Skip to content

Why Berkeley Conservative Student Leaders Fell for Milo Yiannopoulos and Fed the False Fox News/Trumpist Narrative That the University of California Suppresses Conservatism

I began my teaching career at UC Berkeley in the 1980s, as a teaching assistant and acting instructor in the History department. Although this was the height of the Reagan era, Berkeley continued to lean Left, and its student activists built a successful mass movement to pressure the university to divest its financial holdings in companies that did business with the apartheid regime of South Africa. The students in my history classes were mostly liberal, with a sprinkling of moderates and leftists, and one or two conservatives each semester. These conservatives tended to be bright, idealistic, committed to free market principles, and intellectually rigorous. They seemed more interested in entrepreneurialism than student activism. In fact, one of my most impressive conservative students had already found a clever way to generate lots of income – designing and selling the now classic t-shirt outlining on a football grid how the Cal football team in the last minute had defeated Stanford in a famed Big Game battle in which the Stanford Band had marched on to the field before the game had ended, contributing to the confusion that made that famous final play and winning touchdown possible. That student, and most conservatives in my classes enjoyed the give-and-take with their left-leaning classmates, and assumed themselves to be more in touch with where America was heading politically since the nation was shifting rightward. The conservatives were generally the most sympathetic to the UC administration – often giving officialdom the benefit of the doubt when conflicts occurred between it and student protesters. This seemed less an ideological phenomenon than an expression of a kind of school spirt that conservatives imbibed from the fraternity and sorority houses in which most of them lived. They referred to the university as Cal not Berkeley, had family roots in the university, and were often more interested in how Cal fared in the Pac 10 than in the political goings on of the campus Left on Sproul Plaza.

I mention these earlier Berkeley experiences because they help explain why I was so surprised by the behavior of Cal’s conservative student leaders in the opening year of the Trump era: that they would repeatedly extend campus speaking invitations to mean-spirited, shock-jock style speakers, who specialized in baiting vulnerable minorities, speakers I believe my conservative students from the 1980s would have found embarrassingly shallow and intemperate. My students admired conservative intellectuals and valued civility. So I simply cannot imagine their having any interest in associating with a foul mouthed, self-promoting troll like Milo Yiannopoulos, whose celebrity status was attained through public remarks and interviews that attracted attention because of their crudity, cruelty, and bigotry.1 Nor can I imagine my conservative students being a party to frivolous law suits against the university that they loved, lawsuits that the Trump era Berkeley College Republicans and the far right Young America’s Foundation have filed. Those suits made the ludicrous charge that the UC Berkeley administration had acted to suppress conservative ideas and speakers when in fact the university suffered more than $100,000 in property damage while hosting the first Yiannopoulos appearance – which was shut down because of a riot by leftist vigilantes – and then spent millions of dollars on security to ensure that such rioting could not recur and so he and other right wing speakers could and would speak on the Berkeley campus.2

The question of why Berkeley’s conservative students would invite Yiannopoulos to their campus has attracted little media attention. This media neglect is itself a fascinating phenomenon.3 One can understand such neglect in the immediate aftermath of the riot that prevented Yiannopoulos from speaking at Cal in February 2017 since the primary task of reporting on the riot involved focusing on the Left, the 150 or so violent antifa militants who invaded the campus, damaged the MLK Student Union building, prevented the Yiannopoulos speech from occurring, and then trashed downtown Berkeley, leaving $600,000 in property damage there. But long after that riot, and after a tape of Yiannopoulos sick remarks making light of pedophilia caused even the American Conservative Union to disinvite him from addressing its national convention, most of the media still failed to ask why Berkeley’s conservative students were so drawn to Yiannopoulos, why even after this scandal they extended an invitation for Yiannopoulos to return to Cal for a campus speaking engagement in fall 2017.4

This failure reflects the narrowness of the media focus on political speech at Berkeley, that it frames such far right speaking events almost exclusively in a First Amendment context. So for the media the question was whether the university respected the right of its conservative students to invite such far right speakers, not whether these speakers ought to be invited in the first place. Seeing the university only as a site of political combat and not as an educational community, the media proved largely incapable of asking whether such an invitation was damaging to that community and whether it in any way served the educational mission of the university. As with the right wing students themselves, the media proved unwilling to move from the realm of rights to responsibilities – of asking whether such an invitation was responsible.5

Obviously , the First Amendment question answers itself, since yes these students did have the right to invite Yiannopoulos, and yes the university was obliged by law and committed via its free speech policies to enabling even such bigoted, mean spirited, and unpopular speakers to appear on campus when invited by officially recognized student groups. So really the live and unanswered questions are why right wing student organizations at Cal would invite a speaker so offensive that his first appearance at Cal sparked a major riot, and why after that riot and after Yiannopoulos had discredited himself even with the national right wing over his pedophilia scandal, Berkeley right wing student activists still were determined to have Yiannopoulos speak on their campus.

Before we can begin to answer these “why” questions concerning the Yiannopoulos invitations we first need to deal with the question of who the right wing student activists were that extended these invitations and how representative those activists were of Berkeley’s small group (ie a few dozen) of conservative student activists. This is an important matter because it would be both inaccurate and unfair to conservative students at Berkeley to assume that all, or even most of them, were fans of Milo Yiannopoulos or enthusiastic supporters of the right wing activists who invited him. Indeed, the Berkeley College Republicans, the organization whose leaders invited Yiannopoulos, never took a democratic vote on that invitation.6 And in fact, Troy Worden, the key BCR leader and Trumpist, who initiated and defended that invitation would less than a semester later be impeached and replaced by a BCR leader more reminiscent of the Reaganite Republicans I taught in my Berkeley history classes in the 1980s.7 Disgust with their extremism and the way the Yiannopoulos and other speaker controversies were handled by Worden and his BCR leadership cadre – and especially the way they trolled the university administration – led not only to this leadership change in the BCR, but also provoked some disillusioned conservatives to found the Berkeley Conservative Society as an alternative to the BCR, promoting a more intellectual and less confrontational brand of conservative student activism.8

So the who we are dealing with regarding the first Yiannopoulos invitation was the small (and as it turned out short-lived ) leadership cadre of the BCR who spoke for that organization from the spring to the start of the fall semester of 2017. Another small student group on the far right, the staff of an on-line conservative student publication, The Berkeley Patriot, consisting of less than a dozen students, was primarily responsible for the second Yiannopoulos invitation to Berkeley.9 This publication had posted a mere handful of articles, so even calling it a fledging student organization is more than generous. What both the BCR leadership cadre and the Berkeley Patriot had in common, aside from their small size, was their commitment to far right ideology and politics – generally Trump-like – and their deep alienation from the liberal university.

A good place to start our inquiry into why Berkeley’s right wing students invited Yiannopoulos is with the public statements of their leaders. The week before Yiannopoulos’

first scheduled appearance at Cal, Peter Sittler, the internal vice president of the Berkeley College Republicans (BCR), and Troy Worden, the BCR’s future president, who had helped initiate and sign the contract with Yiannopoulos for his Cal speaking date, published in the Daily Californian, Berkeley’s student newspaper, an op-ed “In Defense of Milo Yiannopoulos.” Opening by noting that “Berkeley College Republicans have suffered much criticism and abuse for inviting … journalist and provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos to campus,” Sittler and Worden sought to explain the invitation.10 But the explanation immediately became fogged up by its vagueness and evasiveness. “We invited Yiannopoulos,” Worden and Sittler write “precisely because he raises taboo political topics that our club believes are necessary for, and essential to a complete political debate – and he uses humor and satire while doing so.”11 Were there actually topics at the university that were taboo? Topics that only Yiannopoulos could address? What were these topics? Sittler and Worden never say. Their claim that Yiannopoulos used “satire and humor” in his discourse obscured the reasons he was so widely loathed on campus. Yiannopoulos had been banned from Twitter for his vicious personal attacks on Leslie Jones, an African American actress, which unleashed a wave of racist tweets that his far right followers aimed at her. In his campus tour he had so humiliated a transgender activist by name (projecting that activist’s image on a screen from the podium and making obscene and transphobic remarks about that student) at the University of Wisconsin at Milwaukee that the student dropped out of school. At the University of West Virginia Yiannopoulos crudely and personally attacked a gay sociology professor as a “fat faggot,” and referred to women as “cunts.”12 These personal attacks, especially the one involving the transgender student, were so offensive to some 130 Berkeley faculty that in an open letter to Berkeley Chancellor Nicholas Dirks, they denounced Yiannopoulos’ behavior from the podium as a form of personal abuse that violated the university’s and the federal government’s polices against sexual harassment; they urged the chancellor to cancel his campus speaking engagement.13 Whether or not one agrees with such calls for the cancellation of Yiannopoulos’ speech (and Chancellor Dirks did not) or with the charge that his mean-spirited attacks aimed at humiliating targeted individuals on campus amounted to harassment (which at the very least they bordered on), to chalk this up as “satire and humor” is evasive at best. Sittler and Worden could not really explain why they chose to host a crude, cruel, and bigoted speaker when they refused even to face up to that cruelty, crudity, and bigotry.

Next Sittler and Worden tried to make their invitation to Yiannopoulos sound like a function of their commitment to political pluralism, asserting that “In order to fully develop intellectually, we must not hear solely from those with whom we agree and those who make us feel good – we must have our views challenged. Berkeley College Republicans are in fact the real thinkers on this campus precisely because they have the courage to stand up to Berkeley’s reigning political orthodoxy …. [ie] liberal thought.”14 So if, as these BCR leaders suggest, the BCR was already courageously challenging the Berkeley campus liberal “political orthodoxy” why was there a need for Yiannopoulos’ presence? If there was some intellectual quality that Yiannopoulos would add to BCR’s defiance of the liberals and the Left, Sittler and Worden certainly did not identify it – and other than his nastiness and baiting of minorities it is difficult to see what Yiannopoulos had the potential to add to the Berkeley campus right’s political discourse. Their proposition that hearing from Yiannopoulos would help any student to more “fully develop intellectually” is preposterous given how his bigotry, juvenile antics, and abusive rhetoric foreclosed rational political dialogue and led to disruptions and violent conflict on his campus tour.

Sittler and Worden claimed that Yiannopoulos “gives a voice to repressed conservative thought on college campuses,” but failed to share a single conservative thought that Yiannopoulos expressed.15 What thoughts did he air that others on campus were not free to air? They do not say. Yiannopoulos was famed not for his “conservative thought,” but for baiting religious, racial, and sexual minorities.16 How this connected with the goal of invigorating conservative thought on campus is a mystery that Sittler and Worden did nothing to resolve.

Matriculating on a campus famed for its role in promoting free speech – with Berkeley as the birthplace (in 1964) of The Free Speech Movement -- Sittler and Worden naturally sought to place themselves in that heroic tradition. They wrote that “In the past, Americans have fought and suffered for their right to express themselves; what we are doing here is no different, because… we know that it is right that people’s feelings should take a back seat to open discourse and free speech… The Berkeley College Republicans believe that we should err on the side of more speech instead of less. Our campus is not a ‘safe space,’ and true to Cal’s motto ‘Fiat lux,’ light will be shed upon issues in ways that some may find uncomfortable…. It is time [for liberals] to mature and realize that you will encounter people with whom you may not agree.”17

Such free speech sentiments are admirable, but here too these BCR leaders were studiously avoiding any discussion of the ugly way Yiannopoulos abused that freedom, how he had behaved on his campus tour and how that behavior combined with the political tensions accompanying Trump’s inauguration and Muslim travel ban to unleash conflict that was not merely ugly and frightening but violent. Just a little more than a week before Yiannopoulos’ scheduled Berkeley speech a pro-Yiannopoulos militant had shot and seriously wounded an anti-Yiannopoulos protester on the picket line at the University of Washington.18 At a time when immigrant and undocumented students as well as LGBT students were feeling especially threatened by Trump’s ascension to power was it responsible to bring to campus a nativist, transphobic troll whose tour had provoked such violence? To this all Sittler and Worden had to say was “ we disavow any violence or hurt that may occur as a result of him [Yiannopoulos] coming to campus.”19 While surely Sittler and Worden were right about the need for “mature” attitudes towards speech with which one disagrees, there is also a kind of mature judgment that escaped them, and that involved recognizing that some forms of speech, especially in moments of high political tension and crisis, are so incendiary as to provoke violence. Given the shooting at the University of Washington one might expect some soul searching about the wisdom and timing of the Yiannopoulos appearance at UC Berkeley and some serious thought about at least postponing that event until the political temperature dropped.

But such soul searching and re-thinking did not occur. And why was that? The answer to this question can be gleaned from the part of the Sittler and Wordon op-ed that was autobiographical, which was also the part that was by far the most honest. In contrast to Sittler and Wordon’s obfuscations and vagueness in discussing Yiannopoulos, they were direct, specific, and convincing in describing their own feelings of alienation from their campus and the anger and hurt the Berkeley College Republicans had suffered as they became an increasingly unpopular minority among their liberal classmates in the wake of Trumpism and one of the most polarizing presidential campaigns in American history. Thus Sittler and Wordon ended their op-ed with a plea to their political foes on campus not to do on the date of Yiannopoulos speech “what you have done in the past. Do not illegally release personal information of our members with intent to do harm. Do not steal or destroy our private property. Do not insult, yell at, spit on, intimidate, or otherwise physically assault us. Do not attempt to shut our events down...”20 This litany of complaints conveyed the BCR leadership’s sense of victimization at the hand’s of an intolerant Left. And this is one of the keys to understanding some of the deepest motivations for the Yiannopoulos invitation: payback for their own mistreatment by the Left. Yiannopoulos’ scornful treatment of liberals and the Left was attractive and even cathartic for some among the Berkeley campus rightwing who felt themselves on the receiving end of Leftist and liberal scorn. So the enemy of my enemy is my friend was a submerged (ie not public) part of the reason the BCR ended up championing Yiannopoulos.

