campus and so did not know where the chancellor’s home --University House – was located that such a siege was avoided, and they diverted to California Hall. There the presence of the Oakland Police, who UC had been called in under mutual aid, finally drove the rioters from the campus.
Having been so demonized and threatened by these violent militants for defending free speech, it was positively surreal for Dirks the next morning to read that tweet of the President of the United States charging the university Dirks led with repressing free speech and instigating violence for such repression. Trump’s tweet read: “If U.C. Berkeley does not allow free speech and practices violence on innocent people with a different point of view – NO FEDERAL FUNDS?”16 For Dirks that absurdly inaccurate and slanderous Trump tweet, as well as the Fox News broadcast’s equally misleading condemnation of the university for “repressing conservative thought,” constituted “a kind of window on to our current political reality, which is that truth is not relevant… But it was stark, and it was quick, and it was dramatic.”17 Nils Gilman, Dirks’s chief of staff, was also appalled at the right wing media’s distortion of the events at UC Berkeley, recalling that even though the university administration had championed free speech and only cancelled the talk when the riot put lives at risk, “it was very hard to put that message through because of a huge element of bad faith in much of what gets called reporting on the Right – where the goal is to throw shit at the liberals. And they do that any way they can. And one way to do that was to “conflate” the rioters “with” the “university ... [and its] administration.”18
Even mainstream TV news reporting failed to explain the dynamics of the riot scene itself, leaving the impression that university authorities, including the campus police, had been passive in the face of a violent mob because police had been unable to stop the riot or make mass arrests at the riot scene. Viewers did not understand how unprecedented and dangerous was this invasion of the campus by a large disciplined force of rioters, armed with clubs and incendiary devices. Nor was it reported that the university had called in the Oakland Police for reinforcements. This “pretty poor media coverage,” according to University spokesperson Dan Moguloff, left many people angry at Cal, based on either incomplete or distorted news reports. For many of the people who wrote angry messages to UC officials, Mogulof explains, “it seemed all so simple. ‘Arrest those people. What the hell were you doing?’ But no one stopped to consider if we had enough police officers. If what happened was unprecedented and took us by surprise, etc., etc. As covered by the media it all seemed so simple. We had police officers. These bad guys came. They tried to disrupt [the speaking event] and nothing happened [to them, so] they were able to shut the event down. The University must have been somehow complicit or negligent. It was extraordinarily frustrating.”19
Chancellor Dirks did not have to wait long to see how the combination of such incomplete, misleading media coverage and Trump’s hostile tweet had hurt the university’s reputation. “When you follow my Twitter feed after the February 1st event” you are immediately struck by “the amount of hate. People calling up... with no particular connection to Berkeley, they were screaming at my assistant ‘You’ve suppressed freedom of speech, You’ve suppressed freedom of speech’… The mainstream media… by careless reporting … reinforced the notion that free speech had been endangered” by the university itself.20 “We can’t control Breitbart, we can’t control Fox, we can’t control Trump, but The New York Times” should get the story right. Thus Dirks wrote to Times expressing “regret that” its reportage did not make clear that “my administration … went to extraordinary lengths to facilitate planning and preparation for” the Yiannopoulos event, and cancelled it “only after determining that both the speaker’s and the public’s safety was highly endangered” after the campus “was invaded by more than 100 armed people in masks and dark uniforms who used paramilitary tactics to engage in violent destructive behavior intended to shut down the event.” 21
While the national media’s poor reportage was a major concern, Dirks was also alarmed by a disturbing trend in the media closer to home. Several students, alumni, and community members published op-eds in UC Berkeley’s student newspaper, the Daily Californian, the week following the riot, defending the antifas’ use of violence to shut down the Yiannopoulos speaking event. Although the authors of these defenses of violence represented only a small Left fringe on campus, Dirks felt strongly that such illiberal expressions and endorsements of left wing vigilanteism had to be challenged – and he did so in an op-ed he published in The Daily Californian. Dirks wrote that he was “horrified by the call to embrace the use of violence to contest views with which we may disagree. Even if one believes that Yiannopoulos’ speech might potentially have constituted some form of verbal violence, meeting this threat with actual physical violence is antithetical to what we, as a community dedicated to open inquiry, must do and stand for. Physical violence has absolutely no place on our campus…. In our present political moment, we need more than ever to cleave to the laws that protect our fundamental rights. The First Amendment is unequivocal in its almost unfettered protection of speech with which many might disagree…. We cannot support free speech selectively….”22
Dirks was, of course, justified in his concerns. It was shocking to see pro-violence opinions being expressed in the student newspaper. The arguments offered in defense of violence centered, as Dirks implied, on a false equivalence between Yiannopoulos’s alleged verbal violence and actual physical violence. The op-eds all cited an unverified rumor that Yiannopoulos planned to out undocumented students at Berkeley, much as he had cruelly mocked and singled out a transgender student in his appearance at the University of Wisconsin at Milwaukee. This would endanger undocumented students at Cal, so in the words of one of these antifa supporters, “this is violence. If I know that you are planning to attack me, I’ll do all I can to throw the first punch.”23 Such hate speech should, they argued, be banned from the campus and since the university administration was too timid to do so the community had a right to defend itself. “These were not acts of violence,” explained the only Cal student who admitted to being a one of the rioters, “they were acts of self-defense… No one will protect us? We will protect ourselves.”24 The idea being that liberals such as Dirks lacked the courage to stand up to fascists, leaving it to the more resilient and clear-headed radical Left to defend the besieged Berkeley community from the fascist threat.
With any reflection at all, such arguments defending political vigilanteism and censorship essentially refute themselves. If expressing views that can potentially lead to violence should be banned, as these op-eds assumed, then of course, these very op-eds ought to have been banned since they actually advocated violence. If Yiannopoulos and his supporters wanted to out undocumented students they could have done so quite efficiently and easily in private by naming and turning them into ICE – there was no need to do so from the podium. Had Yiannopoulos sought to pull such a political stunt in his speech at Berkeley he’d have undoubtedly been heckled or booed off the stage, so there was no need for actual physical violence. And if his far right supporters doxed or physically threatened Cal students of color or transgender students they could be prosecuted. These justifications for violence, then, are – to put it mildly - lacking in logic, but they do attest that the small but vocal far Left at Berkeley could and did welcome violence to stifle the free speech of the far right.
Most Berkeley students, according to Cal Democrats activist David Olin, rejected such arguments and the violence itself. The riot, in Olin’s words, “was the result of a fringe and frankly ridiculous group of people who acted violently.”25 Berkeley student government president William Morrow agreed, and charged that rioters “with their faces masked and weapons in their hands are not coming to make history – they are coming to create chaos”26
There is no question, moreover, that most Berkeley students opposed banning speakers on the basis of their political beliefs. In fact, a survey of incoming students at Cal in fall 2017 found that “three-quarters of them agree that ‘the University has a responsibility to provide equal access to safe and secure venues for guest speakers of all viewpoints – even if the ideas are found offensive by some or conflict with the values held by the UC Berkeley community.”27
This does not mean, however, that many of Berkeley’s 40,000 students thought that the Berkeley College Republicans behaved responsibly in inviting Yiannopoulos to campus. Yiannopoulos seemed to many students barren of serious political ideas, and a troll whose rhetoric was crude and cruel. And that he’d been invited because the BCR was seeking publicity not for any genuine educational value. There was a huge contradiction between the way students had been educated since grade school not to bully, not to act in a bigoted way, and Yiannopoulos’ trolling, in which he used bigoted discourse and bullied vulnerable minorities.28 “You can,” explained Cal spokesperson Dan Mogulof, “understand the students’ dismay and confusion when here we are spending millions of dollars to protect and support speakers who engage in [abusive] rhetoric that if students engaged[in] in their residence halls they’d be hauled up on student conduct charges or certainly [would have been punished for using such rhetoric] on their high school playgrounds.”29 Chancellor Dirks agrees: “It’s a terrible inconsistency. Real tensions… exist between the [university’s] values of inclusion and the values of free speech. I think for kids it is a genuine confusion. The truth is that students by virtue of being… member[s] of a student community are often constrained in ways that outside people are not… They are subject to student [conduct] codes. Students for saying things can be held accountable by the rules of student conduct that actually are not about freedom of speech because they’re community values.”30
What this meant was that many students felt that Yiannopoulos’ cruel bullying made him a terrible choice for a campus speaker. And that no good could come of his coming to Cal, especially in light of the disruptions and violence that his abusive speaking engagements had already wrought on his national campus tour. That is why, as Mogulof put it, the “center of gravity” in student opinion “was dismay and disbelief that there wasn’t some way to keep” speakers like Yiannopoulos “off campus. Not because they were conservative but because they were so assaultive in their rhetoric.” Even when told by the law school dean that the First Amendment left Cal with no choice but to open its campus to Yiannopoulos many students remained dissatisfied -- since the far right speaker’s abusive behavior seemed beyond the pale in an educational community.
Such views were only reinforced by the riot and subsequent police invasions of campus to protect far right speakers – which seemed to convert Cal into a political war zone, leaving students alienated, and, in Mogulof’s words, feeling “This is not why we’re here,” that they’d come to Berkeley for an education not a political circus.31 This is likely why some students were glad the Yiannopoulos speech was ultimately cancelled, and why an activist minority of students, at the riot scene, though themselves non-violent, welcomed the antifas’ disruption of the Yiannopoulos event.
Thus it was Dirks and the university administration not the student body that was completely consistent in its support of the First Amendment and the Berkeley free speech tradition, in insisting that Cal be open to all, even an immensely unpopular far right troll. Nonetheless, along with its president and media arm, the American right wing’s richly endowed foundation world embraced the false narrative of UC Berkeley as a university that suppresses conservative speech. The Young America’s Foundation (worth $59 million)32 is the key actor in this regard; it has filed two law suits (the first of which was thrown out) charging that the university ’s major events policy – adopted in the wake of the February riot – discriminates against conservative speakers.33 This policy, for the sake of security and to avoid a repeat of the riot, requires that major campus events that the police determine pose a security risk be held at times and in campus locations in which the police can provide adequate protection. The YAF has been joined in this law suit by Attorney General Jeff Sessions and the Trump administration’s Justice department.34 Of course we leave it to the courts to judge the merits of this suit. But it seems ironic that a university that has spent millions and devoted endless staff time providing right wing speakers access to the campus is nonetheless being depicted as repressive, and dragged into court for allegedly discriminating against right wing speakers.