Understanding this sense of alienation and anger is central to sorting out the way the free speech issue figured into the Yiannopoulos invitations at Berkeley. Yes, there was a free speech element in the public rhetoric of the BCR leadership, which they sought connect to the now valorized Free Speech Movement (FSM) of 1964. But in reality the freedom being exercised via the Yiannopoulos invitation was not a freedom to liberate the student body from restrictions on the content of political speech on campus (since all such restrictions had been eliminated decades ago by the FSM), but rather their own freedom to bring in a speaker with a track record of insulting, offending, and inciting – in so nasty and personal a way that it bordered on harassment – progressive students, whom they loathed.

One could make a case, that students on the Left were too sensitive, since, Yiannopoulos’s words, however vile they might be, lacked the power to actually hurt them, especially if they simply boycotted his talk. But if the Left was arguably too sensitive, these BCR leaders were publicly almost gleefully extreme in their insensitivity and even callousness about the fears, anxieties, and anger their progressive classmates felt about Yiannopoulos’ hateful rhetoric. Indeed, Sittler, a little over a week before writing his pro- Yiannopoulos op-ed with Worden, was, in a Daily Californian interview, not merely dismissive of such concerns about Yiannopoulos – who he termed “hilarious” and “entertaining” – but insulting to students who expressed them, saying that they should “grow up.”21 Noting that Sittler “evaded” questions about Yiannopolous assaultive rhetoric, that Sittler claimed to be “unfamiliar with an incident at the University of Wisconsin in which Yiannopolous harassed a transgender student in front of an entire audience,” and merely mocked those concerned with such cruelty, the Daily Californian, in its editorial “Berkeley College Republicans Must Not Normalize Hate Speech,” accused him of acting “hypocritically” in claiming that “the BCR invited Yiannopoulos to campus to promote dialogue…. This is a club hiding behind the right of free speech as an excuse to legitimize – even laugh at -- hate speech and shirk responsibility for any resulting damage.”22 The Daily Californian found it absurd that Sittler and the BCR claimed to be promoting “free speech and open dialogue on campus,” while ignoring the fact that Yiannopolous was “a repulsive” purveyor of “alt right hate speech” who shuts down any potential dialogue as he “intentionally baits marginalized voices so he can bully them and exploit the angry backlash in front of his fans.”23 Thus while Sittler and the BCR had the purer free speech argument, their disingenuousness about Yiannopoulos and refusal to publicly acknowledge the cruel and hateful character of his oratory and behavior undermined their credibility, motives, and claims to be pursuing any lofty goals regarding free speech.

Criticism of Yiannopoulos’ bigotry – and the racist, xenophobic, Islamophobic, and transphobic component of his discourse— did nothing to stop conservative student leaders at Cal from identifying with him, owing to their feelings of marginalization and alienation.24 This sense of marginalization and alienation was quite visible when Sittler and Wordon, in their pro- Yiannopoulos op-ed charged that at UC Berkeley “any view that deviates from the liberal status quo these days is considered ‘hateful’ and ‘bigoted.’ It is nigh impossible for a Berkeley College Republican to disagree with one of his liberal peers and still expect respect – afterward – his outstretched hand of friendship is often left hanging in the air.”25 The problem with this formulation is, of course, that just because charges of bigotry and hatefulness are sometimes unfair, does not mean that this is always the case. Nor is it even true that at a campus as politically diverse as Berkeley any view outside the liberal mainstream would automatically be assumed to be bigoted. This would certainly not be the case among faculty who study ideas professionally. Nor for administrators or students with any level of political sophistication. Indeed, since most conservatives who have spoken on the Berkeley campus attracted little notice and no protest,26 it was clearly not the deviation from liberalism that led to charges of bigotry, but the specific words and actions of the individual charged with bigotry – and such charges need to be judged via empirical evidence rather than simply dismissed with a rhetorical flourish. Nonetheless the mindset of Sittler and Worden was that since some BCR activists were unfairly stereotyped as bigots because of their conservatism the same must be true of Yiannopoulos (and Trump), and that it was fine with them if the heat of his nasty rhetoric melted the campus’ liberal snowflakes.

But actually the charges of bigotry against Yiannopoulos were not unfair. The evidence of his bigotry is overwhelming. He served as a leading apologist for the white nationalist alt-right, most notably in his Breitbart puff piece “An Establishment Conservative’s Guide to the Alt Right,” which he colluded with white nationalists in writing.27 As conservative critic Elliot Kaufman noted, Yiannopoulos offered here “an outright apologia for racist white separatism,” as when he wrote sympathetically of their segregationism, which he sugar coated as people “fighting for self-determination” who “want their own communities, populated by their own people, and governed by their own values.”28 Yiannopoulos was effusive about how “bright” white supremacist Richard Spencer was, and in an interview explained that he liked to hang out with Spencer because he was “edgy.”29 This was the same Richard Spencer who was the headlined speaker and marched with the KKK at the Charlottesville Nazi rally at which a white supremacist murdered an anti-racist protester. Yiannopoulos refused to condemn their anti-Semitism and himself said things like “the Jews control everything.”30 Given Yiannopoulos’ proposal to set up scholarships reserved for white students, his lectures on what he hates about Islam, his denunciation of Black Lives Matter as a “terrorist” organization it is little wonder that he and Spencer have been drawn to each other. And then there was his bigotry on sexuality, with Yiannopulous denouncing transgender people as mentally ill – urging that they be mocked – and slandering them as child molesters, much like homophobes had done to gays in the mid-20th century.31

Sittler and Worden were too scorned by and scornful of their progressive classmates to deal publicly with any of this evidence of Yiannopoulos’ bigotry. And, of course, doing so would not have served their purposes since it would have sullied the image they sought to project as champions of free speech. The BCR’s silence on bigotry and the campus right wing’s own expressions of hurt and resentment reflected the new tensions brought to the Berkeley campus political scene by Trumpism. This ran far deeper than the normal fare of partisan division because Trump’s nativist platform directly threatened undocumented immigrant students, their friends and families with deportation, and Trump’s Muslim travel ban threatened students from that faith. Since the new Republican president’s attacks on immigrants were so virulent and upsetting, Berkeley College Republicans could hardly expect to escape facing hostility from students in a majority non-white student body within which immigrants, especially Latinos, were so prominent.

It is almost impossible to overstate how tense the political climate was at Cal as a result of Trump’s election, following his hateful nativist campaign. Chancellor Dirks, recognizing how shocked and frightened many students were, wrote a message to the campus community in the wake of Trump’s election, affirming the university’s “values of respect and inclusion,” and urging the university to “rise above the rancor” of an “election season that has witnessed a pervasive rhetoric of intolerance across our nation which had been a cause of alarm and concern for many of us.” He expressed confidence that Berkeley would continue “to embody the best of what a free, open, and inclusive society should be.” 32 The chancellor carried this message directly to the students by appearing at a student senate meeting. At that meeting the chancellor saw first hand how polarizing the election and its aftermath had been.

Dirks encountered evidence of this polarization, right after his remarks to and q. and a. session with the student senate, when a BCR member came up to him and discussed the growing hostility BCR members had experienced because of the election, “including physical intimidation.”33 Dirks replied that any such threats or attacks were “unacceptable,” and told him he would set up a meeting with the Student Affairs office immediately to prevent any such incidents in the future. Dirks noted that even after he’d offered to intervene to help the student was so upset that he kept on venting. “He didn’t want to let go.”34 And here, as with the BCR use of the free speech issue, this BCR activist’s complaint to the chancellor was expressed in a kind of passive-aggressive way that was linked with resentment of the liberal university – in this case, however a resentment directed not only at liberal students but at Cal’s liberal administration and the chancellor himself. This BCR activist, as Dirks recalled, “kept saying ‘you supported every community, every minority, every this and that… but you’re not supporting us.’”35 As Dirks became more familiar with the BCR leadership over the course of the Yiannopoulos and other right wing speaker controversies in his last year as chancellor, he came to see that it was opposed to “virtually every thing the university stood for…. I mean not only the official statements that are being made by the administration [especially on behalf of diversity and inclusion] but the culture of the faculty and the culture of students. And this was … a dominant, repressive, and hostile culture as far as the BCR was concerned.”36

Almost as disturbing to Dirks as physical threats and violence directed at conservative students was what he termed “the choreography of polarization.”37 That when the BCR member came up to speak with him at the student senate meeting, “no else would” come near him, as if he was a pariah.38 In this tense political atmosphere it would take some brilliant intervention on the part of the faculty and administration to promote amicable Left-right relations on campus, but nothing that the chancellor did could change the fact that student politics at Cal was as polarized by Trump’s bigotry and the resistance to it as was the larger polity. In such a political climate it is not surprising that the BCR proved incapable of reconsidering its Yiannopoulos invitation.

There were numerous attempts, however to get the BCR to think through the consequences of the political choice it was making. Faculty and administrators, while respecting the right of the BCR activists to choose their own speakers , did try to reason with them about the ugly things Yiannopoulos had said and done on his campus tour, and why such hurtful behavior was so problematic. Probably nobody did more in this regard than the advisors in Cal’s LEAD Center, who provided organizational and leadership training for Berkeley’s 1,200 student organizations. The LEAD Center advisors found that when they raised the issue in their private meetings with some of the BCR leaders, there was a willingness –absent in their public cheerleading for Yiannopoulos -- to acknowledge that they were not comfortable with the way he had mocked and bullied that transgender student at Wisconsin and did not want him (as was rumored to be his intention) to do the same to undocumented immigrant students -- who its was rumored he planned to out -- in his Berkeley appearance.39 Reminding this BCR activist that the planned Yiannopoulos talk was the BCR’s event not his, the advisor suggested that the BCR contact him and tell him that they did not want him doing such a thing when he spoke at Berkeley. And this BCR activist did seek to contact Yiannopoulos, but could only reach his manager who laughed and told him that if he asked Yiannopoulos not to do something like that it would only make him more determined to do so.40 In the end, however, neither this activist nor any BCR leader cared enough to insist that their speaker behave decently and with some civility.

It is difficult to avoid seeing a connection between Donald Trump’s coarse political discourse and the BCR leadership’s refusal to utter a word in public objecting to the parallel coarseness and cruelty in Yiannopoulos’s rhetoric. For these young Republican leaders, their party’s nominee and new president had normalized the most brutal forms of political discourse – from the use of demeaning language and personal attacks to racist stereotyping --to the point that Yiannopoulos’s hateful speech seemed not just acceptable but helpfully provocative. And Trump, having won, and ascended to the presidency through such rhetoric had proven its effectiveness. So the lesson for this small conservative student organization on a famously liberal- Left campus was that being provocative through coarse rhetoric a la Yiannopoulos and Trump was a path to greater influence and visibility.

It was natural, however, that the BCR leadership sought to make the Yiannopoulos invitation sound high minded (and may even have believed it to be so), whether as a bold act on behalf of free speech, an admirable venture in political pluralism, or a courageous challenge to political correctness. But in their private conversations with UC Berkeley administrators and even in a later BCR leader’s subsequent statement at the chancellor’s commission on free speech it was evident that organizational and personal ambition were major factors drawing the BCR to Yiannopoulos.41 Contrary to the impression left by right wing media, the BCR, which has a long history at UC Berkeley, had regularly hosted respected conservative speakers. These speaking events usually drew neither protests nor media attention, and – this is crucial -- they were often sparsely attended.42 This issue of poor attendance came up, when in the lead up to the February 1 Yiannopoulos event, Nils Gilman, chief of staff to Berkeley chancellor Dirks, queried the BCR leaders as to why they were departing from their and the university’s history of bringing thoughtful “credible conservative” speakers to campus, such as Jim Mattis, who had spoken at Cal several years earlier and went on to become secretary of defense in the Trump administration.43 The answer Gilman received was that less than a handful of students had shown up for Mattis’ talk.44 That Yiannopoulos was being invited in part because he would draw a big crowd. His national speaking tour had, of course, generated headlines, and crowds of protesters so yes it was true that such an event offered the BCR what for them (as a small and unpopular student organization) a rare opportunity to host a well attended political talk, and one that was inexpensive since Yiannopoulos did not demand an honorarium. 45

Ordinarily, of course, there is nothing wrong with seeking to host a speaker who would draw a big crowd. In fact, student political organization leaders are supposed to maximize the appeal of their events to serve the institutional interests of their groups. But Yiannopoulos was a speaker whose lack of civility, whose cruel mocking of that transgender student for example, was objectionable to students and faculty alike. Was it not an unprincipled form of political opportunism to bring a speaker many viewed as lacking in basic human decency merely because he would draw a crowd? This was the issue Gilman, several other UC administrators and Berkeley history department chair Mark Peterson raised with Worden and another BCR leader at a meeting held in the wake of the February riot. The meeting was prompted by BCR statements about wanting to bring Yiannopoulos back to campus, and a desire to understand why the BCR was so eager to have him come to Cal even after his recent disastrous appearance.46 One response they received from these BCR representatives was that “we couldn’t get students to pay attention to conservative ideas [via conventional conservative speakers]. We have to do something to provoke them.”47 In this meeting the BCR leaders, forcefully challenged on such opportunism, were asked whether they’d want to be associated with Yiannopoulos’s assaultive discourse: “Do you really think it’s ok to say the many nasty things that Milo says?” “Troy [Worden], as Gilman put it, “literally smirked.”48 Worden and his fellow BCR leader sought to evade the question by invoking the First Amendment, claiming that they were standing up for Yiannopoulos’s free speech rights. But as to the hurtful things Yiannopoulos had done from the podium, according to Gilman, “they’d just dismiss it and not want to deal with it.” Gilman viewed this as defending “the right to be an asshole. The First Amendment allows you to be an asshole;” and he came away from the meeting aware that it had been futile to try to prod them to re-think their hosting such a loathsome speaker.49