Hostile to the liberal university, the YAF appears interested not in resolving free speech problems but exaggerating them so as to harass the university, sue it, and place it in the most negative light possible. For example, in July 2017 the Berkeley College Republicans were seeking a venue for the campus appearance of conservative writer Ben Shapiro who they planned to host in mid-September. When the College Republicans were initially notified via e-mail that no venue was available for Shapiro on the date and time they requested, the YAF jumped to the conclusion that UC had cancelled this event, and so issued a press release “Berkeley Blocks Ben Shapiro,” with the YAF author of this press release condemning the university for its “disregard of the first amendment rights of its students.”35 But on the day of this press release, UC Berkeley spokesperson Dan Mogulof made it clear that the university had no intention of cancelling Shapiro’s talk. Mogulof told the Daily Californian: “We believe there should be no trouble getting an event scheduled on that day… We completely support the BCR.” Mogoluf added that BCR and campus administrators had yet to meet in person to discuss the event. “We need to meet with them,” Mogulof said.36
Let’s reflect for a moment on the evidence I’ve just alluded to. It was July 2017, TWO WHOLE MONTHS before the planned date of the Ben Shapiro event. The Berkeley College Republicans had just filed their initial room reservation request and had not even met yet with the administration to discuss the Shapiro event. Yet here we have an outside entity, a right wing foundation, inserting itself into a UC room request matter as if there was some civil liberties emergency, issuing an alarmist press release accusing the university of cancelling an event that it had not actually cancelled, and “disregarding “the constitutional rights” of conservative students. Actually there are more than 1,100 student organizations at Berkeley, very few large lecture halls available for student group-sponsored speakers (because those halls are usually monopolized by academic classes), and so there is lots of competition for available space, especially in the early fall. It was a space shortage not a university conspiracy against conservative student rights that led to the failed room request. And in fact, it was quite true that none of the rooms usually used for large student-sponsored events were available on the date requested for the Shapiro event. But as UC Berkeley spokesperson Mogulof indicated, the administration would meet with the BCR and work on finding a way to have Shapiro speak despite the room problem. The result was that by taking the extraordinary step of making Zellerbach Hall, a concert hall not ordinarily used for student-invited speakers, available for the Shapiro talk, covering much of the cost of using the hall, providing added security, including masses of police and the closure of six nearby campus buildings, the university made it possible for the Shapiro event to be held in September.37
Indeed, the Berkeley administration was so accommodating to the BCR on its Shapiro event (and subsequent right wing speakers at Cal) that students outside the BCR complained that it was receiving privileged treatment that no other Berkeley student group received. The Daily Californian found it outrageous that Chancellor Christ had decided to “pay the Zellerbach Hall rent for the Shapiro event..to prove campus was open to conservative thought…. BCR had only to whine, and its event was funded. For other student groups, room reservations, and their costs, and PR are their responsibility… Right wing student groups are receiving unprecedented deadline extensions and subsidies.”38 In light of this favoritism towards the BCR, the Daily Californian thought it extraordinarily dishonest that the “BCR had clung to a victim narrative” of itself as being treated unfairly by Cal.39
It is difficult to avoid the conclusion that the YAF was seeking to manufacture a free speech conflict, judging by the way it issued its wildly inaccurate accusation against the university, depicting Berkeley as seeking to cancel Shapiro when UC was in fact about to take extraordinary steps to expedite Shapiro’s appearance on campus. This behavior by YAF in the Shapiro case was by no means unique. It has become very common for the American right wing to provoke, manufacture, and exaggerate campus free speech disputes for the sake of the publicity this elicits. Not just right wing news outlets, but mainstream media is attracted to conservative claims of free speech violations by the liberal university, especially by Berkeley, famed as it is as the birthplace of the Free Speech Movement, since this makes for a dramatic story that feeds in with the popular trope of university political correctness and liberal hypocrisy.
This kind of manufactured free speech dust up can best understood as a free speech hustle – the intentional use of a phony civil liberties issue to harass and discredit the liberal university, while garnering a great wave of publicity to right wingers posing as free speech martyrs. And with regard to Berkeley in the Trump era, the YAF’s alarmist nonsense on the Shapiro events was not its first but its second Trump era hustle. The first came back in April 2017 and occurred in connection with an invitation for Ann Coulter to appear on the Berkeley campus late that month. One might say that the first element of a free speech hustle is finding a speaker to invite to campus whose rhetoric is so assaultive and degrading to students of color or other vulnerable minorities that it sparks outrage and calls for cancellation. Yiannopoulos himself, with his nativism, transphobia, misogyny, and racism, is a prime example of this kind of speaker.40 Ann Coulter, famed for her crude nativism and demonization of Latinos also qualifies, especially in a campus community like Berkeley, which not only has a sizable Latino presence but undocumented immigrant students feeling especially vulnerable in the wake of Trump’s deportation offensive.41 Inviting Coulter to campus in the wake of the Yiannopoulos riot seemed a sure path to political conflict and potential free speech martyrdom, bringing a PR bonanza for the YAF and the campus right wing. The YAF was involved in the Coulter affair at Berkeley from the start, agreeing to cover most of her $20,000 speaking fee.
With the Coulter affair it was not merely the YAF, but Berkeley College Republican leaders who sought to embrace and enhance the right wing narrative of Cal as a politically intolerant university. These right wing students, without having reserved a room or notified the UCB administration, announced publicly in late March 2017 that they had invited Ann Coulter to speak at Berkeley in late April and that she would be speaking on the issue of immigration. It turned out that no room large enough, or according to UCB police, secure enough, could be found that could accommodate a Coulter event on the date announced by her student hosts. When the UCB administration pointed this out and suggested that Coulter appear on campus in the fall, the BCR condemned the university for “cancelling” the campus appearance of this prominent conservative. This charge was echoed widely in the right wing and mainstream media, though in fact a Coulter speech had never been officially scheduled so it was not accurate to say that it had been cancelled.42
Here the campus right, by failing to consult with university officials, and falsely claiming that Coulter was scheduled to appear and then suppressed by UC Berkeley, had manufactured a free speech dispute out of whole cloth. As Nils Gilman, chief of staff to chancellor Dirks explains, “After the anti-Milo riot the BCR and their right wing allies and sponsors wanted to be seen as being shut down” by the liberal university. The Coulter affair was a “total set up…. What Coulter did was ridiculous. She says ‘Oh, I’ve been invited. And I’m coming on’ the date her rightwing student hosts had named. All of a sudden we’re morally obligated to offer her a spot on that day. What? That’s not how it works. We’re perfectly willing to accommodate you coming to campus but, given the jacked up nature of the political environment in the wake of Trump’s election and the riot in February, we’re going to do it in circumstances where we can guarantee the safety of the event. They were refusing to tell us what their plans were so we couldn’t approve them. They said ‘you’re not approving us. Therefore you’re cancelling us.’ I mean the whole thing was bad faith from top to bottom.”43
The media neglected the real story of how this phony free speech conflict was engineered, and after buying Coulter’s claims of being shut down, generated a political storm so severe that the UC Berkeley administration scurried to find a closer alternative date, and proposed that Coulter appear only one week after the date targeted by the BCR, during the study week (known as “dead week”) before finals in May.44 This offer was rejected by Coulter, a publicity hound, basking in her moment of big media play as a supposed free speech martyr barred from Berkeley.45
Coulter depicted the changed date for her campus appearance as an attempt to stifle conservative speech. And in support of this bogus claim she tweeted – what to anyone who attended Cal knew to be utter nonsense – that she was refusing to speak on campus during dead week “BECAUSE THERE ARE NO CLASSES,”46 suggesting that students were no longer on campus that week. But in fact, the Berkeley campus during dead week is packed with students studying for final exams. And since they are on campus and with no classes, interested students would have more time and opportunity to attend her talk than when classes were in session.47
Coulter also mocked university concerns about public safety as just an excuse to put her off because she was a conservative speaker – ignoring the fact that, as chancellor Dirks explained, “we were receiving mounting threats of violence around the [Coulter] event… Anarchists and anti-fascists openly threatened to prevent Ms. Coulter’s talk ‘by any means necessary.’ Right-wing groups threatened to appear on campus armed to ensure the opposite…”48 Yet Coulter suggested she would simply appear on the appointed day and speak on Sproul Plaza, which of course would be much more difficult than a secure building for the police to protect. In response to her public statements, campus officials said that extra police would be on hand (and they were) to provide security should Coulter make good on her word about speaking on the Plaza.49 But Coulter failed to appear on Sproul as there was no need for that since she’d already gotten what she wanted from Berkeley: free publicity and an underserved claim to free speech martyrdom. She also lied about why she never showed up, falsely claiming that the university had told her it could not offer her protection if she came to campus.50
The YAF’s response to the Coulter affair was to file two law suits against the university. These suits charged that UC’s delaying of her speech under the emerging major events policy represented an unconstitutional attempt to suppress conservative speech. This claim attracted little support on campus. Indeed, out of Cal’s 1,000 plus student groups precisely ONE, the Berkeley College Republicans joined the YAF in this law suit.51
But neither Coulter nor the YAF foundation could match the level of deviousness and publicity hounding that Milo Yiannopoulos displayed in his free speech hustle at Berkeley during fall semester, 2017. As we have seen, back in February Yiannopoulos had been a genuine (though hardly an innocent) victim of a horrific free speech violation when the antifa riot led to the cancellation of his Berkeley campus speech. Yiannopoulos stated in the wake of the riot that he
would return to Berkeley to exercise his free speech rights on behalf of campus conservatives. His determination to return to the political stage at Berkeley was made all the more acute by his fall from grace among conservatives nationally caused by his pedophilia scandal (when he was caught on tape joking about pedophilia and mocking the whole idea of an age of consent for sex between adults and minors), which had cost him his job at Breitbart news, his major book contract, and his opportunity to speak at the American Conservative Union convention.52 Clearly he hoped to use Berkeley, the scene of his greatest political splash nationally, to restore his political celebrity.