Mark Peterson’s follow up questions at this meeting may have been the most revealing of all. After one of the administrators asked Worden and his fellow BCR activist whether they agreed with Yiannopoulos’ bigoted comments – such as those he’d made about Muslims -- and the students backed off, claiming that they “absolutely do not support everything that Milo says,” Peterson asked: “So can you tell me which position that Milo has taken that you actually do support?” The conservative students seemed stumped. According to Peterson, “they were hemming and hawing. And finally Troy, after a certain amount of time, said ‘Well we like what he says about mens’ rights.’ “50 Peterson responded by asking “’What do you mean by that?’ Then again kind of hemming and hawing, and not very clear,” seeming to imply that “the decks are stacked on campus against men – I don’t know – who committed sexual assault allegedly. It was,” Peterson noted, “quite feeble. They were not prepared to say much of anything about Milo as, in particular, as a speaker or supporter of anything they were in favor of.”51 Peterson pushed back, and also offered the BCR some advice: “Of course it’s your right to ask anyone you want to come and speak on campus. But you should also understand that with rights come responsibilities too. And that in this case you’re asking someone about whom you seem to have very little to say [ concerning any ideas of his and how they align with the BCR’s]… But at the same time you have [in Yiannopoulos] someone who has a … record of engendering violence and danger, and destruction on the campuses he goes to, and they should be careful about the costs and benefits here… the very high costs of bringing the tiger to the nursery school.”52

Chancellor Dirks’ experience with the BCR leadership in connection with Yiannopoulos controversy was similar to Gilman’s and Peterson’s. “I was” Dirks recalled, “privy to conversations that were unguarded – that’s really very limited obviously,” but these made clear that the embrace of Yiannopoulos was an expression of BCR feelings of marginalization and alienation as well as a hope that a high visibility speaker, no matter how unpopular, would attract attention to the BCR – something they felt entitled to in the wake of Trump’s recent election victory. A BCR leader told Dirks “ we want to do this [Yiannopoulos event] because we have been just invisible at Berkeley. This is a way of making visible our reality. Do I approve everything the guys says? No.” Dirks’ impression was that “some of” BCR’s leaders “approved of some of the” things Milo had been saying in his campus tour. “Milo is pretty edgy for a Berkeley student, but they didn’t care.”53

There is no way to be certain whether Worden and the other BCR leaders who met with Dirks and other Cal administrators to discuss their views on Yiannopoulos were actually being candid. Indeed, judging by some of the critical comments by BCR rank and filers who opposed Worden and his leadership cohort, these BCR leaders may have been closer to the far right fringe than they were willing to let on either in public or in meetings with UC officials. Berkeley BCR member Jonathan Chow, who had challenged Worden’s leadership, claimed that Worden’s views “veered toward the extreme.”54 Chow charged that some BCR members “who supported Worden told him they were ‘national socialists,’ a term used by neo-Nazis – which appalled Chow.”55 As BCR president, Worden had also been, according to Chow, unwilling to respond to member complaints when “anti-Semitic comments began to pop up” in a BCR-on line discussion board.56 Though Worden denied these charges, on the Tucker Carlson show Worden had trotted out the anti-Semitic canard of a demonic George Soros ( the Jewish financier), who Worden charged (without evidence) was funding Berkeley’s violent left wing groups.57 Moreover, San Jose Mercury News reporters noted that “Worden’s social media pages are peppered with photos of himself grinning next to the likes of [Steve] Bannon and Kyle Chapman, an alt-right instigator who goes by the name of Based Stickman. He’s also been photographed with ex-Google employee James Damore – who was fired for writing a memo suggesting that biological differences explain the tech industry’s gender gap – and Martin Sellner, the head of the far-right Austrian group Generation Identity.” Asked to explain these photos he had posted, Worden “dismissed the idea that he agrees with all of the people he poses with,”58 a response that begs the question of why he thought so highly of these extremists that he posed with them and then posted the photos. At the very least, one can say that Worden – and some of his leadership cohort in the BCR -- flirted with the alt-right and white nationalism. Thus it is little wonder that BCR member Ivan Varlea complained that the BCR “has been hijacked by bigots.”59

In Worden’s case there was also an element of personal opportunism involved in the Yiannopoulos event. Given the controversy and headlines generated by Yiannopoulos’ vitriol and the protests, disruption, and violence at the stops on his national campus tour, hosting him, especially in liberal Berkeley, seemed a sure path toward calling attention to ones’ self, and drawing media coverage. Becoming the voice of this effort to stick it to the Berkeley Left could lead to fame in the national conservative community, and possibly a career as a right wing political operative or in the right wing media world. All the more so in the wake of the riot that made the Yiannopoulos event a major news story. For Worden the Yiannopoulos controversy offered connections to his conservative heroes, as when he appeared on Fox with Tucker Carlson. Indeed, by the time the Yiannopoulos controversy was over Worden had his own website, featuring clips from his appearances on Fox, NRA TV, and other national right wing media outlets. In fact, Peterson, after viewing Worden’s initial appearance on Fox News, in which he overstated and overacted in the role of the oppressed conservative in liberal Berkeley, thought Worden sounded like he was “really interested in auditioning for a job on Fox News or Breitbart , one of these right wing media type of things.”60 Worden would subsequently work for Campus Reform, a right wing organization devoted to attacking the liberal university.

There is nothing inherently wrong with such opportunism. So let’s not begrudge Worden and his fellow right wing student leaders their moment in the sun. Young people need to chart out career paths and Worden was doing it well here. But this kind of courting of the right wing media does become problematic when student leaders prevaricate on national TV, as Worden did on Tucker Carlson’s show, distorting campus events so as to slander the university and foment sensationalism, playing to the prejudices of the far right against the university – demonized as a left wing pc indoctrination center -- instead of being truthful. Worden did this on Carlson’s show when he falsely accused the UC Berkeley administration of being too “cowardly” to stand up to violent protesters who disrupted “high and low profile” conservative speakers on campus – making it sound as if the BCR’s speakers were regularly disrupted by force, which is simply untrue.61 Indeed, an on-line BCR forum hosted by Worden and another BCR leader in April 2017, made it clear that disruptions of their speakers was a rarity, and that they were able to “host a large amount of conservative speakers. It’s just the controversial ones that get the headlines. Almost every other week,” explained Worden’s fellow BCR activist Elias W., “there’s another guest speaking at our meetings, for instance, just recently we had WW2 vet and journalist Charles Wiley speak to our club, Republican Assemblyman Rocky Chavez, Bay Area GOP Chair, former SF GOP head Harmeet Dhillon, RNC Committeeman Shawn Steel, Ben Shapiro, the list goes on.”62

Worden also told Carlson that when the anti-Yiannopoulos riot occurred at Berkeley the campus police did nothing because they had been ordered to “stand down,” apparently by UC’s liberal university administration, which was also untrue.63 Indeed, in suggesting that the Berkeley campus police were derelict in their duty during the riot because they did not abandon their positions at the entrances of the Berkeley student union building to arrest the rioters -- which the police chose not to do because they were outnumbered and did not want to risk harming the many non-violent students who the antifa rioters used as shields -- Worden was insulting the officers whose actions had saved him from injury. Had the police not stood their ground, the rioters would have been able to enter the student union that they had besieged, where they could and almost certainly would have assaulted Worden and the others who were hosting the Yiannoupolos event, along with Yiannoupolos and his entourage.64

The implications of Worden’s condemnation of the way the UC Berkeley administration and its police force handled the riot were ugly; he was suggesting that Berkeley’s liberal administration was coddling the rioters. This was a form of guilt by association, in that he implicated liberals—the leaders of UC Berkeley’s administration -- in the violence of the far Left, ignoring the fact that the administration had deployed what for the campus was an almost unprecedented police presence, 85 officers, to prevent violence and protect the Yiannoupolos speaking event (no one could have foreseen the invasion of the campus by some 150 or so black-clad antifas organizing a riot), and then sent out for reinforcements from the Oakland Police department for help in ending the riot.65 As suggested above, Worden’s attack on the liberal university was likely done in part to appeal to Carlson and his right wing viewers, and to make a name for himself on national TV. But there was clearly more going on here than mere posturing for the Carlson and his TV audience. Nils Gilman, who, on behalf of the Berkeley chancellor’s office, interacted with the BCR leadership throughout the free speech crises of 2017, came away convinced that their “motives and strategy” were “less about ideology than about trolling: they believe that getting the far left to overreact de-legitimates the liberals – since, as is common on the right, they dismiss any distinction between these two positions; many of them are acting in patent bad faith – and yes, I think they are utterly cynical about the [university as an] institution, which they see as a cultural fifth column, which they are happy to do their part in destroying.”66

Though Gilman’s analysis may seem harsh, Worden’s own words in the on-line forum Worden co-hosted for the BCR in April 2017, attest to the validity of Gilman’s critical reading of Worden and the BCR leadership in the early Trump era. Worden’s posts in that forum express hostility to UC Berkeley and to the liberal university nationally, which he depicts as breeding grounds not only for liberal indoctrination but violent radicals. According to Worden, “If you look at what academia has become since the 1960s, it’s easy to understand why universities have become factories for producing orthodox, bien pensant liberal students in the same cookie-cutter ideological mold. And because academia is self-propagating, it becomes an endlessly repeating example of confirmation bias and groupthink. The vast majority of humanities departments are filled with people who are easily offended and who regularly compare Trump to Hitler. They should not be surprised when their students believe them and use violence to prevent the rise of the next “fascist” regime.”67 Here you have all of the elements Gilman described: the depiction of the university as a cultural fifth column, the conflating of liberalism with the far Left, and a view of the university that is hostile and cynical.

While it is true that the Berkeley faculty (as well as the professoriate nationally) is, as Worden suggests, disproportionately liberal, the notion that it engages in ideological indoctrination is dubious and the claim that it seeds political violence among its students is over the top. The number of students who engaged in political violence at Cal (most of whom are affiliated with the small By and Means Necessary group) is minuscule, and those who even endorse such violence also constitute a very small minority of Berkeley’s 40,000 students.68 Were this not the case, the antifa riot on February 1, 2017, would surely have been a student-run operation, when in fact less than a handful of the 150 or so rioters were – according to the campus police – students.69 A 2017 survey, noted that the vast majority of first year Berkeley students supported hearing from speakers on all sides of the political spectrum.70 It should also be noted that the chancellor of UC Berkeley not only championed Yiannopoulos’ right to speak on campus, and turned down faculty and student calls to cancel the speech, but also wrote an open letter to the university community condemning both the riot and the op-eds published in the Daily Californian that came in from the far Left defending the riot on anti-fascist grounds.71 In the realm of causality, however, the fact that Worden’s view of the university was inaccurate is less important than his underlying hostility to the university since that hostility makes plain that his motivations for inviting Yiannoupolos were linked to a desire to place the university in the most negative light possible.

In light of Worden’s charges that liberal faculty inspire student violence, there is an ironic quality to the way he discussed violence in the BCR’s on-line forum. Though one would expect any critic of political violence to express regret and outrage over the riot that prevented Yiannopoulos from speaking and did $100, 000 in property damage to the university, Worden did not react that way. On the contrary, he depicted the riot as a big win for the BCR: “the problem,” wrote Worden, “is that violent and absurd actions and beliefs of groups such as BAMN will go unchallenged unless they are brought to national attention; that is what we succeeded in doing by inviting Milo to Berkeley.”72

Though it is jarring to hear an aborted speech and a major riot described as a success by one of the key sponsors of that speech, Worden was looking at the event in terms of his organization’s and his own self-interest. He even boasted in a BCR on-line forum that the riot was a real plus for the BCR since “our membership has increased greatly since the whole Milo fiasco. Many students have … become interested in ‘coming out of the closet’ as conservative or moving more to the center after what they’ve seen. Antifa is actually making students more conservative not less; their tactics have backfired.”73 Worden’s fellow BCR organizer Elias W. concurred, explaining in the BCR on-line forum that “If anything, things like the Milo protests, and the violence/property destruction has helped our group to grow immensely.74

There is a clear connection between the BCR’s lack of concern about the cruelty of Yiannapoulos’s political discourse and the upbeat way that Worden and Elias W. viewed the riot at Cal. In both cases, there was an indifference to the welfare of the larger university community. If students from vulnerable minority groups were upset or hurt by Yiannapoulos’s bigoted rhetoric that was no concern of the BCR; if university property was damaged by the riot, so what? So long as liberal hypocrisy was exposed, leftist violence provoked and blamed on the liberal university. For Worden and other activists in this militant right wing, liberal classmates were not friends, and liberal professors were not mentors – both were enemies in this view of the university as a political war zone. As Worden explained in a BCR on-line forum, “It’s too easy to ignore the crazy things your peers and professors say. Call them out, stand up for what you believe in. Be willing to lose ‘friends’ who cannot rationally disagree with you…. As Churchill said, ‘You have enemies? Good. That means you’ve stood up for something, sometime in your life.’”75

Though Worden was the most vocal and confrontational BCR leader in the early Trump era, he was not alone in his hostile view of the liberal university and its leadership. Naweed Tamhas, the BCR’s external vice president, echoed Worden’s charge that the university had coddled violent radicals who shut down the Yiannopoulos speech, and he even sought to trace the origins of such supposed permissiveness to UC administration liberalism. Among the documents included as an exhibit in the second law suit the BCR and the Young America’s Foundation filed against the university for allegedly suppressing conservative speech, is an e-mail Thamas sent to UC Campus Police Captain Alex Yao charging that the UC police department (UCPD) “stood idly by the night of [the anti-Yiannopoulos] protests on February 1st as both civil demonstrators and attendees were assaulted by masked criminals.”76 Thamas attributed this police passivity to “the Robinson-Edley Report,” a UC policy statement written in the aftermath of complaints about police brutality generated by the police baton charge against Berkeley’s version of Occupy Wall Street demonstrators (the UC campus name for these protests was Occupy Cal) back in 2011. Thamas actually believed that this liberal document, the Robinson-Edley Report, “encouraged … university police to take a hands-off approach when violence breaks out.” 77 And he was writing Yao to inquire as to whether the “UCPD will respond differently than it did on February 1st in the case of a violent outbreak “ at its next major speaker event (Ben Shapiro), scheduled for September 2017.78