Yiannopoulos conned both his conservative student hosts – this time it was the tiny staff of the Berkeley Patriot, a fledging right wing on-line student publication – and the university administration – into believing he was going to not merely appear at Berkeley in late September 2017 but preside over what he called “Free Speech Week,” with a range of stars of the American right, including Steve Bannon, Ann Coulter, and Charles Murray. But it turned out that Yiannopoulos was lying. Neither these nor other prominent speakers he’d named had ever agreed to appear with him at Berkeley. Charles Murray explained that the very idea of his speaking at such an event with Yiannopoulos was absurd: “I would never under any circumstances appear at an event that included Milo Yiannopoulos… because he is a despicable asshole.”53 And even less prominent speakers who Yiannopoulos had contacted, such as right wing editor Lucian Wintrich, dropped out when they realized Yiannopoulos never intended to follow through with Free Speech week. According to Wintrich, Yiannopoulos and his company knew the week before Free Speech Week that “they didn’t intend to actually go through with it. Wintrich learned that it was “a set-up from the get-go.54”
This pattern of deception eventually alienated even some of Yiannopoulos’ right wing student hosts on the Berkeley Patriot, who shortly before the Free Speech Week debacle withdrew their speaking invitation from Yiannopoulos.55 He declared that he would speak at Berkeley anyway, but on the day of his appearance, protected by an army of police, Yiannopoulos spoke for only a few minutes, said a prayer, sung the national anthem and left before much of a crowd could even assemble. University spokesperson Mogulof aptly termed this brief Milo appearance at Berkeley, made possible by the costly ($800,000) police presence, “the most expensive photo-op” in Cal’s history. Yiannopoulos later claimed that he left in haste because the campus police had told him his safety could not be assured. But that too was a lie. Every moment of his time on Sproul Plaza was videotaped and in that time no police officer spoke with him.56
This was one of the rare instances where the free speech hustle backfired on right-wingers. Yiannopoulos apparently expected and hoped that Berkeley militants would disrupt his speech or that UC would bar him so he could play the free speech martyr. Therefore there was no need to follow through on the elaborate and mostly fictitious list of speakers he had misled his student sponsors, the university administration, and the public into believing he would bring to Berkeley. Yiannopoulos’ mindset on the eve of his so called ‘Free Speech Week’ can be gleaned from the interview he gave to Playboy in which he said, “I believe the challenge for us is to create something so attention-grabbing that it produces another UC Berkeley [meaning a repeat of the riot back in February 2017] and I can sell 100,000 copies of the book [he’d recently published].” And referring to his “Free Speech week” at Cal, he added, “Hopefully, God smiles on us and Antifa comes out and fire-bombs the entire university.”57
But God did not smile on Yiannopoulos because at his Berkeley appearance, as at Ben Shapiro’s, an army of police kept the peace and there was no riot. This was because Chancellor Christ spared no expense to ensure that even a speaker as widely reviled on the Berkeley campus as Yiannopoulos must be allowed to speak there. Christ did so because she was determined to preserve UC Berkeley’s free speech tradition, undo the damage done to the university’s reputation by the riot on campus back in February, and disrupt the false narrative offered by Fox News and the other right wing voices that Berkeley was an intolerant university that shut down conservative speakers. Thanks to Christ, Berkeley’s free speech tradition prevailed and Yiannopoulos was given the opportunity and freedom of speech to reveal that behind the image of a free speech martyr was as a deceptive, narcissistic troll with no respect for the university or even his right wing student hosts. Essentially the chancellor had given Yiannopoulos enough rope to hang himself morally and politically, which is what he did.
On free speech grounds, then, chancellor Christ performed brilliantly in her handling of both Yiannopoulos’ “free speech” debacle and the Ben Shapiro event. In both cases she had shown that the university was deeply committed to First Amendment principles and that neither far Left rioters or far right trolls were going to be allowed to undermine that commitment. Given the national media obsession with free speech on campus and the pervasive criticism of universities by not only the media but alumni and politicians for failing to stand up for free speech principles, Christ as the chancellor of the university famed for its iconic Free Speech Movement had little choice but to take this strong free speech stand to prove that Berkeley’s free speech tradition endured even in the Trump era. Her free speech stance also reflected Christ’s personal commitment to liberty as a literary scholar of Victorian England and an ardent admirer of that era’s virtual patron saint of freedom of speech John Stuart Mill.58
Admirable as Christ’s free speech stance and free speech victory were, they were both quite costly. Costly not only with regard to the millions of dollars spent – at a time of tight budgets59 – to protect these right wing speakers but also with regard to student and faculty alienation. There was considerable student and faculty dissent on the chancellor’s decision both to open the campus to these speakers – particularly Yiannopoulos who was widely viewed as a mean spirited bigot and self-promoting troll, who spewed hate speech, and cruelly harassed individual students from the podium – and to spend lavishly on security for them.60 On a First Amendment basis one can say, that Christ chose what was right rather than what would have been popular with segments of the Berkeley campus Left that did not so highly value free speech. Indeed, in terms of the national conversation on the First Amendment – and the op-eds that pervaded the national media Christ must be seen as a highly effective free speech champion who refused to bow to those who would curtail First Amendment rights on campus under the guise of stifling hate speech -- and that this triumph of liberty was well worth the cost Christ paid in dollars for security and in criticism from the Left for tolerating hate speech.
But there is a whole other realm of problems with Christ’s bold free speech stance that has been missed by most of the national news media, whose coverage of the Berkeley free speech crisis centered so much on the First Amendment –and the hate speech vs free speech conflict -- that it largely ignored the university’s educational mission. Christ was under so much pressure from the media, politicians, alumni, university counsel, the president of the University of California system, and her own free speech principles to maintain Berkeley’s free speech tradition that she had little opportunity initially to focus upon the educational implications of her actions. Similarly, there has been such a media obsession with protecting First Amendment freedoms on campus that one almost never hears anyone pointing out that when those freedoms are exercised on campuses they must be done in ways that do not interfere with the university’s educational mission. Though right wingers seeking to weaponize the First Amendment to attack the liberal university have cited the Free Speech Movement in justifying the notion that the university must accommodate vastly unpopular speakers any time and place conservatives chose for them, they forget that the free speech victory that Berkeley’s Free Speech Movement won melded political liberty with order. The Berkeley Academic Senate’s historic December 8, 1964 resolutions that codified that victory barred the university from restricting the content of political speech or advocacy, but also reserved to the university the authority to regulate the time, place, and manner of such speech “to prevent interference with the normal functions of the university.”61
This power to regulate time, place, and manner was crucial because the faculty whose resolutions settled the Berkeley free speech crisis in 1964 understood that the university was an educational institution and so its free political forum must not disrupt the university’s educational work. This meant that you could hold whatever political rally you want out on Sproul Plaza but not march into classrooms while classes are in progress. It meant you could use amplified sound at your rallies on the Plaza but not right outside classrooms where it might drown out student and faculty communication in their classes. It meant you could not interfere with either academic sessions or the functioning of university business in campus offices.
Yet if you look at what UC Berkeley did to accommodate and protect these unpopular right wing speakers it is evident that Christ administration went so far out on a limb to defend free speech in the political sphere that it neglected its responsibility to prevent the disruption of the university’s educational work. In effect, the Christ administration inadvertently violated the university’s own time, place, and manner regulations. It did so most extensively in connection with the Ben Shapiro speaking engagement in September 2017 when for the sake of security it had the UC police in the late afternoon close down six campus buildings. These buildings housed offices that provide essential student and academic services, and both staff and students were angered by their closure.62
Student groups who shared offices in the closed buildings of the student union complex were especially indignant that scores of student organizations were being required to leave their campus spaces for the sake of a speaker invited by one small student group. Student disgust with this situation ran so deep that some activists staged a sit-in on the pass through balcony breezeway between the student union and Eshelman Hall protesting the building closure.63
It is true that some of the objections to the disruption of their academic environment caused by these right-wing speaking events were linked to the disdain that a liberal and left-leaning student body and campus community felt towards far right speakers themselves. This was the case, for example, with the Berkeley student government, whose senate initially considered a resolution criticizing the University for subsiding the Ben Shapiro speaking event, but then modified it so as to focus on the building closures and safety issues caused by the Shapiro event. Nonetheless, this unanimous student senate resolution criticizing the university administration for its “misguided decision to overlook student safety and well-being to accommodate” the Shapiro event, and its point that “we need to stop prioritizing speakers over students” resonated far beyond the student government itself.64 University spokesperson Dan Mogulof found this out as he walked across the campus, and had a student – a sociology major “holding ice coffee and a Rice Krispes Treat wrapper” – shout to him: “Students have a right to go to their classes and feel safe in their classrooms, and you’re ready to compromise that for, like, the First Amendment that you’re trying to uplift?”65 The same kind of complaint came from the chair of Berkeley’s anthropology department, who expressed outrage that her department’s most important annual academic lecture had to be postponed – upon the advice of campus police -- because of the “high risks associated with any campus events held during” the dates of the campus events supposedly planned by Yiannopoulos.66
In the Shapiro event and for Yiannopoulos’ chimerical Free Speech Week the university ordered in an army of police and a network of police barricades that made Berkeley’s southern entrance look like it was under military siege. Such precautions were taken both to avoid a repeat of the anti- Yiannopoulos riot and with the Charlottesville tragedy – where a homicidal white supremacist plowed his car into a crowd of anti-racist activists, killing one of these protesters – in mind.67 This militarization, however, led many students to avoid the whole Sproul area, and some to decide that given the campus chaos it was best to skip classes altogether. This problem was further exacerbated because, in the wake of the Charlottesville mayhem, more than 130 Berkeley faculty had urged the cancellation of Yiannopoulos’ Free Speech week, cancelled their own classes, and urged a boycott of classes.68 They viewed these Yiannopuolos events as potentially dangerous to their students, especially students of color, as those events seemed certain to attract white supremacists to the Berkeley campus – just as the first anti-Yiannopoulos riot made the city of Berkeley a magnet for these violent right wing extremists and their antifa counterparts who had engaged in violent street confrontations in the summer and early fall of 2017.69
To put this time, place, and manner issue into a larger perspective, just imagine that student radicals had closed six campus buildings and placed barricades in a Berkeley’s main entrance way in a disruptive protest. What would have happened to them? They would almost certainly have been disciplined – suspended, or expelled – and likely arrested as well for interfering with the regular functions of the university. Yet here it was the campus administration that had disrupted the work of the university. Of course the administration did this with the best of intentions, tolerating such disruptions for the sake of ensuring that unpopular right wing speakers could be safely heard on campus and so preserving Berkeley free speech tradition.