This Thamas message to Yao is in its way an extraordinarily revealing document, attesting to the power that right wing ideology and alienation from the liberal university had to blind this BCR leader to political reality. That ideology and alienation led Thamas, a junior at Cal, to believe that a liberal university would issue a report encouraging a “hands off approach” by police “when violence breaks out,” is simply astonishing since, of course, no university administration would ever encourage its campus police to ignore such criminality, and no police officers sworn to enforce the law would agree to breach their duty to halt and prevent violent criminal acts. Such a misreading of university policy derives from right wing stereotypes concerning liberal permissiveness being applied here to university administration and campus police rather than from the Robinson Edley report – which Thamas either never read or misunderstood. Just as groundless, of course, was his claim that the UCPD “stood idly by” while the anti-Yiannopoulos riot occurred. Thamas’s implication that the UCPD and UC administration were indifferent to violence was all the more misguided and wrongheaded in that it came as these police and campus officials were in the process of planning one of the most elaborate and expensive security operations in UC Berkeley’s history – including the closure of six campus buildings and the deployment of an army of police – to protect the BCR’s upcoming Shapiro event.79

Chief Margo Bennett of UCPD and Interim Vice Chancellor of Student Affairs, Steve Sutton responded to Thamas’ message, about which they expressed “regret” over its “unfortunate tone and inaccurate factual content.”80 Bennett and Sutton explained to Thamas that his message “grossly mischaracterizes the Robinson-Edley report, falsely claiming that the report encourages police ‘to take a hands-off approach when violence breaks out.’ In fact, the Report clearly states that its general framework of restraint in police use of force, ‘must include explicit exceptions for responding to threats of violence and other exigent circumstances…. When confronted with a dangerous situation, our police officers should not be constrained in their ability to protect against property damage or injury, to themselves or others (Robinson-Edley Report at p. 80).’”81 Bennett and Sutton also wrote Thamas that it had been wrong of him to “falsely accuse our sworn law officers of “idly standing by” while the anti-Yiannopoulos riot occurred. “Both of us” explained Bennett and Sutton, “were on the scene last February when, in an unprecedented development more than 100 armed members of the Black Bloc paramilitary group invaded the campus with the intention of shutting down Mr. Yiannopoulos’s event. Rather than officers ‘idly standing by,’ what we saw was dozens of dedicated law enforcement officials who, despite being outnumbered, willingly put themselves in harm’s way to hold the building and safely evacuate your guests and members of your organization, the Berkeley College Republicans…. Far from ‘standing down,’ on multiple occasions teams of UCPD charged into the mayhem to extract individuals they observed under attack.”82

It was not unreasonable for leaders of a conservative student group to be sensitive to bias from the administrators of an overwhelmingly liberal university. But Thamas, Worden and like minded-BCR members went well beyond this, to a view of the university that crossed over into cynicism that bred an almost paranoid interpretation of the actions of the university administration. This was visible, for example, in the way Worden discussed the actions and motivations of the Berkeley administration regarding the security fees it asked for in relation to the first Mlio Yiannapoulos event. According to Worden’s post in a BCR on-line forum, “the initial quote for (mandatory) security we received from the university was $10,000. We believe this was an attempt to scare us into cancelling the event. We held our ground, and the university issued a final fee of $6,500.”83 This charge that the UC administration wanted to use security costs as a weapon to frighten the BCR into cancelling the Milo Yiannapoulos talk is not merely groundless, it is ludicrous. Chancellor Dirks, as we have seen, had publicly championed the right of Yiannapoulos to speak on campus despite his distaste for this speaker’s assaultive and bigoted rhetoric. Indeed, Dirks, in an open letter, turned down on free speech grounds the request of more than 100 faculty to cancel the Yiannapoulos talk. As to the $10,000 figure, it was mentioned by UC officials initially only as a rough estimate of security costs for the Yiannapoulos event, pending a more detailed review by the UC Police department, a review that came up with a smaller fee of $6,370.84 In other words, the final fee was lower not because the BCR, as Worden boasted, “held our ground” against an administration seeking to “frighten the BCR into cancelling” its far right speaker but because the police in their viewpoint-neutral security assessment came up with $6,370 as the final figure for the security fee.

This, however, only begins to get at how disingenuous Worden’s account of the fee issue was in that on-line BCR forum. As we have seen, Worden falsely claimed that BCR resistance to repressive administrators had resulted in the lower final security fee of $6,500, presenting the $6,500 figure (the correct figure was $6,370) as a victory for the BCR. But in a letter to Chancellor Dirks three weeks before the Yiannopoulos event the BCR had complained about the $6,370 security fee, which it denounced as “arbitrary and excessive… In effect, the University is restricting BCR’s constitutional rights to free expression by charging fees for unsolicited security that amount to a tax on a ‘controversial speaker…. It is apparent that the $6,370-tax is specifically designed to prevent the BCR from successfully bringing Milo Yiannopoulos to the University.”85 The BCR then went on to threaten the university with a law suit, “injunctive relief in court if the security fee is not eliminated in its entirety.” 86 In other words, the BCR was claiming that if the university charged them even a modest security fee this constituted a free speech violation and an attempt to block their right wing speaker.

This last accusation was wildly inaccurate and reflected either ignorance of the costs of major speaking events, paranoia about the university, dishonesty – or some combination of the three. A security fee was not some sinister weapon that the university administration deployed against the BCR to stifle its right wing speaker, but was a standard requirement for large events on campus. As university counsel Chris Patti explained in his response to the BCR complaint, “The First Amendment does not immunize event sponsors from the requirement to reimburse the University for the reasonable cost of providing event security, so long as security fees charged are not arbitrary or content based…. It is the regular practice of the University to charge event sponsors such fees based on content-neutral factors such as the venue, the type of event, the number of anticipated guests, whether tickets are sold, and if the university is open to non-university guests. The university has routinely and neutrally applied this policy to charge sponsors comparable fees for appearance of a wide range of speakers, including Anita Hill, Lewis Farrakhan, Will Farrell, Rand Paul, Justice Sonia Sotomayor and the Dalai Lama, and your claim that ... security fees have not been charged for similar events is baseless. Similarly baseless is your contention that the University’s failure to give BCR special treatment with regard to security fees is motivated by a desire to block your event.”87

Actually, when one considers the total costs for security that the university incurred in in connection with the February Yiannoupolos event these BCR complaints about the security fee seem ridiculous. Given the threats the university was receiving for hosting the talk, and the disruptions and violence that had erupted at earlier stops on Yiannoupolos’ national campus tour, the university opted to beef up the police presence for the event, so that it included – a sizable police presence, and the total security costs came out to $220,000. With the university paying so much to protect their event and then suffering $100,000 in property damage from the riot provoked by this first Yiannapoulos event it is quite striking – and evidences an obvious right wing bias against the liberal university -- that any BCR leader would complain about or claim political discrimination on account of their being assessed such a small security fee.88

Indeed, since Worden and like-minded BCR leaders were wedded to a view of the university administration as the liberal enemy of conservatism, it was almost impossible for them to credit the university with being fair-minded, let alone generous in its relationship with the BCR – even when the evidence of such fair-mindedness and generosity was overwhelming. This can be seen in Worden’s discussion of the way the security fee issue was resolved after the riot. Worden acknowledged that in the end, “the Milo event” cost the BCR only “a few hundred dollars.”89 This was because the university decided that since the riot led to the cancellation of the Yiannopoulos talk it would dispense with the standard security fee, and absorb virtually all the costs. Rather than thank the university for waving the fee, Worden claimed (without evidence) that “the university was clearly afraid of the bad PR [public relations] they would receive if they made us pay such an outrageous amount of money [ie $6,500 out of the $220,000 security costs] for an event that they cancelled.”90 Actually the decision to wave the fee had nothing to do with PR, but was “simply standard best practice not to charge for event security if the event does not take place due to circumstance beyond the host’s control.”91 Indeed, had the administration waved the fee for PR purposes it would obviously have coordinated this decision with UC Berkeley spokesperson and PR leader Dan Mogulof, but in fact, Mogulof only found out about the waved fee “after the BCR did.”92

About the only accurate part of Worden’s account of the fee issues was his assertion that “We had attorneys ready to sue if we were made to pay these costs.”93 This threat to sue the university was not empty rhetoric. Both the dominant faction of the BCR, which had convinced itself that the liberal university sought to suppress conservatism, and its off campus financial angel, the wealthy far right Young America’s Foundation, eager to sue liberal universities, joined forces in April 2017 in filing a law suit charging Cal with view point discrimination against campus conservatives and their guest speakers.94 The suit centered on Ann Coulter, the next major far right media star -- a nativist extremist who specialized in demonizing Latino immigrants -- that the BCR invited to UC Berkeley. Though the free speech dispute over Coulter was phony, it was so cleverly instigated by the BCR and fanned by Coulter, a publicity hound, that most of the media fell for the rouse. The BCR launched the controversy when it announced – without having secured a room, arranged security, or consulted with

the campus administration – that Coulter would be speaking on campus the last week of classes. When it turned out that no room large or secure enough for the Coulter event was available on campus during this hectic week of the semester, the BCR charged that the administration had cancelled the event, when in fact no such event had ever been officially scheduled so there was nothing to cancel – a crucial fact that the gullible news media missed.95

The UC administration then offered Coulter a venue on campus during the week before finals, known as “Review, Reading, and Recitation week” (also known as “dead week”) when students have no classes so they can prepare for their exams. But Coulter, playing the free speech martyr, turned down this offer, claiming in a tweet that students would not be on campus to attend her talk that week “BECAUSE THERE ARE NO CLASSES AT BERKELEY.”96 This was a ridiculous claim, because, as every Berkeley student knows – and as several explained in the Daily Californian --“there are lots of people on campus during dead week – libraries are always packed”; “Many events happened on campus during dead week”; “Students are more likely to go [to hear Coutler during dead week than during the regular semester] because there are no classes. There are less [time] commitments.”97 As UC spokesperson Dan Mogulof put it, “Where do they think students go before finals? To the beach?”98

The BCR-YAF law suit also sought to indict the Berkeley’s campus emerging major events policy as discriminatory. That policy required that controversial speaking events that generated threats to public safety be held in the day time and end before 3:00. The BCR and YAF viewed this as a way to keep the audiences small for conservative speakers. But the actual purpose of the policy was to avoid another riot, and keep controversial events safe so the First Amendment rights of even unpopular speakers could be protected. Had the university not sought out such new policies to prevent another riot and learn from the mistakes of February 1, (when the cover of darkness aided the antifa rioters and the night time rush hour delayed the police reinforcements requested from Oakland) it would have been negligent in the life and death area of public safety. But such safety concerns were virtually ignored by these right wing plaintiffs hungry for litigation and eager to accuse the university of some sinister political bias. Though the initial suit was quickly dismissed, the YAF and BCR would file a second suit, this time joined by Attorney General Jeff Sessions and Donald Trump’s Justice Department.99

This was not the first time the Trump administration aligned itself with the BCR in its feud with the UC administration. After the anti-Yiannopoulos riot, President Trump had sent out a tweet falsely claiming that the university had suppressed free speech and fomented violence against dissenters: “If U.C. Berkeley does not allow free speech and practices violence on innocent people with a different point of view – NO FEDERAL FUNDS?”100 With his characteristic disregard for the facts and the truth, Trump was accusing the the University of California at Berkeley, whose administration had defended Yiannopoulos’ right to speak, with suppressing free speech, and accusing the university of fomenting violence against dissenters, when in fact it had extra police on hand to seeking to prevent such violence against the Yiannopoulos event. This was not merely a case of blaming the victim – since the university had been the victim of violence perpetrated by armed and masked leftist vigilantes- but of also threatening the victim, since Trump’s tweet pondered removing federal funds from the university for its alleged acts of political discrimination. Ignoring its gross inaccuracies and unfairness, BCR activists were so delighted by Trump’s attack on the university that they designed and began wearing t-shirts quoting it: “De-fund?”101

It is difficult to say which act by the BCR’s dominant leadership faction was the most hostile to the university: Misleading the public via the media into believing the university suppressed conservative speech? Cheering Trump’s threat to de-fund their university? Suing the university for imaginary free speech violations? Boasting about the positive impact that a major campus riot had on their organization? Bringing speakers to campus who they knew would offend and upset vulnerable minorities on their campus? Not since the heyday of SDS and the New Left in its most revolutionary phase in the late 1960s has such deep hostility towards the university been displayed by student activists, and even SDS’ hostility towards the university was mostly directed at it as a surrogate for the defense establishment rather than at the university as a cultural fifth column. It took not merely the leadership of far right students like Worden, but reinforcement from influential off campus figures and institutions, from Donald Trump to Fox News to the YAF, to get the leadership cadre of even this relatively small conservative student organization – the BCR had at most only a few dozen activists – to embrace so negative of view of the university.102

There was a strong element of conservative identity politics involved in breeding the kind of mindset that could lead to such hostility to the university and end up with the Yianopoulos invitations. In a university so strongly identified as a center of liberalism and with a vocal student and faculty Left, conservative students felt, as one UC official observed, that “they have not got an equal footing or voice in the university, and promote themselves as behind enemy lines fighting the good fight.”103 Yet for all their boasting about their courage in defying a campus world mostly to the left of them, being such a small and unpopular ideological minority was stressful in that “they did not feel free or comfortable in the classroom environment or among their peers in talking honestly about their ideas with students from the other side. They really, really don’t feel that they can do that.”104 Such feelings led to not only the kind of alienation discussed earlier, but a disillusionment with the university, and an almost tribal identification with their conservative classmates and organizations. This can be seen in the autobiographical story that one BCR activist told an adviser: “He shared that he came to Berkeley excited to come to a place where there was going to be rigorous debate and classroom discussion about everything and he felt he did not actually get that. He came with unpopular views. And the only place he felt he could feel comfortable expressing those views was within the BCR and the Patriot.”105

This yielded a strong “us against them” mindset, which connects up with the free speech issue and the Yiannopoulos invitation. Since as conservatives they did not often feel free at Cal to express their views, they eagerly embraced the Yiannopoulos invitation as a way of surfacing and challenging liberal intolerance towards right wing expression – which was for them a central part of their free speech cause, that they knew his far right provocations would leave the Left irate and calling for the event to be shut down, proving that Berkeley had a free speech problem. In this sense, as one UC official put it, “their purpose was the symbolism of what Milo represented not what Milo actually was.”106 This was yet another reason why they evaded questions about Yiannopoulos’s bigotry, as it did not serve their own goals of making a statement about free speech and their own identity as an unpopular conservative minority. And, as this UC official explained, one must keep in mind their youth, that “they’re 19 and 20; they’re deeply committed to their cause and oblivious to things that lessen the righteousness of their cause…. In private they would be more thoughtful and indicate that they didn’t like what [Milo] was saying, but he gave them the hammer that they needed, that they wanted, to drive home the very basic free speech concept… [and] they may not have had another way of getting that hammer.”107

But the parochialism of this form of identity politics was so pronounced that it made the way the Right used the free speech issue seem not ennobling but petty and mean-spirited. As one dean explained it, these right wing students, “they’re like all marginalized students. They want to say ‘FUCK YOU’ to the man, and there is no better way to say ‘fuck you’ than [inviting] Milo Yiannopoulos [to campus]. He’s a big Fuck You package wrapped up and tied with a bow.”108 Campus officials tried to get these students to see beyond themselves, but the right wing students proved incapable of empathizing with the fears and anxieties that, for example, this nativist speaker, aroused in undocumented immigrant students. As one advisor explained, the problem was “it doesn’t serve their purposes to have that empathy. Believe me we tried [to elicit such empathy]. We had many conversations with them about impact vs. intent. ‘You don’t feel safe saying something [conservative] in class. How do you think an underrepresented student felt when they were being threatened with deportation? We’d taken every opportunity to take that complexity of discussion into the room with those students.’” 109

The invasion of the campus by riotous anti-fas was an unprecedented event that nobody could have predicted. But nowithstanding the BCR leadership’s crowing about how the riot’s backlash increased their membership and visibility, the ugly violence actually made the BCR an even more unpopular group on campus since vocal critics blamed the Yiannopoulos invitation for inciting the riot.110 From the far Left, as we have seen, came plaudits for the antifas for doing what the administration supposedly lacked the backbone to do : protect UC’s vulnerable minorities, especially undocumented students, from Yiannopoulos and his bigoted followers.111 Such defenses of political violence were aired so fervently in the student newspaper that Chancellor Dirks responded with an op-ed condemning this authoritarian mindset.112 More mainstream students were furious at both the antifas and the BCR for making their campus a political battlefield and damaging their student union building – which is why concerned students woke up at dawn to help clean up the broken glass left by the riot.113 This anger would only intensify as the BCR’s escalating efforts to bring other far right provocateurs to campus – including Ann Coulter – yielded more conflict and required yet more security that was even more disruptive of the academic environment. In other words, the Yiannopoulos invitation ended up solving none of the problems right wing students had been concerned about, and instead served to exacerbate Left- right tensions on campus.

Making matters worse, the BCR leadership refused to take any responsibility for having helped provoke the violence.114 Obviously the antifas’ vigilanteism was the prime culprit in the riot. But with the BCR writing and making statements asserting that they were blameless -- that “they should be able to have speakers come to say whatever horrible things and not have to thing about security because … people should not be violent” – made them seem yet more irresponsible and arrogant. Riot or no riot, they, as one UC official put it, “still believe that when a person has violence it is not because of what they are doing. It’s because of that person’s violence, lawlessness. They really, really don’t understand -- and we really tried to get them to see – that they have a responsibility for provoking that reaction.”115

The Yiannopoulos invitation and the riot had one other negative effect on Berkeley student politics. It fostered among BCR leaders an embrace of a distorted critique of the UC Berkeley administration’s free speech record that would, as we have seen, continue through the Coulter affair and beyond. That critique originated in the right wing echo chamber, emanating from Trump’ misleading tweet, Fox News, and the YAF, and held that the UC administration was at war with the free speech rights of conservatives on campus – carrying on as if the UC administration’s cancellation of the Yiannopoulos talk was some kind of free speech violation rather than a move to save lives amidst a riot, and that this was a part of some broader agenda to purge conservatism from the liberal university. Such a critique was a product of the far right’s imagination and was not indigenous to the Berkeley campus since everyone active in Berkeley student politics knew that regulating the content of speech was akin to the third rail in the Cal campus’ political world, something the Berkeley administration had stopped doing in the 1960s as a consequence of the Free Speech Movement. The fact that the dominant faction of the BCR in the early Trump era could embrace such an absurd critique was, as suggested earlier, a testament to their profound sense of alienation – and was a consequence of the riot which in its own way was as costly to the university’s reputation as was the riot itself.

Here a reminder is in order that we must be wary of painting the entire BCR with the same broad brush, and assuming that the kind of flirting with the alt right and feuding with the UC administration that BCR leader Worden went in for was popular with the entire BCR membership and leadership. Even Peter Sittler, who had co-written with Worden that op-ed defending Yiannopoulos did not join with him in fabricating his narrative of a hypocritical liberal UC Berkeley administration conspiring to suppress conservative speech. In fact, Sittler, a BCR Vice President, told the Washington Post right after the February campus riot that Berkeley chancellor Nicholas Dirks “worked tirelessly to plan [the (Yiannapoulos) event and make sure it went through.” Sittler praised the university for having “acted in good faith” and being “fully committed to protecting our First Amendment rights.” 116 And, as noted earlier, the presence of BCR dissatisfaction with Worden’s leadership took another semester to make itself known, but in late October 2017 that dissent led to Worden’s impeachment on the grounds that the BCR ought to be working to train activists and promote education in conservative ideas “not to troll the university.”117

Even so, it must be kept in mind that neither the February riot nor the Yiannapoulos pedophilia scandal – which had led to his resignation from Bretibart news, the cancellation of his book contract with a major publisher, and his being disinvited from speaking at the American Conservative Union convention -- could keep right wing students at Berkeley from inviting him back to Berkeley for a the fall 2017 speaking engagement. This time the sponsoring group was not the BCR itself but an on-line far right publication that a handful of conservative students staffed, The Berkeley Patriot. Not a single word of criticism of Yiannapoulos scandalous remarks on pedophilia was uttered publicly by any right wing student leader at Berkeley. And in fact, Worden, told the Daily Californian “that the BCR has no comment on Yiannapoulos’ remarks on pedophilia.”118

The Berkeley Patriot staff proved as unwilling in the summer and fall of 2017 as the BCR has been in early 2017 to take a hard look at Yiannopoulos’ bigotry While the Charlottesville tragedy in summer of 2017 so alarmed the Berkeley administration that it went all out in heightening security for right wing speaking events in the fall, that tragedy had not dampened at all the Berkeley Patriot’s desire to bring far right speakers to campus. In fact, the Berkeley Patriot viewed Charlottesville just as Trump did, as a conflict caused by the anti-racist protester as well as the Nazis.

The most elaborate explanation of why the Berkeley Patriot staff – a small group of less than a half dozen Trumpist right wingers -- was so committed to bringing Yiannopoulos to Berkeley came in a statement read at the Chancellor’s Commission on Free speech. That statement was written anonymously by one member of the Berkeley Patriot staff, and read to the commission by commission member Mariel Goddu, a graduate student in psychology. Goddu was not affiliated with the Berkeley Patriot -- and did not approve of their politics -- but had solicited this statement because she thought it would be useful for the commission since this group’s invitation to Yiannopoulos had contributed to the free speech crisis that the commission was seeking to resolve. The circumstances under which she first met him and other Berkeley Patriot staffers was in itself indicative of the problematic ethics and maturity level of these young activists. She encountered them while walking late at night on the Berkeley campus, when they were tearing down political posters. After Goddu objected, these students sheepishly explained that the posters they were damaging and then photographing were their own, a political prank, which would enable them to pose as the victims of anti-conservative vandalism.119 But because Goddu, a teaching assistant, sought to be understanding and to learn more about them, she did not lecture them or turn them in for their prank, but instead befriended them and inquired about their ideas and experiences as right wing organizers on campus. This is what made it possible for her to solicit and receive the statement on Yiannopoulos from a member of the Berkeley Patriot.

That statement was written by one Berkeley Patriot staffer who claimed he was speaking only for himself, but whose views were obviously common among Berkeley student right wing activists since they so closely resemble those we saw earlier in the writings of the BCR leadership. This statement began by explaining that “the whole point of inviting Milo to campus was to demonstrate that the [university] community’s values are toxic.”120 This was not followed with an explanation of what exactly was toxic about those values, but as with the BCR’s rhetoric, conservative student alienation from the university was front and center. The statement implied that there was too little willingness to listen to dissenting ideas, too much emotion and not enough reason, that those who objected to ideas they disliked should explain why, rather than shutting down access to those ideas.121 In other words, the statement was making a free speech and pluralism argument, and it expressed the hope that the Yiannopulos talk would spark political dialogue rather than protest. Though these were positive statements regarding free speech and the need for political dialogue, just as the BCR’s statements did the previous semester, they ignored what Yiannopoulos had been saying and doing on his campus tour – which was inflaming conflict via assaultive discourse rather than promoting dialogue across the political spectrum. As with the BCR, the Berkeley Patriot ignored his abuse of minorities and his crude and cruel mockery of individuals on campus with whom he disagreed. If one wants to make a free speech argument that makes sense in this context it would be about the right of all views – even hateful ones – to be expressed from the podium of a public university , but this was not the argument the Berkeley Partiot statement made since doing so would have meant dealing with Yiannopoulos’s bigotry and abusive behavior during his campus tour.

Was this second Yiannoupolos invitation offered to show that the violent Left could be overcome and that this time Yiannapoulos actually could speak at Berkeley, restoring the free speech tradition established by the Free Speech Movement? This would be the most generous reading of the Berkeley Patriot staff’s motivations. But the Berkeley Patriot’s level of hostility to the university in their on-line publication, their intense anger at campus liberals, leftists and the Berkeley administration, makes it difficult to avoid the conclusion that defending free speech in this case was secondary, and that attracting attention to the Berkeley right wing and its leaders and using Yiannopoulos to offend, insult, and provoke these political enemies were central motivations for sponsoring his talk.

Just how white hot this anger was in the time leading up to the second Yiannopoulos appearance at Berkeley can be gleaned from a Berkeley Patriot editorial from late August 2017, which spoke directly and resentfully to Berkeley leftists and was equally scathing in its view of the UC Berkeley administration. Here the Berkeley Patriot fumed that “University administrators nearly always cave to your absurd demands, offering you safe spaces and counseling when ‘controversial’ speakers come to campus. You can riot and shut down speech with impunity, free from fear of suspension, expulsion, having scholarships revoked, or even a slap on the wrist. Illegal immigrants can parade around campus bragging about how they are ‘here to stay” despite their immigration status with no consequences whatsoever. When the Berkeley College Republicans set up a table with a Trump sign on it? Their property is destroyed and their members are attacked. Professors who speak out against your worldview risk being blacklisted, protested, and perhaps even fired, in the case of Dr. Keith Fink of UCLA (and many others).”122 Actually, Nils Gilman, the chancellor’s chief of staff, was quite vocal in condemning physical attacks on the BCR, and the Berkeley campus police investigated all reported crimes against the BCR.123 And there is no evidence at all that conservative faculty at Berkeley were persecuted or black listed, which is likely why the authors could only cite a UCLA adjunct’s firing to support this strained argument about academic unfreedom at the liberal university . But again veracity is not the issue here; it is anger, resentment, and alienation. Thus one can bring a far right troll to embody that anger and infuriate the hated student Left, while at the same time valorize this mean- spirited event as a grand chapter in the history of free speech if the talk comes off peacefully, or if it does not use whatever disruption occurs to discredit the Left and the liberal university itself.

Since the Berkeley Patriot’s discussions leading to the second Yiannopoulos invitation to speak at Berkeley have never been made public there is no way of saying for sure if it was all that different from the discussion held at Stanford University by the staff of its right wing publication, the Stanford Review, as it considered extending an invitation for Yiannopoulos to speak on their campus. A conservative present at that meeting recalled that it began with one confused editor of the Stanford Review, arguing that “’Someone should sponsor his lecture – it’s a matter of free speech’…. Soon other editors made different arguments: ‘This will create a huge stir,’ said one. ‘It will drive the [leftwing] social-justice warriors crazy,’ offered another. This was certainly true. Campus leftists would definitely have protested the event, and might even have tried to shut it down. As one influential editor put it: ‘Best-case scenario is that SJWs [social justice warriors] freak out and we get another Berkeley.’ We all knew what he meant: Inviting Yiannopoulos could bait the Left to do something silly and destructive, drawing media coverage that would allow us to act as martyrs for free speech on campus. That is, the left-wing riots were not the price or downside of inviting Yiannopoulos – they were the attraction.”124

While clearly the Berkeley Patriot staff was angry enough at the campus Left to want to bait them a la Stanford, the Patriot case seems somewhat different because this time Yiannopoulos was promising the moon to Berkeley right wing students. Instead of just appearing himself, Yiannopoulos claimed he would bring to Cal in late September 2017, a whole week full of of high profile right wing events, that he called “Free Speech Week,” featuring some of the biggest stars the of the American far right, including Steve Bannon, Ann Coulter, and Charles Murray.125 The chance to host this all-star cast of far right celebrities was so dazzling to these young Berkeley conservatives that there seems little doubt that they were more than eager for these events to be held, and were not hosting this right wing extravaganza to spark a riot. Though of course it is also true that these “Free Speech Week” events, were supposed to include anti-feminist, anti-immigrant, anti-Muslim themes and speakers that were sure to offend, and generate protest from, the campus Left.