But such good intentions do not alter that fact that the administration had allowed the time and place of a political event to disrupt the academic life of the university. All of this brings to mind the scholarship and arguments of Robert Post, Sterling Professor of Law at Yale, that the First Amendment has been inappropriately applied to college campuses.70 Post makes a crucial point in reminding us that a university campus is not a park, but is part of an educational institution whose academic mission should be served by and not subordinated to extramural political events such as outside speakers invited by student groups. It was not merely leftist students, moreover, but a much larger group of academically engaged and politically inactive students who complained that the administration had allowed the Berkeley campus to become a political circus, with military-style occupations by the police, barricades, and a magnet for potentially violent extremists, and all for the sake of right wing speakers who had almost no appeal on campus and little, if any, educational value.71 They felt that their campus had essentially been hijacked and their safety and academic environment sacrificed to the administration’s desire to prove its free speech bona fides.
There is then a striking contrast between Chancellor Christ’s success as a champion of free speech in the fall semester of her declared free speech year at Berkeley and her less stellar performance as a guardian of Berkeley’s academic environment and functions. This contrast reflects the oversimplified Left-Right discourse regarding free speech at the university and the ways it pressured the Berkeley administration to neglect its primary academic responsibility. It also suggests that many conservatives, who think nothing of provoking mass disruptions of the university, have lost touch with the key traditional responsibility of the university to hold classes and provide academic services to its students. Perhaps part of the problem is that most of those op-ed writers, politicians, right wing media stars and foundation officers have so long since completed their own college degree work that they have forgotten the importance of academics to current students, and carry on as if the university’s main obligation is to the First Amendment rather than to their students and the academic work in which students and faculty are engaged
First Amendment scholars and lawyers might characterize this situation I have described as a tension – and even a healthy one -- between the university as an educational institution and the university as a site where students and the outside speakers they invite exercise their First Amendment rights. But at Berkeley in the fall of 2017 this was more than a tension, it was a dictate: the university was essentially pressured into disrupting its academic work to host these right wing speaking events in a central campus location where they could be maximally disruptive. Chancellor Christ, recognizing that the Yiannopoulos and Shapiro events – and their accompanying security - would be disruptive, initially thought the best way for the university to host these events would be to hold them away from the central campus area, at the Lawrence Hall of Science where intense security could be provided without disrupting the university since that building was up in the Berkeley hills quite a distance from central campus buildings. Had the chancellor been allowed to follow her instincts on this, these events could have been held with no disruption of academic life and work on campus. But this was not be. Why? Because university counsel told the chancellor that convening these controversial talks at such a remote location raised First Amendment issues, that the university was obligated to provide equal access to the main campus venues for all speakers. Owing to this legal advice, the chancellor dropped the Lawrence Hall idea, and so First Amendment rigidity prevented her from acting in a way that would have better served the university’s academic environment and educational work.72
Although it may sound counterfactual, it is worth pondering what would have happened had Chancellor Christ not taken the extraordinary steps she did to accommodate these prominent right wing speakers. Let’s say that with Shapiro she had taken the hard line I seemed to be suggesting in this paper – that she’d only provide him with space if it was available in the rooms usually used by student organizations. And since there were none, the BCR would need to delay his Berkeley talk until such space became available. I indicated above that this only sounds counterfactual because this is precisely what happened with the Ann Coulter debacle. With Coulter, Christ’s predecessor as chancellor, Nicholas Dirks, sought such a delay since a room large and secure enough to accommodate Coulter’s talk would only become available a week after the date she and her BCR hosts had targeted. Result? Through histrionics by Coulter (and her student hosts) in the mass media about this being a violation of their free speech rights, and Coulter’s refusal to wait a week to hold her talk, UC Berkeley was pilloried in the media for supposedly barring this right wing speaker. Christ, learning from the mistake of her predecessor, was determined to do all that was necessary to avoid such a PR disaster, even if it meant disrupting the university’s academic work, since the false media narrative of UC Berkeley as repressive and the spotlighting of right wingers as free speech martyrs – however fanciful -- was damaging to the university’s reputation.
If, however, we take a closer look at what Dirks actually did in relation to the Coulter fiasco it offers a valuable case study of how media distortions and the right wing’s weaponization of the First Amendment to attack the liberal university have fostered a warped view of academic decision-making. Dirks could only have come out ahead in the Coulter PR war had he gone along with a ridiculous prioritizing of an outside speaker (and a vacuous one at that) over the university’s own academic work. He could have won that PR battle by evicting some academic class or other university event from its large lecture room to make way for Coulter so she’d have had her event on the date she and the BCR wanted and so could not even pretend she was a free speech martyr.
Dirks in this matter, however, had too much academic integrity to play such a PR game. Thus when he inquired as to whether one of the best lecture halls at Cal, at the law school, could be made available for Coulter he learned that there was a class scheduled to take an exam there. After speaking with the acting dean who controlled this space, Dirks recognized that evicting the students from their lecture hall would be disruptive of their academic work. As the chief academic officer of the university Dirks thought it was wrong to cause such a disruption and so he wouldn’t do it. Instead, he looked for other spaces for the Coulter event, and recognizing that none could be made available without similar disruptions of the work of student, faculty, and staff, opted instead for a postponement of the Coulter event so that it could be held when space was actually available.73 In other words, Dirks was doing his job in protecting the university’s educational work, but this fact was lost in all the right wing and media uproar about the university “cancelling” the Coulter talk.
In retrospect Dirks sees that he had not moved as quickly as his critics, and that going by the book and prioritizing Cal’s academic work over this politically symbolic Coulter event was a mistake because it led to the university being unjustly slammed in the national news media as politically intolerant.74 This perception that it had been a mistake to prioritize academic work over this PR battle to preserve Cal’s reputation as a center of free speech is understandable given the PR beating that Dirks and UC Berkeley took in the Coulter affair. And of course Dirks’ successor as chancellor learned from this “mistake” and so was careful not to repeat it – in the Shapiro and Yiannopoulos events. But if we put aside the PR battle for the moment, it is easy to see that Dirks had not in fact made a mistake. He had done what was best for the students in that class whose education he refused to disrupt. The point is that deciding to do the right thing educationally has been made to seem a “mistake” because neither the media nor the far right cares about the university’s educational responsibilities, but act as if the university’s #1 job is hosting extremist speakers on demand so as to prove its free speech bona fides.
To her credit, Chancellor Christ realized that though she had won extremely important free speech victories by demonstrating – via the peaceful Cal speaking events by Shapiro and Yiannopoulos in September 2017 -- that the Berkeley campus was open to even the most widely loathed right wing speakers, promoting free speech at Cal was not the straightforward task she had imagined when she declared her first year of her chancellorship “Free Speech Year.” She came to realize that there were significant minorities of the student body and faculty who were critical of her handling the speaker controversy. Indeed, in the forums that Christ had organized as part of Free Speech Year, one with the Berkeley faculty’s academic senate and another co-organized with PEN that included students as well as faculty, the chancellor got these criticisms first hand. And she began to adopt a more complex view of free speech on campus, describing it as an ongoing process involving discussion and reflection rather than a simple set of principles. Christ was also chastened by the experience with Yiannopoulos and the way that he misled the university, abusing Cal’s earnestness and free speech idealism for a self-serving publicity stunt that cost the university dearly in terms of time, money, and comity.75
Christ’s commitment to free speech had not weakened, but she developed an understanding that the UC Berkeley needed both to better defend itself against those who were weaponizing the First Amendment to harass the university, and to find ways to accommodate speakers all along the ideological spectrum without disrupting or bankrupting the university. Christ also recognized that the free speech disputes had yielded divisions and anger on campus, that the university needed to provide an open forum for the campus community to dialogue as a means towards healing, assessing what had happened, and what could be done to better respond to speaker controversies in the future.76 Thus in October 2017 she convened a group of faculty, students, staff, and administrators, the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, charged with investigating “how the campus could better address and manage politically controversial public events.”77
The Chancellor’s Free Speech Commission held three public hearings in January and February 2018 in which some 40 Berkeley students and faculty discussed – among other things -- how the campus’ free speech crises affected them. Much more effectively than the national media coverage, this testimony revealed just how disruptive the massive security measures for the Shapiro talk and Yiannopoulos’ “Free Speech Week” had been for students and staff who worked or made use of the services in the Sproul Plaza area.
It wasn’t just the building closures but communications problems that made those times chaotic. Students and staff reported that they did not know in advance the extent of the security measures and so could not prepare for them. So students came to campus to meet with counselors only to learn that the building in which the office was located had been locked down. Office managers were unclear on how to respond when employees either missed or wanted to leave work early because they did not feel safe with the army of police and protesters on the Plaza. Some students had missed the notices concerning items banned from campus, and so came to Cal – as students often do – with their books in their backpacks only to learn that they could not bring backpacks to campus, leading to missed appointments and classes.78 These were all problems that few if any universities could prepare for effectively since educational institutions are not in the business of coping with or administering a virtual stage of siege.
Arguably the most dramatic testimony during the hearings came from an African American staff member recalling the very tense moment for him amidst the militarization of Cal’s campus during one of these free speech events. He was leaving his campus job at night and remembers thinking he wished he’d worn his Cal ID card as he passed through the assemblage of police because he was afraid of how the police would respond – afraid he might get shot -- if he reached in his pocket for his ID.79
It became evident from the testimony at the commission hearings that the disruptive impact of the free speech crises was localized, in that it disproportionately impacted one part of the campus, the Sproul Plaza area. If one attended classes in the engineering quadrant or entered campus on the north side of Berkeley’s huge campus you might not even be aware that on the south side there was military-style police occupation and large crowds of protesters. This uneven impact had a racial dynamic to it since the offices and services disrupted in the Sproul area included those most heavily used by students of color. Indeed, both the hearings and the earlier free speech forums convened by the chancellor generated evidence that Black and Latino students felt they bore the biggest burden from these free speech crises since the right wing speakers were most hostile to their communities, the offices which served them were most disrupted, and they felt the most threatened by both the police presence and the potential violence from white supremacists drawn to Berkeley by the Left-Right battle zone that the campus and city had become.80
Race was not, of course the only dividing point since Yiannopoulos in particular was infamous for targeting transgender students in his campus tour, and both he and Shapiro were Islamophobic. But there is no question that many students of color felt a sense of betrayal at how these free speech crises has been handled by the university. That it was a mostly white group of right wing students who insisted on bringing in speakers hostile to Blacks, Latinos, Muslims, and undocumented immigrants, and a mostly white liberal university administration that supported such speaking events so that money was no object in that support, and whose white sensibility did not allow it to see that the supposed solution to the security problems generated by these speakers, a mass police presence on campus, left many Black and Latino students feeling even more unsafe.81
The Free Speech Commission hearings also offered a window on to those on the other side of the ideological divide at Berkeley, right wing students who had either invited or supported the inviting of Yiannopoulos and the other far right speakers that sparked Berkeley’s year of free speech crises. Among those testifying before the commission was the president of the Berkeley College Republicans, a right wing columnist for the Daily Californian, and there was a statement read into the record by a commission member on behalf of The Berkeley Patriot, the on-line right wing student publication that had signed on to host Yiannopoulos and his so called Free Speech Week.82
In several respects the testimony by these conservatives was the most depressing of any offered during the Commission hearings. On one level was the students’ sense of victimhood, that they were an unpopular right wing minority on a liberal campus at a time and place when – thanks to Trump’s election and presidency – Left and liberal disdain for the right was at fever pitch. The university had not found an effective way to make these conservatives feel welcome in the campus community, leaving them alienated— in ways that seem even deeper than sociologist Amy Binder and Kate Wood documented in their seminal, pre-Trump era study of conservative student activists, Becoming Right.83
But if the university had failed these campus conservatives, they reciprocated, and failed to display any concern about the impact of their actions on the campus community. At hearings where a wide range of members of the university community testified to the ways these speaker events had interfered with their education, work, and disrupted their lives, the conservative students displayed complete indifference to these complaints, took no responsibility for helping to foment the crisis, and repeated the mantra that they had the right to invite to campus anyone they liked.84
This too is part of the legacy of the media – and especially the right wing media -- frenzy over First Amendment rights on campus. It has popularized among right wing students a discourse of rights and an ethic of entitlement. But there has been no corresponding discourse about responsibility. Yes students have the right to bring hateful nativist speakers to campus. But is that the responsible thing to do, especially at a time of high political tension provoked by the most xenophobic president in American history? This is a question the conservative student leaders at Cal evaded consistently not only in their commission testimony but in every single one of their op-eds, press statements, and TV interviews.85
There was a parallel evasion on the part of Berkeley conservative student leaders when it came to their statements about Yiannopoulos and the logic of inviting him to speak on campus. All kinds of disingenuous or shallow rationales for the invitation were offered by these students both at the hearings and in print – that his appearance could supposedly spark dialogue and debate, that he was an attractive speaker because he charged no speaking fee and would pack the room, that he was a provocateur who would force liberal Berkeley to finally listen to the right, which it needed to get used to doing now that Trump was president, and finally that though they did not necessarily agree with what he said they were free speech champions by standing for his right to bring his widely panned rhetoric to campus. But in none of this did these right wing students ever actually deal with the crudity and cruelty of what Yiannopoulos had been saying and doing on his campus speaking tour: such as referring to women as “cunts” at the University of West Virginia, mocking a gay professor there as a “fat faggot,” denouncing a transgender student at the University of Wisconsin at Milwaukee from the podium, by saying “you know he failed because I can still bang him,” while projecting that student’s image and livestreaming it on the Breitbart website.
Even after the passions unleashed by Yiannopoulos’ abusive rhetoric and his nativist and racist discourse had led to the shooting of an anti-racist protester at the University of Washington only a little over a week before his first Berkeley appearance, no reflection was heard from Berkeley conservative students on the wisdom of inviting him to their campus. In the hearings, none of these conservative students uttered a word of criticism of the way Yiannopoulos misled the university with a phony speakers list for his chimerical Free Speech Week. Nor did they take any responsibility for the time and money that right-wing initiated debacle cost the university. This was an extension of the amoral way the Berkeley College Republican leadership had reacted in February to Yiannopoulos’s pedophilia scandal, which found BCR leader Troy Worden stating that the “Berkeley College Republicans have no comment” on his remarks concerning pedophilia.86 Nor was there any explanation of why at a time when that scandal caused even Breitbart news and the American Conservative Union to break with Yiannopoulos he still received a second invitation to speak from Berkeley’s right wing students.
In response to this vagueness on the part of right wing students about the justifications for bringing a troll like Yiannopoulos to campus, one of the recommendations that the Chancellor’s Free Speech Commission made in its final report (issued just before the end of the 2018 academic year) was that for all events that required extra security, registered student organizations submit to the university “a public statement explaining how the event comports with the [university’s] Principles of Community.” The Commission, again in the interest of getting student groups to take some responsibility for the consequences of their choices on public events also recommended that the student groups “provide volunteers to assist at sponsored events that need extra security.”87
In direct response to the testimony it heard that criticized the way these speaking events disrupted the Sproul Plaza area, the Commission recommended the establishment of an additional free speech zone on the west side of the campus. In essence, this meant that the Commission, recognizing that future disruptive events were likely (owing to the university’s free speech obligations), was opting for greater geographical equity by altering which parts of the campus would have to bear such disruptions, instead of ghettoizing it, as was the case this past year in the Sproul area.88
Though not specifying how this was to be done, the Commission advocated “increase[d] communication about the steps faculty, staff, and student can take to protect themselves from a disruptive event and “make the police a less intimidating presence during potentially disruptive events.” The Commission also recommended something chancellor Christ had considered doing but was unable to (since doing so would have stretched the police too thin) during Yiannopoulos’ “free speech week”: “organize counterprogramming to empower targeted community members in the face of the most disturbing campus speech events.”89 The Commission wanted as well for the costs of such events not to be borne by the university alone, and so recommended that the state of California provide additional funds to cover the extra security costs for speaking events that were likely to be disruptive.
Given the polarized state of American politics it is not surprising that the media responded to the Commission’s report by focusing not on such recommendations about better managing controversial speaking events, but on the report’s critical words about far right wing campus speaking tours and their off campus sponsors. In Politico, for example, the story on the commission’s report was headlined “UC Berkeley Panel Blasts Motives of Conservative Speakers.”90 And it is true that the Commission reported that “Many commission members are skeptical of these speakers’ commitment to anything other than the pursuit of wealth and fame through the instigation of anger, fear, and vengefulness in their hard right constituency. Speech of this kind is hard to defend, especially in light of the distress it caused (and was intended to cause) the staff and students, many of whom felt threatened and targeted by the speakers and outside groups financing their appearance.”91 The report also took aim at the right wing foundation world and the role of outside funding in promoting campus turmoil, arguing that “at least some of the 2017 events at Berkeley can now be seen as part of a coordinated campaign to organize appearances on American campuses likely to initiate a violent reaction in order to advance a facile narrative that universities are not tolerant of conservative speech.”92
Since Yiannopoulos had spoken openly of his desire to provoke such campus turmoil he was, of course, defensive about these charges. And even the title, Dangerous, of his juvenile book boasted of his pride in provoking anger, as did its chapter titles: such as “Why Muslims Hate Me,” “Why Black Lives Matter Hates Me,” ”Why Feminists Hate Me,” Why Establishment Gays Hate Me”93 True to form, Yiannopoulos dismissed the Free Speech Commission report as the work of “Marxist thugs.”94
Though one can debate the Commission’s indictment of these right wing speakers and their sponsors, it reflected the frustrations many at Berkeley experienced at the disruption of their academic life for the sake of speakers like Yiannopoulos, with nothing to contribute intellectually and who seemed addicted to mean-spirited vitriol. It was probably impolitic to include this indictment since it distracted the media from the Commission’s major recommendations, which were well conceived, practical, and aimed at sustaining Berkeley’s free speech tradition in the wake of a year of challenges and turbulence.
But on the other hand, a Commission on Free Speech, almost had to speak freely about what it saw as the roots of Berkeley’s free speech crisis.
The Free Speech Commission, despite all its recommendations for changes to better manage controversial political events on campus nonetheless shared the basic assumption of the chancellor and her legal advisors about the First Amendment and campus disruptions: That UC Berkeley was required by the First Amendment to accommodate invited speakers no matter how great the security risks or potential for major disruptions of the academic and work life of the campus. Thus there was a whole section of the Commission’s report devoted to “Improved Communication About Disruptive Events.” Here the Commission offered a number of suggestions about how, in these crisis situations, to improve such communication between the university’s top leadership and the university community “to enhance the ability of faculty, staff, and students to protect themselves” in the event that a dangerous environment emerged. In particular, the Commission asked that the chancellor and her leadership team let the campus community know the answers to the following questions:
- “May instructors cancel class without penalty?