One of the ironies of this Yiannopoulos extravaganza is that it was not the student sponsors of these events but Yiannopoulos himself who more closely resembled those right wing editors at Stanford who were more interested in provoking a riot from the Left than holding a speaking event. Yiannopoulos was a narcissistic publicity hound, whose campus tour was much more centered on building his brand as a far right troll and enhancing his celebrity than on the needs and desires of his right wing student sponsors. The riot at Berkeley in February had been great for Yiannopoulos, who received massive media coverage because of it and was lionized on the right as a free speech martyr who had challenged and unmasked the liberal university’s hypocrisy and intolerance. It was only the pedophilia scandal just a few weeks later, that disrupted Yiannopoulos’s ascent as an iconic right wing celebrity. For Yiannopoulos the prospect of another Berkeley riot was deeply attractive, offering a shot at political redemption. Indeed, on the eve of his planned “Free Speech week” at Cal in September 2017, Yiannopoulos told Playboy “I believe the challenge for us is to create something so attention grabbing that it produces another U.C. Berkeley and I can sell another 100,000 copies of the book [he had just published]… Hopefully, God comes out and smiles on us and Antifa fire-bombs the entire university.”126 In other words, the would-be free speech martyr actually had little interest in actually speaking at Berkeley or in bringing other major right wing speakers to join him in what would turn out to be a chimerical “free speech week.” He seemed to be counting on either the Bay Area’s violent left or the UC Berkeley administration to shut down his grandiose but fictional event, and so never finalized invitations to right wing celebrities, most notably, Bannon and Coulter. to join him at Berkeley, despite having indicated that they would be appearing at Cal. This was all a political stunt, and one for which the Berkeley Patriot staff unknowingly were serving as props.

Indeed, UC Berkeley administrators who interacted with Yiannopoulos and his staff in the lead up to his “Free Speech Week,” came to realize that, as Chancellor Christ put it, this “Free Speech Week” was “a fiction. The event was designed to be provocation to try and get us to cancel the event and then to get the news story they wanted” about how the university bars conservative speakers.127 University spokesperson Dan Mogulof agrees that this was “a charade” on the part of Yiannopoulos, “and an effort to get us to say no.” Yiannopoulos and his staff would tell UC officials “We’re coming for a week.” UC responded: “Fine. Yiannopoulos and his staff: “We’re bringing all the people that hate you the most.” UC responded: “Good.” Yiannopoulos and his staff: “We’re going to have it out in Sproul Plaza in the middle of the day.” UC responded: “Excellent.” “And so,” as Mogulof explained, “I think they started to panic a little bit” since the university was not going cancel his “Free Speech Week” and allow him to pose as a free speech martyr victimized by the hypocritically repressive liberals who ran the university.128

It would take a book to document all the machinations and deceptions that Yiannopoulos and his staff employed in connection with “Free Speech Week,” but one in particular stands out since it attests to both his dishonesty and the hollowness of his claims to be a free speech warrior. I am referring to a furious e-mail that Yiannopoulos sent to Mogulof a month before “Free Speech Week.” Yiannopoulos accused Mogulof of having “leaked information to the press” about his upcoming “high profile speaking event, ” which could lead to “violence and destruction of property” and Yiannopoulos threatened to expose this supposedly unethical behavior during Free Speech Week.129 What actually had happened was that in a meeting with the chancellor, Berkeley Patriot staffers had confirmed several of the major speakers. The chancellor informed Moguloff, and as university spokesperson, he, in response to press inquiries, had merely done his job and let reporters know. He did not “leak” this information, as he allowed reporters to attribute the story to him. Mogulof noted “this overlay of incredible irony that this guy who’s coming for ‘free speech week’ is trying to tell me, the spokesperson what I can and can’t say.”130

And why was Yiannopoulos so angry that Mogulof had released the names of the speakers? It’s hard to avoid the conclusion this ire erupted because unknowingly Mogulof had made public the lies Yiannopoulos and his staff had been telling the student sponsors of “Free Speech Week.” They were, as Mogulof put it, “trying to maintain control [over the students working on the event] and what upset them was that this internal manipulation – ‘Oh we’ve got Bannon and Coulter coming, kids, please proceed with what you are doing.’ As soon as that washed down to the public it defeated its purpose because as we now know Bannon and Coulter [ were not coming to Berkeley]… It was a clear case of what was an effective manipulation … of a student group “—and the public release of the phony speaker list was the first step in exposing Yiannopoulos’ lies and manipulation.131

And this brings us to the second irony of the Milo II chapter at Berkeley, that the Berkeley Patriot’s right wing student idealists, in the process of being conned by Yiannopoulos, the far right celebrity they adored, and his staff, were essentially rescued from financial liability and total public humiliation by the liberal university administration they had so scorned. For at least a month the students had been misled by Yiannopoulos into believing that he was not only bringing right wing celebrity speakers with him to Berkeley, but that he was going to pay the fees of the campus venues for “Free Speech Week.” Despite all the hostile rhetoric from the Berkeley Patriot (and the BCR) about the UC Berkeley administration, that administration actually cares about and seeks to assist all of Berkeley’s 1,000 plus student groups to function effectively irrespective of their politics. In fact, as mentioned earlier, the University provides all registered student groups with mentorship through Cal’s LEAD center, which seeks to help student groups develop organizational and leadership skills. With the Milo II events on the horizon, the LEAD advisors encouraged the Berkeley Patriot staff not to be taken advantage of by their celebrity speaker and his staff, financially or in any other way, advice that was especially apt given that Yiannopoulos was failing to come up with promised fees for the venues.132

But because of their conservative idealism, naivete, and inexperience in running major events, the Berkeley Patriot staff was initially, as one Cal official recalled, “unwilling to think about” this advice to be cautious with Yiannopoulos and his representatives, who had their own agenda and who, as it turned out, were deliberately misleading the students on a host of issues.133 Yiannopoulos’s people were objecting to provisions of the contracts for the events, which were common to most university events, and they were lying about the celebrity speakers who would appear at “Free Speech Week.” The students, as this Cal official put it, “wanted to believe” that the source of these problems was the liberal university placing roadblocks in the way of this historic conservative event – and even made such accusations publicly – rather than face up to the dishonesty of their conservative idol. “They got so far down the road [of organizing these “free speech week” events]… feeling pressure to complete their mission” that they were easily “manipulated by Milo’s people… The students did not realize there are people out there that are truly just con men… that there are people out there who will lie and cheat.” 134 The student sponsors also overestimated their own power in relation to Yiannopoulos, assuming that he would have to make good on his promises to them because they controlled access to “the Berkeley platform… that Milo really wanted.”135

And when UC Berkeley administrators got wind of the fact that several of the famous speakers Yiannopoulos had claimed were coming to Cal had not committed to speaking there, they prodded the Berkeley Patriot staff to cease relying on Yiannopoulos and to interact directly with those celebrity speakers to see if they actually planned to speak at “Free Speech Week”—and to get written confirmations of such commitments to speak at Cal. Getting these gullible young students to see that they had been deceived by Yiannopoulos proved a protracted process since they found it so difficult to believe he would deceive them. But as the students began to make contacts with the most prominent speakers Yiannopoulos claimed were coming, they learned that neither Ann Coulter nor Steve Bannon nor Charles Murray were planning to come speak at Berkeley. This debacle with the speakers and the failure of Yiannopoulos to come up with the venue fees before the university deadlines finally woke up some of these students. After deciding not to sign the contracts for most of the speaking venues in the absence of the promised fees by Yiannopoulos, Berkeley Patriot staffers on the eve of “Free Speech Week” withdrew their sponsorship of this Yiannopoulos event (or non-event).136

In the end, Yiannopoulos, having lost his student sponsors and the venues for the Berkeley through his own duplicity, appeared only briefly on Berkeley’s Sproul Plaza. Protected by an army of police – costing the university hundreds of thousands of dollars – he spoke for a few minutes, sung the national anthem, said a prayer, and left.137 The planned week long conservative extravaganza had melted down to this brief appearance on Sproul. Given the enormous expense, the lack of serious intellectual or political content, and the incredible brevity of the Yiannopoulos appearance (which Yiannopoulos also lied about, falsely claiming that the campus police had urged him for security reasons to leave campus), UC Berkeley spokesperson Dan Mogulof was quite apt in terming it “the most expensive photo-op” in Cal’s history.138 By any objective measure the university and its free speech tradition had prevailed, affording Yiannopoulos the freedom and safety to have his Berkeley platform, though he made a fool of himself through his web of lies about his phony “free speech week” and lack of any serious political message on Sproul Plaza. It would be too much, however, for Berkeley’s right wing student leaders to admit publicly that the liberal university had done itself proud while their far right celebrity speaker discredited himself -- a depressing testament to the power of ideology on the far right and the insignificance of facts in the post-truth Trump era.

True to form, the most vocal Berkeley Patriot staffers tried to save face by blaming the right wing’s favorite scapegoat, the liberal university, for the implosion of Free Speech Week. The Berkeley Patriot filed a civil rights complaint with the US Justice Department claiming that UC Berkeley had “suppressed the group’s First Amendment rights.”139 The Patriot spokesperson claimed that the organization ended its sponsorship of Free Speech Week because “it feared alleged retaliation from the campus for the complaint” its lawyer had filed with the Justice Department – as if the university was conspiring against the Patriot in order to pressure it into cancelling Free Speech Week. But, as Moguloff pointed out to the press, UC has spent $800,000 on security for Free Speech Week, and “we aren’t in the habit of spending $1 million on events we are trying to cancel.”140 A Patriot spokesman also claimed that the UC administration had threatened this right wing group with criminal prosecution in retaliation for its Justice Department complaint, and added this charge to its complaint against the university.

These complaints and accusations against the university administration were not merely groundless but dizzying in their topsy turvy quality. UC in seeking to help these student hosts of Free Speech Week had, as we have seen, alerted them to the likelihood that the key speakers Yiannopoulos claimed were coming, were not in fact coming. The university had also repeatedly extended the deadlines for both venue fees and signed contracts to give the disorganized students and the dishonest Yiannopoulos every opportunity to secure the venues.141 And, of course, the university was paying the enormous security costs as well. It would be difficult to imagine anyone being more accommodating to a right wing event’s sponsors than Cal had been here, so the idea that the university was suppressing these students’ First Amendment rights defies all logic.

Equally bizarre was the Patriot’s claims about criminal prosecution. This was a reference to the chancellor’s call for police to investigate whether a hate crime had been committed in connection with the anti-immigrant and anti-LGBT chalkings (and incendiary posters charging students and faculty with supporting terrorists) that appeared on campus on the eve of what was supposed to be free speech week. The chancellor’s statement criticizing these messages did not mention the Berkeley Patriot or any student group, and did not call for the prosecution of the Patriot. So to read her statement as an attempt to use prosecution to threaten or retaliate against the Patriot is far fetched, to put it mildly.142 Judging by the Patriot’s claims, it is evident that its members had a role in this hateful messaging – and with such crude nativist slogans as “Deport them all, build the wall” it is little wonder that the far right at Berkeley had so little appeal on a liberal campus with a large Latino and immigrant student population.143 But in any case, the police determined that no crime had been committed ,so no one in or out of the Patriot was prosecuted. Mogoluf told the press: “These utterly unfounded allegations aimed at the Chancellor would be silly if they weren’t so sad…. This is all part of an ongoing effort to blame others for an event that collapsed when it became evident that most, if not all of the speakers never had any intention of coming… The letter [the Berkeley Patriot sent] to the Justice Department reads like an assignment in short form fiction.”144

Given how transparently inaccurate the Berkeley Patriot’s charges against the university were it may be difficult to believe that even these right wing students believed in their veracity. But from first hand experience, Mogulof learned that at least one of them did. At a campus free speech forum, Mogulof ran into one of the Patriot students who he’d known for a while. So Mogulof showed him the chancellor’s statement on the hateful messaging, pointing out that “it doesn’t mention a student group…. It doesn’t mention the Berkeley Patriot… It doesn’t even state a crime was committed.” So there was no way the message could be seen as a threat of prosecution against the Berkeley Patriot, Mogulof insisted. “No,” the student responded, “it was clear what she meant.” He, as Mogulof put it, “absolutely believed that.”145 Such students, in Mogulof’s view, “came to campus” seeing themselves as an oppressed political minority, and so had “many extra bags filled with anger and resentment,” leaving them unable to look at the university objectively, and usually if not always assuming the worst, even in the face of contrary evidence.146

Chancellor Christ found it “troubling” that such students engaged in demonization of the university and seemed so devoted to an inaccurate view of the university as politically repressive. “One of the things that” Christ “never resolved to her “own satisfaction is whether the students who did feed this [Fox News/Trump] narrative [of the liberal university suppressing conservatism] actually believe it. I think some of them actually did.”147

This also raises the question of where or whether truth fits in to the politics of the far right on campus. At Berkeley in the opening months of the Trump era, the dominant right wing student leadership’s role models, the successful right wing politicians, most notably Trump lie continuously, and demonize liberals with no regard for factual accuracy. Thus the fact that Trump’s tweet about UC Berkeley after the February campus riot falsely accused the university of suppressing dissent and promoting political violence was no problem for at least some right wing students, who, as we have seen , happily sported t-shirts quoting that tweet’s threat to de-fund the university. Or think of Ann Coulter, who Berkeley’s right wing students invited to campus, and who with them orchestrated a fake free speech controversy. Her response in late September to the Free Speech Week controversy was to falsely charge that “Berkeley administrators were dead set on blocking the event ‘and pulled the usual tricks…. They think leftist ideas are so fragile and indefensible that they can allow NO OTHER VIEWPOINTS to be heard on campus. 148To offer this phony indictment of UC Berkeley Coulter had to ignore both the fact that Cal had in mid-September spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on security in order to host successfully right wing pundit Ben Shapiro, and that Yiannopoulos himself was intending, and would be allowed, to speak at Cal by a university administration that spent nearly a million dollars on security to make that possible. With such big name figures on the right carelessly hurling false charges at the university, is it any wonder that their youthful counterparts do the same?