- May students skip classes or other campus appointments without penalty?
- May staff leave their posts if they feel threatened?”95
If one reflects upon such questions it again becomes evident that First Amendment absolutism has placed the university in the ridiculous position of accepting as a given that it must live with continual disruption of its academic life and business in order to host political events that have little if any relationship to its academic mission. The assumption the Commission made was that the university – or at least parts of it – should be ready for another crisis and police invasion provoked by an extremist speaker because the university was required by law to allow such speakers and disruption. So for the Commission the task was how to better prepare and cope with such disruptions.
Now, let’s take as a given that in some cases the university, following the advice of the commission, does effectively communicate that students can skip classes because of safety issues caused by a speaker conflict. Is this a plus? Have we gotten to the point where we are ok with class attendance being interrupted in this way? If so, the whole point of time, place, and manner regulation has been negated, and the work of the university subordinated to the campus tours of celebrity speakers and provocateurs.
While this problem seems to me serious and worrisome it does reflect an impressive free speech commitment. That even after a year of turmoil and division caused by right wing speakers and the violent response on the Left to them, the Free Speech Commission stood by the right of such speakers to appear on campus, and searched for ways that the campus community could more effectively cope with such political events. Equally impressive given the university’s budget woes and the high costs of security Cal bore for the speakers this past year was the Commission’s refusal to put a cap on such spending, and in effect refused to use finances and safety problems (serious as they have been) to shut down or even limit the free political forum at Berkeley.96 And the same was true of the chancellor, who praised the work of the Commission and supported its recommendations.97 These ringing affirmations of free speech at Berkeley, and not the Commission’s criticism of the likes of Yiannopoulos is the heart of the story of the Commission and its work – and it is a story that the media largely missed.
This is not to say, however, that media criticism of Berkeley on free speech was groundless. There are vocal students and faculty at Berkeley and non-student militants across the SF Bay Area who take the position that hate speech, fascistic speech, must not be given a platform at the university. And in Yiannopoulos’ case there were also students and faculty who, citing his abusive behavior from other university podiums, saw his personal attacks on students and faculty as forms of harassment that violated the university’s own policies – as well as federal policy under Title IX -- and so should not be tolerated at Cal.98 Those who have been vocal in airing these views are, however, only a minority of the student body and the faculty and do not set university policy. But their views do matter. And we need to remember that the Free Speech Commission was the chancellor’s and does not speak for such dissenters, for whom the free speech conflicts of the past year at Berkeley did nothing to change their truncated views on free speech
Indeed, a key conclusion that emerged clearly from my oral history research at Berkeley is that each side in the Berkeley free speech conflicts of the past year came away more convinced than ever that its position on free speech was correct. Left critics saw the anti-Yiannopoulos riot in February 2017 and the time and money UC spent (and in their view, wasted) on his bogus free speech week in September 2017 as proof that hosting such a hateful speaker was wrong-headed.99 This, of course, contrasted with the UCB administration’s conviction that legally and morally the university had no choice but to host these far right speakers, and that the university managed to do so in the fall of 2017 without disruption represented a triumph for the free speech tradition.100 And then of course, there were Berkeley’s right wing students who have convinced themselves that they did right in inviting such extreme speakers since the turmoil this provoked supposedly proved the hollowness of liberal Berkeley’s vaunted free speech tradition.101
What all this means is that the campus and off campus elements that paved the way for Berkeley’s free speech crises of the past two academic years remain in tact. These include an alienated student right wing –aided by wealthy far right foundations -- eager to antagonize those on the Left and to challenge and embarrass the liberal university, a Left that seeks limits on the free speech rights of racist, transphobic, and nativist extremists, and a university administration committed to protecting and preserving Berkeley’s free speech tradition. The one important change from the grim days leading up the the February 2017 riot at Berkeley is that President Trump’s incompetence and corruption, and the rising strength of opposition to him both in the streets and at the voting booth, has diminished somewhat the panic that beset the Left at the dawn of the Trump era in 2017. This offers some hope that future free speech conflicts at Berkeley will be free of the ugly violence and property damage of February 2017, and so in that sense, as UC spokesperson Dan Mogoluf put it, Milo Yiannopolous may eventually be looked back upon in the Berkeley context as Milo Anomalous.102
As I watched on-line the hearings of the Free Speech Commission and the other forums on free speech sponsored by the chancellor I was as impressed by the questions that didn’t get asked as those that did. For me, these would be directed towards 1) the faculty and students urging the barring of hateful speakers. I’d ask them the mechanism they’d use for such barring. Would this be done by a board of censors? If so who would select its members and establish criteria for speaker bans? Can there be such a thing as a free university that included such a censorship apparatus? What would the university do when the courts ruled such censorship unconstitutional? 2) To the right wing students who invited Yiannopolous I’d ask them to engage with his crudity and cruelty, asking them how they can expect to promote dialogue via speakers who insult and frighten their classmates. I’d ask them if they are finding their own way politically or are being used as pawns by self-promoting celebrity speakers and rich foundations with an ideological axe to grind. And whether it makes any sense at all to be suing a university that spent millions of dollars securing their speaking events. 3) And to the university administration, I’d ask it both to define Cal’s educational mission and explain how these speakers and the disruptions they foment serve that mission – whether the university has gone too far in tolerating disruptions of its educational work. I’d ask them to respond to the students who complained that the university had become a political circus, interfering with their education, as well as to the Left critics who complain that the administration allowed UC to be converted into a doormat for right wing interests that weaponized the First Amendment to harass the liberal university. I’d ask whether at times its leaders seemed more concerned with responding to outside pressures -- winning its free speech argument with Fox News, Trump et al than it was with the well being of its own student body.
On one level it seems unfair to sound this note of criticism of the UC Berkeley administration since chancellors Dirks and Christ have been both courageous and far more consistent in defending free speech during the Trump era than their critics on the Left or the right. Neither onerous security costs, nor slanderous tweets from the president of the United States, nor rioting leftwing vigilantes, nor the obnoxious political hoaxes of Yiannapoulos could shake the determination of these chancellors and their administrations to preserve and protect Berkeley’s historic tradition as a center of freedom of speech.
But in the long term that free speech tradition cannot be preserved by the administration alone. Berkeley’s free speech crises in the Trump era revealed, as Dan Mogulof explained, that when it comes to free speech “our truths are not self-evident” to a significant segment of the Berkeley student body.103 The challenge of championing such truths and demonstrating to students that those truths are worth sacrificing for is a daunting one, all the more so because Berkeley’s free speech crises in the Trump era have triggered justifiable student complaints, sarcasm, and searching questions, such as the one raised by the Daily Californian’s disillusioned editors on the first anniversary of the antifa riot at Cal.
These editors bemoaned the fact that the university spent millions of dollars to protect hateful speakers while “financial support for the … Undocumented Student Program is “nonexistent,” and “the Title IX office also needs more money to help combat the campus’s pervasive sexual misconduct problem… It’s outrageous that ‘Free Speech Week’ alone cost the campus nearly $3 million despite barely lasting 20 minutes… an event that was clearly a last-ditch attempt from a fallen public figure to regain the media’s attention after he made comments that appeared to condone pedophilia. When UC Berkeley is forced to pay millions of dollars to allow campus groups to host bigoted speakers, it puts students in danger and starves them of much-needed funds. But on the bright side, the campus saved face to a group of donors, alumni, and legislators who wanted UC Berkeley to uphold its reputation as a bastion of free speech. Was it worth it?”104
The raising of such questions by students, and the difficulty this recent free speech history poses to being able to answer them in ways that they find convincing, are among the the great challenges facing Cal’s leaders as they struggle with legacy of the Berkeley free speech crises wrought by Trump era -- with its polarization, bigotry, and ugliness. Given that the far right has used free speech as a political football at Cal it is not surprising that vocal Berkeley students on the Left have become cynical about the waving of free speech banners on behalf of bigoted, reactionary speakers. But such cynicism by students is an effect and not the cause of Berkeley’s free speech crises.
It is external forces – of the far right and far left -- not the university itself that have been at the root of those crises. The reactionary Mercer family of billionaires bankrolled Yiannopoulos, the wealthy YAF foundation subsidized Coulter and the subsequent law suits against UC Berkeley, supported by the far right attorney general, and the Trump tweet slandering Cal, none of these forces has any roots on the Berkeley campus. And the same is true of both antifa, with its left wing vigilanteism and its far right, Nazi and white supremacist counterparts. The two sides share a loathing for the university (the Left because Cal offered a platform for fascistic speakers, the Right because it sees the university as a center of left wing political correctness that undermines conservative values) and a willingness, even an eagerness to use the university as a battleground for ideological warfare. This is what Chancellor Dirks meant when, in one of the final op-eds of his tenure at Berkeley, he concluded that “the real issue in the campus speech debate was that “the university is under assault.”105
With so much money and hatred being directed against the university, there are no grounds whatsoever for predicting a quick end to that assault. Indeed, as we have seen, the First Amendment itself has been weaponized by the far right against Cal. But if, as the university continues to stand up to such attacks and for free speech, it is more forceful in articulating its educational mission and responsibilities it may be in a better position to insist on the need to contain the disruptiveness and the costs of the political events outsiders push on to the campus. This is neither a call for a closing off the campus to any political sect or speaker, nor a quest for some novel approach to campus political discourse, but rather a return to the long tradition, and legally ordained authority of the university to enforce reasonable regulation of the time, place, and manner of political speech on campus so that it does not interfere with the university’s educational work.
While this Berkeley history is new, the historian depicting it is an old hand at studying free speech at Cal. So some self-reflection seems in order to assist readers in recognizing and transcending my biases. There is no doubt that the location of the history narrated here in Berkeley, birthplace of the Free Speech Movement (FSM), and my own history as a biographer of FSM leader Mario Savio and historian of the FSM (and member of the FSM archives executive board) contributed to the pro-free speech slant of my account of the political turmoil at Cal in the early Trump era. On the other hand, the research that went into this study led me to question and then reject some of my initial assumptions, and to recognize, in a way I had not previously, the importance of time, place, and manner provisions of the Berkeley academic senate resolutions that ended UC Berkeley’s free speech crisis of 1964. I had always seen it as a self-evident truth that free speech must be protected on the Berkeley campus, but through this research came to see that freedom alone would not suffice for a great university, which also required order if it was to accomplish its educational mission and function well as a workplace. Even so, the narrative I constructed and have presented here is generally admiring of those who defend Berkeley’s free speech tradition and critical of those who do not. The nature of the events narrated in these pages, with antifas crudely employing violence against free speech and the university, and rightwingers just as crudely abusing free speech and slandering the university, makes it easy to reduce this story to a morality tale about free speech and its enemies.
But such a black and white image of this history cannot do justice to the grey areas, in which reside the complexities of the campus free speech issue. The fact is that while the free speech crises at Berkeley spotlighted those who, like the antifas, would take a sledgehammer to the Berkeley free speech tradition, those crises also provoked thoughtful criticism of both that tradition and free speech jurisprudence. Such criticism was most notable among radical faculty who the Berkeley academic senate and Chancellor Christ wisely included in the free speech forums organized as part of the programming for the “Free Speech Year” she had declared at the opening of her term as chancellor.
Among the most important of these criticisms was the one that concerned technology. Judith Butler, Berkeley’s eminent professor of comparative literature, objected less to the speech than to the abusive deployment of technology from the podium by Yiannopoulos. She was referring to his use of “cameras or ‘trigger cams’ that project images of audience members against their will” both to the audience at the speech and to a national viewership on-line, along with Yiannopoulos’ “direct appeal to those watching or present to mock, harass, or troll that person and flood that person’s e-mail with insult.” She argued that this use of “invasive technology in conjunction with explicit calls to invade privacy” violated the university’s “anti-harassment protocols.106 Since, of course, internet technology did not exist back in 1964, the Free Speech Movement’s principles cannot be used to resolve this dispute over abusive uses of technology. Can one actually claim it a free speech infringement if from a campus podium Yiannopoulos is denied the technological tools to humiliate and invade the privacy of audience members? Such questions demand serious consideration and reflection.
Also worth reflecting upon are the arguments against hate speech offered by Berkeley law professor John Powell. As a legal scholar, Powell acknowledged that the courts have upheld the constitutionality of hate speech. But he rejected deference to such decisions, arguing that the courts were wrong about hate speech, and have yet to catch up with the social science scholarship on the “psychological harm caused by hate speech,” much as the US Supreme Court for decades upheld Plessy and racial segregation until it finally came to grips with the psychological damage that segregation did -- documented in the scholarship cited in the historic Brown decision outlawing racially segregated education.107 The implication here is that rather than spending millions of dollars protecting hateful speakers, the university should use its resources to challenge the courts and society to face up to the damaging impact of hate speech – as courts in democratic societies outside the United States have already done.108
This issue was taken seriously by top university officials. Nils Gilman found the mental health question real, but problematic since it was impossible to “eliminate insults,’ and that if you even tried to do so it was “unclear how you the university can operate since” so many forms of expression can insult people and potentially damage their mental health. Gilman thought political expression could not be policed to bar hateful discourse without violating the First Amendment. But he did see and act on one important exception, and that was where speech acts -- in one case malicious political posters – targeted specific members of the university community in ways “that might provoke violence against them.” Gilman had those posters taken down, and personally observed the ”mental health impact” those threatening posters had on the targeted students, who were “depressed and scared and having anxiety attacks.”109
Putting aside for the moment the legalities, it is clear that the hate speech issue ought not be dismissed as some superficial impediment to freedom of expression on campus. That stereotyping students as liberal “snowflakes” because they express fear and loathing of hate speech is both unfair and misleading. Chancellor Christ’s personal experience with this issue during the free speech crises in her first year in office
made this all quite clear. Displaying the kind of empathy and sensitivity that is often absent in the media and virtually always absent on the right, Christ explained that she “became very aware of how some of the [bigoted] speakers made constituencies on campus feel that they didn’t belong, that they were threatening their sense of place in the community. Even though I wish our students were more resilient, I realized that I came from a [different] place… 73 years old, successful, I have a powerful position so it is easy for me to be resilient. It is not so easy for someone who feels that she may not belong at Berkeley in the first place, and [then to have a vitriolic speaker comet to campus] telling her she doesn’t belong.”110
Whether on not one agrees with the arguments and criticism raised by Butler and Powell there is no question that they enrich the discussion of, and debate about, the Berkeley free speech tradition. It is unfortunate that the free speech forums at which these views were aired did not attract the kind of national media attention that the right wing speaker controversies and riot did. But these forums were important nonetheless, especially because Christ listened so carefully and learned from them, as was reflected in her perceptive public statements that displayed a deepening awareness of the costs as well as the benefits of the Berkeley free speech tradition, and its impact on all segments of the university community. Thus the same chancellor who had insisted on keeping the campus open to the far right, proved herself open to hearing these leading critical faculty voices from the Left. Even if no consensus has emerged regarding how to act on such criticism, one can at least say that the university, is, as it should be, speaking freely about who loses as well as who benefits from Berkeley’s free speech tradition.
ENDNOTES
- Frances Dinkelspiel, “One Day, One Night: The Fuse That Lit the Battles of Berkeley, Berkeleyside, Oct. 31, 2018. ↩︎
- Daryl Ansel interview with the author, May 9, 2018, Berkeley; Nils Gilman interview with the author, May 11, 2018; Brad Devlin testimony, Chancellors Commission on Free Speech, Feb. 9, 2018, Berkeley; Report of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, April 2018, ↩︎
- “Bretibart Writer Targets Transgender Student,” Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Dec. 14, 2016. ↩︎
- Robert Cohen, When the Old Left Was Young: Student Radicals and America’s First Mass Student Movement, 1929-1941 (New York: Oxford Univ. Press, 1993; Ellen Shrecker, No Ivory Tower: McCarthyism and the Universities; Todd Gitlin, “Campus Conservatives Say Campus Speech is Under Threat. That’s Been True for Most of History,” Washington Post, Aug. 11, 2017. ↩︎
- Erwin Chemerinsky and Howard Gilman, Free Speech on Campus (New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, 2017), 97-110. ↩︎
- There had, prior to the Trump era, been free speech violations by an ultra-militant segment of the Berkeley Left, and one such incident – the disruption of a campus event with Marc Benioff and Lors Ulrich in 2016 -- even included an attempt to assault a speaker (Benioff). But such incidents were isolated and involved only a very small group of radicals, nothing on the scale of the anti-Yiannopoulos riot. See Nils Gilman et al, “Event Disruption is the Antithesis of Campus Free Speech Tradition,” Daily Californian, March 16, 2016. ↩︎
- David Weigel, “Four Lessons from the Protests in Berkeley,” Washington Post, Feb. 2. 2017. ↩︎
- Margo Bennett interview with the author, May 10, 2018. ↩︎
- It was Fox News’ right wing commentator Todd Starnes on “Fox and Friends” who first suggested cutting off federal funds to Berkeley because of the riot that shut down the Yiannapoulos speaking engagement. Trump, a daily viewer of this show, almost certainly got the de-funding idea from Starnes. But the Trump de-funding tweet went even further in that it not only blamed UC for cancelling the speech but further slandered Cal by asserting that “UC Berkeley… practices violence on innocent people with a different point of view.” The full text of this wildly inaccurate and demagogic tweet (dated Feb. 2. 2017) was: “If U.C. Berkeley does not allow free speech and practices violence on innocent people with a different point of view – No Federal Funds?,” Dinkelspiel, “One Day, One Night: The Fuse That Lit the Battles of Berkeley ↩︎
- “UC Berkeley Chancellor Affirms Milo Yiannapoulos’ Right to Speak on Campus,” Daily Californian, Jan. 26. 2017. ↩︎
- Chancellor Christ: “Free Speech is Who We Are,” Berkeley News, Aug. 23, 2017; “UC Berkeley Spent $4 million for Free Speech Events,” New York Times, Feb. 5. 2018. ↩︎
- “Ann Coulter at Berkeley: Untangling the Truth,” California Alumni Magazine, May 8, 2017; “A Thousand Gather Peacefully Protesting Ben Shapiro’s Talk, Daily Californian, Sept. 14. 2017; Dan Mogulof interview with the author, May 9, 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