Although the public side of the Free Speech Week debacle was the most covered by the news media, the internal story summarized above of the way the Berkeley Patriot students had been conned by Yiannopoulos was in some respects equally significant. Even as Yiannopoulos was playing them, as we have seen, most of this small group of right wing students, until at least the eve of Free Speech Week, chose to believe his lies and act as if the university rather than their disingenuous celebrity speaker and his staff were deceiving them. This at a time when campus officials were working effectively to protect them and the university by alerting the students to the lies Yiannopoulos was telling them. This raises the question of whether right wing students are, due to their idealism and youth, vulnerable to exploitation by such off campus right wing forces, adults with their own agendas. A similar question may be asked regarding the Young America’s Foundation, and whether without its influence and money anyone other than a few hard core ideologues in the BCR leadership would have opted to to sue the university. 149

This issue of off campus, adult manipulation and exploitation of students is one that has largely escaped the media’s attention – focused as it is on free speech and Left vs right conflicts on campus. Since we have long since left behind the era of in loco parentis, there are limits to what the university can do about this, since it cannot order students away from those adult political operatives and celebrities who seek to push them around or exploit them for their own political, personal, or organizational purposes. Especially on a campus like Berkeley, the media attention it gets makes it a magnet for celebrities and foundations on the far right, whose skills in self-promotion make it difficult, once they are interacting with students, to determine whether student politics actually reflect the views and decisions of students or of adult politicos who are pressuring them. As a UC Berkeley administrator noted, “ Last summer, one of the [Berkeley] Patriot members actually approached me and asked if the University would support them if they decided to withdraw their invite to Milo. He said they were being treated very poorly by Milo and his organization—‘bullied’, as he described it--- and that they feared what would happen should he come to campus. I made clear to him that the decision was theirs to make, and that the campus would support them either way. When the other active member of the Patriot (there were only three or four at most) heard about this he intervened, over-ruled and said the show would go on. My take-aways in that context: The tone and content of the Patriot messaging was entirely dependent on which of them was out front…and one of them was clearly in thrall with the notoriety he obtained (heady stuff for a twenty-something) and Milo’s own celebrity, but also quite intimidated at the same time. I have also heard from student sources that towards the end external parties, not the students were calling most of the shots. I believe they withdrew the invite at external direction to avoid a situation where Milo would have had no excuses for his fraudulent Potemkin event. Finally, to admit that they’d been had, and that the campus had been right all along, would have been deeply humiliating and ruinous for their standing among their fellow travelers.”150

Berkeley being Berkeley, the birthplace of the Free Speech Movement and a national center of Left militancy, in some respects makes this story unique. No university had an antifa- led riot on the scale of Berkeley’s and none had a debacle as wacky as Free Speech Week, with its very public unraveling, culminating with Yiannapoulos’s ridiculous photo-op at Cal, all of which exposed his dishonesty, that after all the fuss over his right to speak at Berkeley, when he finally made it to Sproul Plaza he had absolutely nothing memorable to say, little to say at all, and so with his craving for publicity satisfied he left after his photo-op.

But while unique in its scale and denouement, the Berkeley-Yiannopoulos conflict was with regard to the right wing student mindset and motivations not at all unique. The politics of resentment, anger, and right wing student alienation from the liberal university – fanned by the polarization wrought by the Trump campaign – that had led to the Yiannopoulos speaking invitations at Cal were (and remain) present on many campuses, which is what made his national campus tour possible. This politics of resentment and alienation had roots that preceded Trump’s ascendance, as sociologist Amy Binder and Kate Wood documented in their case studies of the campus right wing in their classic work Becoming Right (2013), though such resentment and alienation escalated exponentially in the Trump era.151 The challenge for university leaders is to work to ease these feelings of alienation and see if it is possible to convince the campus rjght and Left to join in a healthy dialogue, and to cease pretending that baiting each other will ever produce such dialogue.

There is an urgency to this task of political dialogue and healing. Not only to stop the violence and end the bitterness that we have seen at Berkeley. But also to serve the educational mission of the university. Though right wing students had every right to invite Yiannopoulos to speak at Berkeley, his presence did not serve that educational mission. Think of the contrast between the selection of this speaker and the search process universities conduct for professors. In such searches academics look across the nation and the world for the most brilliant, creative, and accomplished scholars who can engage with the university community and relate to students irrespective of their academic field or politics. The motivation is intellectually to enrich the university. In every respect the Yiannopoulos invitation was the opposite of this – a speaker selected because: 1) he was widely reviled; 2) he was practiced at insulting vulnerable campus minority groups; 3) his presence might provoke a disruption and possibly violence on the Left and damage the reputation of the liberal university; 4) he aligned with the politics of resentment of a very small political faction on campus, whose narrow organizational interests might be served by the negative headlines he generated. Note that none of these motivations had anything to do with education, and only the free speech argument makes such a hateful speakers’ presence on campus at all justifiable. If the university is to devote thousands or even millions of its precious educational dollars to outside speakers invited by students, it ought to act in ways that ensure that such speakers serve some educational purpose. Since the university cannot and must not bar even the most educationally worthless speakers from campus, it ought to strive to build the kind of inclusive educational community that right wing students feel a part of, and if that happens, if we build a community in which students on all points of the political spectrum feel valued, and in turn value education and the university itself, they may no longer want to devote time and money to speakers so obviously hostile to the university and barren of educational value.

A good starting place for such community building – suggested by both the LEAD staff and the free speech forum sponsored by Chancellor Christ and PEN – is taking more seriously the task of teaching students to tolerate and constructively engage with classmates whose ideas they may disagree with strongly. During that free speech forum it was suggested that Cal adopt a freshman requirement “on how to dialogue across differences of opinion.”152 One of the faculty present responded: “Isn’t that what we’re supposed to be doing in the classroom?” 153A LEAD center advisor found this “an awesome moment.” That faculty member was “exactly right. Why should there be a need for special training in how to dialogue across differences? That should be something they’re seeing in their classrooms.”154 But apparently it has been something students have not seen nearly enough of at Berkeley, nor – judging by the way political conflicts have played out -- at colleges and universities across the nation. The challenge is teaching students to really listen to each other. And to honor free speech ideals while also aspiring towards an ethic of responsibility, where speakers are asked to be mindful of the impact that belittling and bullying speech acts have on their classmates, the university community, and on the campus as a site for dialogue and education. The university must ask itself why such an ethos of constructive dialogue – and the skills to enact it – seems poorly taught and rarely learned, and how this poor performance in community building can be rectified both in and outside the classroom.