- “UC Berkeley Spent $4 million for Free Speech Events,”; “UC Berkeley Professors Request Cancellation of Milo Yiannopoulos Talk,” Daily Californian, December 10, 2017: UC Berkeley Chancellor Affirms Milo Yiannopoulos’ right to speak on campus,” Daily Californian, Jan. 26, 2017. ↩︎
- Ann Coulter Backers File Lawsuit Against UC Berkeley Administration,” Daily Californian, April 24, 2017. ↩︎
- Margo Bennett interview with the author, May 10. 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
- Donald Trump tweet, Feb. 2, 2017. ↩︎
- Nicholas Dirks interview with the author, June 20, 2018, NYC. ↩︎
- Nils Gilman interview with the author, May 11, 2018, San Francisco. ↩︎
- Dan Mogulof interview with the author, May 9, 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
- Dirks interview with the author. ↩︎
- Nicholas Dirks, “Violence at Berkeley and Freedom of Speech,” New York Times, Feb. 3. 2017. ↩︎
- Nicholas Dirks, “Do Not Condone Violence to Suppress Free Speech,” Daily Californian, Feb. 10, 2017. ↩︎
- Nisa Dang, “Check Your Privilege When Speaking of Protests,” Daily Californian, Feb. 7, 2017. ↩︎
- Neil Lawrence, “Black Bloc Did What Campus Should Have,” Daily Californian, Feb. 7, 2017. ↩︎
- “Berkeley College Republicans, Cal Berkeley Democrats Debate on Free Speech,” Daily Californian, March 23, 2017. ↩︎
- William Morrow, “Don’t Just Learn It, Live It,” Daily Californian, May 4, 2017. ↩︎
- “Report of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech,” April 9, 2018, UC Berkeley, 6. ↩︎
- These Cal students were part of that generation Erwin Chemerinsky and Howard Gilman described as “the first generation educated, from a young age not to bully,” (Erwin Chemerinsky and Howard Gilman, Free Speech on Campus (New Haven: Yale Univ. Press: 2017), 10. ↩︎
- Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
- Dirks interview with the author. ↩︎
- Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
- Amy Binder, “There’s A Well-Funded Campus Industry Behind the Ann Coulter Incident,” Washington Post, May 1, 2017. ↩︎
- Law suit Filed Against UC Berkeley for Cancelling Ann Coulter Speech,” Washington Post, April 24, 2017. ↩︎
- “Justice Department Sides With Conservative Groups in Free Speech Lawsuit Against UC Berkeley,” Washington Post, Jan. 25, 2018. ↩︎
- “YAF Claims Campus Blocked Ben Shapiro Appearance,” Daily Californian, July 19, 2017. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Daily Californian, August 15, September 11 and 14, 2017; “No, Cal is Not Blocking Ben Shapiro’s Speech,” California Alumni Magazine, July 20, 2017. ↩︎
- “Right Wing Student Groups Invite Bigoted Trolls to Invade Campus Under Guise of Free Speech,” Daily Californian, Sept. 22, 2017 ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- “Milo Yiannopoulos is the Pretty, Monstrous Face of the Alt-Right.” Bloomberg News, Sept. 15, 2016. ↩︎
- On Coulter’s crude anti-Latino bigotry and nativism, see Ann Coulter. Adios America: The Left’s Plan to Turn Our Country into a Third World Hell Hole (2015). ↩︎
- “Right Wing Author to Speak at UC Berkeley in April,” Daily Californian, March 28, 2017; “UC Berkeley Administrators Propose Re-Scheduling of Ann Coulter Event to September,” Daily Californian, April 19, 2017. The Coulter visit was co-sponsored by BridgeCal, a campus organization promoting political debate; Ann Coulter at Berkeley: Untangling the Truth.” ↩︎
- Nils Gilman interview with the author. ↩︎
- For an example of how the media bought into the false notion that UC “cancelled” Coulter’s talk at Cal and had fallen away from its free speech tradition, see “UC Berkeley is Sending Mixed Messages About Freedom of Speech,” Los Angeles Times, Sept. 24, 2017. ↩︎
- Ann Coulter at Berkeley: Untangling the Truth.” ↩︎
- “Misconceptions Concerning Ann Coulter’s Now-Cancelled Visit to Campus,” Daily Californian, April 25, 2017. ↩︎
- Ibid ↩︎
- Nicholas Dirks, “Berkeley is Under Attack from Both Sides,” New York Times, April 26, 2017. ↩︎
- Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Ann Coulter at Berkeley: Untangling the Truth.” ↩︎
- “Berkeley Community Responds to Milo Yiannopoulos’ Resignation from Breibrart News,” Daily Californian Feb. 21, 2017. ↩︎
- Bryan Schatz, “Milo’s Dumb ‘Free Speech’ Stunt Cost UC-Berkeley $800K and Nothing Happened: Could That Have Been by Design?” Mother Jones, Sept. 25, 2017. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Marissa Reynoso interview with the author, May 10, 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
- “Milo’s Dumb ‘Free Speech’ Stunt”; “’Free Speech Week at Cal was ‘Political Theater,’ Carol Christ Tells ASUC Senate,” Daily Californian, Oct. 5. 2017; Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
- Art Tavan, “From the Mouth of Madness: The Dangerous Brand of Milo Yiannopoulos,” Playboy, Sept. 22, 2017. ↩︎
- Carol Christ interview with the author, May 9, 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
- UC Berkeley was struggling “to reduce a crippling $150 million budget deficit,” “What Stunts Like Milo Yiannopoulos’ ‘Free Speech Week” Cost,” New York Times, Sept. 24, 2017. ↩︎
- “UC Berkeley Faculty Members Call for Boycott of Classes during ‘Free Speech Week,” Daily Californian, Sept. 13, 2017; UC Staff Members Express Safety Concerns For ‘Free Speech Week,’’ Daily Californian, Sept. 14, 2017; also see, student and staff testimony at Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, January 18, February 5 and 19, 2018. ↩︎
- Robert Cohen and Reginald E. Zelnik, eds. The Free Speech Movement: Reflections on Berkeley in the 1960s (Berkeley: UC Press, 2002), 324. ↩︎
- “UC Berkeley Will Shut Down 6 Buildings for the Shapiro Event, Daily Californian, Sept. 11, 2017; ↩︎
- Carol Christ interview with the author. ↩︎
- ASUC Senate Denounces UC Berkeley Subsidization of Ben Shapiro Event.” Daily Californian, Sept, 14, 2017 ↩︎
- Andrew Marantz, “ How Social-Media Trolls Turned U.C. Berkeley Into a Free Speech Circus,” New Yorker,(July 2, 2018). ↩︎
- Laurie Wilkie, “Campus Sacrifices Community Safety, Intellectual Integrity for Provocative Speakers,” Daily Californian, Sept. 26, 2017. ↩︎
- Carol Christ interview with the author. ↩︎
- UC Berkeley Faculty Members Call for Boycott of Classes during ‘Free Speech Week,” ↩︎
- “Fighting Violence with Violence Achieves Nothing,” Daily Californian, Sept. 3, 2017 ↩︎
- Robert C. Post, “The Classic First Amendment Under Stress: Freedom of Speech and the University,” also see, Robert C. Post, Democracy, Expertise, Academic Freedom: A First Amendment Jurisprudence for the Modern State (New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, 2012) ↩︎
- Darryl Ansel interview with the author; Dan Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
- Carol Christ interview with the author. ↩︎
- Nicholas Dirks interview with the author, June 20, 2018, NYC. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Christ interview with the author. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Report of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, April 9, 2018. ↩︎
- Testimony at hearings of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, Jan, 18, Feb, 5 and 9, 2018. ↩︎
- Report of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech ↩︎
- Testimony at hearings of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, Jan, 18, Feb, 5 and 9, 2018. ↩︎
- Prudence Carter interview with the author, May 10, 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
- Brad Devlin and Mariel Goddu testimony at hearing of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, Feb, 9, 2018. ↩︎
- Ibid; Amy J. Binder and Kate Wood, Becoming Right: How Campuses Shape Young Conservatives (Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press, 2013). ↩︎
- Devlin and Goddu testimony. ↩︎
- For a typical display of such evasiveness, see Peter Sittler and Troy Worden, “In Defense of Milo Yiannopoulos,” Daily Californian, Jan 27, 2017; also see Troy Worden’s interview on Tucker Carlson’s show on Fox, “Campus Craziness, May 29, 2017. ↩︎
- “Berkeley Community Responds to Milo Yiannopoulos’ Resignation form Breibart News,” Daily Californian, Feb. 21, 2018. ↩︎
- Report of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, April 9, 2018 ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- “UC Berkeley Panel Blasts Motives of Conservative Speakers,” Politico, May 3, 2018. ↩︎
- Report of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Milo Yiannopoulos, Dangerous (Milo Worldwide LCC, 2017), 73-121, 138-152; 173-188. For a revealing window on to just how juvenile, poorly reasoned, and mean-spirted his book is, see Eli Rosenberg, “’Not Even Funny’: Editor’s Markup of Milo Yiannopoulos’ Manuscript Draws Ridicule, Ire,” Washington Post, Oct. 28, 2017. ↩︎
- “UC Berkeley Panel Blasts Motives of Conservative Speakers,” Politico, May 3, 2018. ↩︎
- Report of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech. ↩︎
- Ibid; Prudence Carter interview with the author. ↩︎
- Christ interview with the author. ↩︎
- UC Berkeley Professors Request Cancellation of Milo Yiannopoulos Talk,” Daily Californian, January 10, 2017; Judith Butler, “Limits on Free Speech?” Academe Blog, Dec, 7, 2017; “One Day, One Night: The Fuse That Lit the Battles of Berkeley.” ↩︎
- Darryl Ansel interview; “Berkeley College Republicans Must Not Normalize Hate Speech.” Daily Californian, January 17, 2017. ↩︎
- Christ and Mogulof interviews with the author. ↩︎
- Some of these right wing students were so proud of the conflict they sparked over the Yiannopoulos speaking invitation – and aligning President Trump with their criticism of the liberal university that they sported “No Federal Funds?” t-shirts, which, of course, was the quote from Trump’s tweet threatening to cut off federal funds to Cal because the university had, in his warped view, violently squelched free speech -- an inaccurate and slanderous claim ( Marissa Reynoso interview with the author). ↩︎
- Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- “UC Berkeley Literally Spent $4 Million on “Free Speech.” Wow, ” Daily Californian, Feb. 6, 2018. ↩︎
- Nicholas B. Dirks, “The Real Issue in the Campus Speech Debate: the University is Under Assault,” Washington Post, August 9, 2017. ↩︎
- Judith Butler, “Limits on Free Speech?” Academe Blog Dec. 7, 2017. ↩︎
- “UC Berkeley Faculty Members Clash on Free Speech, Controversial Speakers,” Daily Californian, Sept 8, 2017. ↩︎
- Jeremy Waldron, The Harm in Hate Speech (Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press, 2012) ↩︎
- Nils Gilman interview with the author. ↩︎
- Carol Christ interview with the author. ↩︎