ENDNOTES

  1. I don’t mean to suggest that hard right nastiness was absent from Berkeley student politics (or from US student politics nationally) in the 1980s. There was at UC Berkeley (and other campuses had counterparts, most notably Dartmouth, with its far right Dartmouth Review) a publication that seemed to exist to troll the student Left. It was called The Berkeley Review, and my most vivid memory of it was when its race-baiting was directed at Pedro Noguera, Cal’s talented African American student body president whose presence and radical politics so infuriated this far right publication that it called him “Nic the Nig.” But this publication had virtually no impact on Berkeley student politics nor on my conservative students, who never even mentioned it. ↩︎
  2. Frances Dinkelspiel, “One Day, one night: The Fuse that lit the battles of Berkeley,” Berkeleyside, Jan. 31, 2018. ↩︎
  3. Out of the scores of articles on the Yiannopoulos controversy in the mainstream media in February 2017 following the riot at UC only two probed the reasons that right wing students have been inviting Yiannopoulos to speak at their college and university campuses, and one of those was written by me. See Alyssa Rosenberg, “If College Liberals Are So Naïve, Why Did the Campus Right Fall For Yiannopoulos?” Washington Post, Feb, 21, 2017; Robert Cohen, “The Milo Yiannopoulos Scandal Reveals The Sorry State of Campus Conservatism,” Inside Higher Education, Feb. 23, 2017. Later an anti-alt right conservative published a very revealing article on this topic, grounded in his experience in right wing student politics at Stanford University. See, Elliot Kaufman, “Campus Conservatives Gave the Alt-Right a Platform: They Deserve Their Fair Share of the Blame for the Entirely Predictable Consequences of That Choice,” National Review, August 15, 2017. Note, however, that not even these articles explored, as I will in this paper, why right wing students at Berkeley invited Yiannopoulos to their campus. ↩︎
  4. “Berkeley Community Reacts to Milo Yiannopoulos’ Resignation From Breitbart News, Daily Californian, Feb. 21, 2017. ↩︎
  5. It is worth noting that Berkeley Free Speech Movement (FSM) leader Mario Savio back in1964, shortly after the FSM’s victory (ie. After the Academic Senate of the faculty endorsed the movement’s call for an end to all restrictions on the content of speech at Cal) was already more advanced than the mainstream media would be in 2017 in that he immediately saw that speech acts on campus involved not merely questions of right but also responsibility. Savio at the FSM’s victory rally on Dec, 9, 1964 told the crowd “We are asking that there be no, no restrictions on the content of speech save those provided by the courts. And that’s an enormous amount of of freedom. And people can say things in that area of freedom that are not responsible. Now… we’ve finally gotten into a position where we have to consider being responsible because we now have the freedom within which to be responsible, And I’d like to say at this time… I’m confident that the students and faculty of the University of California will exercise their freedom with the same responsibility they’ve shown in winging their freedom.” (Robert Cohen. “What Might Mario Savio Have Said About the Milo Protest in Berkeley?” The Nation, Feb. 7. 2017). ↩︎
  6. Anon. source 1, telephone interview with the author, June 20, 2018. ↩︎
  7. “Bitter Feud Divided UC Berkeley Republicans as the Club’s Future Hangs in the Balance,” San Jose Mercury News, Oct. 28, 2017; “Berkeley College Republicans President Impeached by President Amid Power Struggle,” Daily Californian, Oct. 12, 2017 ↩︎
  8. “Berkeley Conservative Society Attempts to Foster Civil Discourse in Debate With Cal Berkeley Democrats,” Daily Californian, Nov. 9, 2017. ↩︎
  9. Dan Mogulof interview with the author, May 9,2018, Berkeley; “What is the Berkeley Patriot the Student Group Responsible for Organizing ‘Free Speech Week,’?” Daily Californian, Sept. 18, 2017. ↩︎
  10. Peter Sittler, and Troy Worden, “In Defense of Milo Yiannopoulos” Daily Californian, Jan. 27. 2017. ↩︎
  11. Ibid. ↩︎
  12. “Free Speech Both Ways,” Inside Higher Education, Dec. 5, 2016; Breitbart’s Milo Yiannopoulos Doubles Down on Harassing University of Wisconsin Student,” Media Matters, Dec. 16, 2016 ↩︎
  13. “UC Berkeley Faculty Call for the Cancellation of Milo Yiannopoulos Talk,” Daily Californian, Jan. 10, 2017. ↩︎
  14. Sittler, and Worden, “In Defense of Milo Yiannopoulos. ↩︎
  15. Ibid. ↩︎
  16. Joel Stein, “Milo Yiannopoulos is the Pretty, Monstrous Face of the Alt-Right,” Bloomberg.com/features-2016- America Divided/ Milo Yiannopoulos, Sept. 15, 2016. ↩︎
  17. Sittler, and Worden, “In Defense of Milo Yiannopoulos. In a subsequent op-ed,Sittler, and Worden even claimed “The Berkeley College Republicans are the New Free Speech Movement,” see Peter Sittler and Troy Worden, “Conservative Speech Will Not Be Stifled by Violence,” Daily Californian, Feb. 14, 2017. ↩︎
  18. “How the Shooting at the UW Protest Unfolded,” Seattle Times , Jan, 23, 2017; “Couple Charged in Shooting, Melee during UW Speech by Milo Yiannopoulos, Seattle Times, April 24, 2017. ↩︎
  19. Sittler, and Worden, “In Defense of Milo Yiannopoulos. ↩︎
  20. Ibid. ↩︎
  21. “Berkeley College Republicans Must Not Normalize Hate Speech,” Daily Californian, Jan. 17, 2017. ↩︎
  22. Ibid. ↩︎
  23. Ibid. ↩︎
  24. It is entirely possible – and even likely -- that at least some of Yiannopoulos’s fans on the Berkeley student far right wing were in fact nativists and so embraced Yiannopoulos and his minority-baiting oratory not despite but because of its bigoted character. See, for example, the nativist graffiti that right wing students active in The Berkeley Patriot chalked on campus on the eve of Yiannopoulos’s second visit to the Berkeley campus, described in “Berkeley Patriot Alleges UC Berkeley Retaliation to Chalk Graffiti, Posters in Additional Civil Complaint,” Daily Californian, Oct, 4, 2017. ↩︎
  25. Sittler, and Worden, “In Defense of Milo Yiannopoulos. ↩︎
  26. Elias W. (BCR activist) post in BCR on-line forum, April 2017. ↩︎
  27. Joseph Bernstein, “Alt White: How the Breitbart Machine Laundered Racist Hate,” Buzzfeed, October 5, 2017. ↩︎
  28. Elliot Kaufman, “Campus Conservatives Gave the Alt-Right a Platform” National Review, August 15, 2017. ↩︎
  29. On Spencer, Yiannopoulos said, “I don’t see it as a bad thing that I surround myself with edgy people…. Because they’re interesting. I’m not going to not hang out with someone because the New York Times calls him racist. (“Milo Yiannopoulos is the Pretty, Monstrous Face of the Alt-Right”). ↩︎
  30. Kaufman, “Campus Conservatives Gave the Alt-Right a Platform.” ↩︎
  31. “Breitbart News Published Slur-Filled Talk Given by Senior Editor Milo Yiannopoulos at the University of Delaware, Yiannopoulos: ‘Never Feel Bad for Mocking a Transgender Person,’” Media Matters, Oct. 25, 2016. ↩︎
  32. “Chancellor Reaffirms Values of Respect and Inclusion, UCB Public Affairs, Nov. 9, 2016. ↩︎
  33. Nicholas Dirks interview with the author, June 20, 2018, New York City. ↩︎
  34. Ibid. ↩︎
  35. Ibid. ↩︎
  36. Ibid. ↩︎
  37. Ibid. ↩︎
  38. Ibid. ↩︎
  39. Marissa Reynoso interview with the author, May 10, 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
  40. Ibid. ↩︎
  41. Brad Devlin testimony, Hearings of Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, Feb. 9, 2018. ↩︎
  42. Mark Peterson telephone interview with the author, June 30, 2018. ↩︎
  43. Nils Gilman interview with the author, May 11, 2018, San Francisco, ↩︎
  44. Ibid. ↩︎
  45. Devlin Testimony. ↩︎
  46. Mark Peterson telephone interview. ↩︎
  47. Gilman interview with the author. ↩︎
  48. Ibid. ↩︎
  49. Ibid. ↩︎
  50. Mark Peterson telephone interview. ↩︎
  51. Ibid. ↩︎
  52. Ibid. ↩︎
  53. Dirks interview with the author. ↩︎
  54. Emily Deruy and Thomas Peel, “Bitter Feud Divides UC Berkeley College Republicans as the Club’s Future Hangs in the Balance,” San Jose Mercury News, Oct. 28, 2017. ↩︎
  55. Ibid. ↩︎
  56. Ibid. ↩︎
  57. See, Worden interview on Tucker Carlson, “Campus Craziness,” Fox News, May 29, 2017. ↩︎
  58. “Bitter Feud Divides UC Berkeley College Republicans.” ↩︎
  59. “Right-wing Student Groups Invite Bigoted Trolls to Invade Campus Under Guise of Free Speech,” Daily Californian, Sept. 22, 2017. also who met with Dirks and the Invade Campus Under Guise of Free Speech,” and white nationalism. Thus it is little wonder that ↩︎
  60. Mark Peterson telephone interview. ↩︎
  61. See Worden interview on Tucker Carlson, “Campus Craziness,” Fox News, May 29, 2017. ↩︎
  62. Elias W. post on BCR on line forum, April 2017. ↩︎
  63. Worden interview on Tucker Carlson, May 29, 2017. ↩︎
  64. Margo Bennett interview with the author, May 10, 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
  65. Dirks interview with the author. ↩︎
  66. Nils Gilman to e-mail to the author, April 22, 2018. ↩︎
  67. Troy Worden response to chabanals, BCR on-line forum, April 2017, reddit.com/r/conervative16292jh/were_the_ Berkeley_college_republicans-the-premier/ ↩︎
  68. Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
  69. Margo Bennett interview with the author. ↩︎
  70. UC’s Office of Planning and Analysis survey found that three quarters of entering Berkeley students in 2017 agreed that “the university has the responsibility to provide equal access to safe and secure venues to guest speakers of all viewpoints – even if the ideas are found offensive by some or conflict with the values of the UC Berkeley community,” (Report of the Chancellor’s Commission on Free Speech, April 9, 2018, 6). ↩︎
  71. “UC Berkeley Chancellor Affirms Right of Milo Yiannopoulos to Speak on Campus,” Daily Californian, Jan. 26, 2017; Nicholas Dirks, “Do Not Condone Violence to Suppress Free Speech,” Daily Californian, Feb. 10, 2017. ↩︎
  72. Troy Worden response to catuse, BCR on-line forum, April 2017. ↩︎
  73. Troy Worden response to De Young Republicans Conservatarian, BCR on-line forum, April 2017. ↩︎
  74. Elias W. post, BCR on-line forum, April 2017. ↩︎
  75. Troy Worden response to request for “advice for those of us that are stuck in extremely liberal colleges,” BCR on-line forum, April 2017. ↩︎
  76. Naweed Thamas to Alex Yao, Aug. 23, 2017, Exhibit Q, YAF and BCR v. Janet Napolitano, US District Court, Northern District, SF, Feb, 16, 2018. ↩︎
  77. Ibid. ↩︎
  78. Ibid. ↩︎
  79. Steve Sutton and Magro Bennett to Naweed Thamas, [Aug. 24, 2017], exhibit R, YAF and BCR v. Janet Napolitano, US District Court, Northern District, SF, Feb, 16, 2018. ↩︎
  80. Ibid. ↩︎
  81. Ibid. ↩︎
  82. Ibid. ↩︎
  83. Troy Worden response to question of “how much did the Milo event cost in total?,” BCR on-line forum, April 2017. ↩︎
  84. “Berkeley College Republicans Required to Raise Up to $10,000 to host Milo Yiannopoulos,” Daily Californian, Dec. 26, 2017; “Berkeley College Republicans No Longer Required to Pay Security Fee For Yiannopoulos,” Daily Californian, Feb. 2, 2017. ↩︎
  85. Berkeley College Republican to Nicholas Dirks, Jan 11, 2017, copy in author’s possession. ↩︎
  86. Ibid. ↩︎
  87. Chris Patti to Berkeley College Republicans, Jan 12, 2017, copy in author’s possession. ↩︎
  88. On the $220,000 cost, see, “Here’s How Much… [It Costs When an Incendiary Speaker Comes to Campus.” USA Today College, Sept 23, 2017. ↩︎
  89. Troy Worden response to question of “how much did the Milo event cost in total?,” BCR on-line forum, April 2017. ↩︎
  90. Ibid. ↩︎
  91. “Berkeley College Republicans No Longer Required to Pay Security Fee For Yiannopoulos,” Daily Californian, Feb. 2, 2017; Mogulof e-mail to the author, July 12, 2018. ↩︎
  92. Mogulof e-mail to the author, July 12, 2018 ↩︎
  93. Worden response to question of “how much did the Milo event cost in total?” ↩︎
  94. “Law Suit Filed Against Berkeley For Canceling Ann Coulter Speech,” Washington Post, April 24, 2017. Note that both the headline and lead in this story typify the media’s poor reporting on the Coulter incident at Cal. As will be discussed below, her speech was never “cancelled” by the university. ↩︎
  95. Krissy Eliot, “Ann Coulter at Berkeley: Untangling the Truth,” California Magazine, May 8, 2017; Nils Gilman interview with the author; Dan Mogulof interview with the author; “UC Berkeley Administrators Propose Rescheduling of Ann Coulter event to September,” Daily Californian, April 19, 2017; Nicholas Dirks interview with the author. ↩︎
  96. “Misconceptions Concerning Ann Coulter’s Now-Cancelled Visit to Campus,” Daily Californian, April 25, 2017. ↩︎
  97. Ibid. ↩︎
  98. Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
  99. “US Department of Justice Supports Free Speech Lawsuit Against UC Berkeley,” Daily Californian, Jan. 28, 2018. ↩︎
  100. Donald J. Trump tweet, 6:13 AM- Feb 2, 2017, ↩︎
  101. Marisa Reynoso interview with the author. ↩︎
  102. A BCR officer told the San Jose Mercury New that the BCR had 45-80 active members. See “Bitter Feud Divides UC Berkeley Republicans,” San Jose Mercury News, Oct, 28, 2017. But judging by its generally small meetings and social media trail those numbers seem quite inflated, and one or two dozen seems a more accurate count. ↩︎
  103. Anon. source 1 telephone interview with the author. ↩︎
  104. Ibid. ↩︎
  105. Ibid. ↩︎
  106. Ibid. ↩︎
  107. Ibid. ↩︎
  108. Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
  109. Anon. source 1 telephone interview with the author; Marisa Reynoso interview with the author. ↩︎
  110. Daryl Ansel interview with the author, May 9, 2018, Berkeley. ↩︎
  111. Nisa Dang, “Check Your Privilege When Speaking of Protests,” Daily Californian, Feb. 7. 2017; Juan Pietro, “Violence Helped Ensure Safety of Students,” Daily Californian, Feb. 7, 2017. ↩︎
  112. Nicholas Dirks, “Do Not Condone Violence to Suppress Free Speech,” Daily Californian, Feb. 10, 2017 ↩︎
  113. Daryl Ansel interview with the author ↩︎
  114. Troy Worden, “UC Berkely Students Should Respect Free Speech Rights of Conservatives, Daily Californian, Sept, 8, 2017. Devlin testimony at Free Speech Commission hearing. ↩︎
  115. Anon. source 1 ↩︎
  116. “Berkeley College Republicans VP: University ‘Worked Tirelessly to Protect Our Rights,” Washington Post, Feb 3, 2017. ↩︎
  117. Bitter Feud Divides UC Berkeley College Republicans, San Jose Mercury News, Oct 28, 2017 ↩︎
  118. “Berkeley Community Reacts to Milo Yiannopoulos’ Resignation from Breitbart News,” Daily Californian,Feb 21, 2018. ↩︎
  119. Mariel Goddu testimony, Chancellor’s Free Speech Commission hearings, Feb 9, 2018. ↩︎
  120. Anon. Berkeley Patriot member statement read by Goddu, Chancellor’s Free Speech Commission hearings, Feb 9, 2018. ↩︎
  121. Ibid. ↩︎
  122. “Faux Fortitude: Leftists are Not Brave for Speaking Out on Campus,” Berkeley Patriot, Aug 25 2017. ↩︎
  123. “Berkeley College Republicans’ Sign Destroyed,” Daily Californian, March 2, 2017. ↩︎
  124. Kaufman, “Campus Conservatives Gave the Alt-Right a Platform” National Review, August 15, 2017. ↩︎
  125. “Full Speaker List Revealed for ‘Free Speech Week” at UC Berkeley, Daily Californian, Sept. 14, 2017. ↩︎
  126. Art Tavan, “From the Mouth of Madness: the Dangerous Brand of Milo Yiannopoulos, Playboy, Sept. 22, 2017. ↩︎
  127. “‘Free Speech Week’ at UC Berkeley Was a ‘Political Theater,’ Carol Christ Tells ASUC Senate, Daily Californian, Oct 3, 2017. ↩︎
  128. Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
  129. Milo Yiannopoulos e-mail to Mogulof, RE: Free speech week, 8/24/17. ↩︎
  130. Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
  131. Ibid. ↩︎
  132. Marissa Reynoso and Millicent Grady Chaney interviews with the author. ↩︎
  133. Anon source 1 interview with the author. ↩︎
  134. Ibid. ↩︎
  135. Ibid. ↩︎
  136. Marissa Reynoso and anon. source 1 interviews with the author; “Milo Yiannopoulos Makes Brief Speech at UC Berkeley as Hundreds Protest Outside Barriers,” Daily Californian, Sept. 24, 2017. ↩︎
  137. Bryan Schatz, “Milo’s Dumb Free Speech Stunt Cost UC Berkeley $800K and Nothing Happened: Could That Have Been By Design?” Mother Jones, Sept. 25, 2917. ↩︎
  138. Ibid; Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
  139. “Milo Yiannopoulos Speaks While Hundreds Protest,” Daily Californian, Sept. 29, 2017. ↩︎
  140. “Conservative Berkeley Students Ask US Justice Department to Launch Investigation,” San Franciso Chronicle, Oct. 4, 2017, ↩︎
  141. For an excellent summary (complete with a time line chart) of the deadlines extended and missed repeatedly by the Berkeley Patriot in the planning for “Free Speech Week,” see “Berkeley Patriot Alleges UC Berkeley Ignored Request to Subsidize ‘Free Speech Week’ Costs,” Daily Californian, Sept. 19, 2017. ↩︎
  142. “Chancellor Christ Condemns Hate Messages,” UC Berkeley Public Affairs, Sept. 21, 2017. ↩︎
  143. “Berkeley Patriot Alleges UC Berkeley Retaliation to Chalk Graffiti, Posters in Additional Civil Rights Complaint,” Daily Californian, Oct. 4, 2017. ↩︎
  144. “Civil Rights Law Suit Filed over Cancelled Free Speech Week,” California news wire service, Oct 5, 2017. ↩︎
  145. Mogulof interview with the author. ↩︎
  146. Ibid. ↩︎
  147. Carol Christ interview with the author. ↩︎
  148. “Coulter Says She Assumes ‘Free Speech Week’ at UC Berkeley is Cancelled, Milo Yiannopoulos Says It’s On,” Washington Post, Sept, 22, 2017. ↩︎
  149. That the YAF and not Berkeley students were the driving force behind the “free speech” law suit against Cal was asserted by every administrator who had first hand knowledge of both the law suit and what most conservative Berkeley student activists were saying – in private --- about the suit. ↩︎
  150. Mogulof e-mail to the author, July 12, 2018. ↩︎
  151. Amy J. Binder and Kate Wood, Becoming Right: How Campuses Shape Young Conservatives (Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press, 2013. ↩︎
  152. Millicent Morris-Chaney telephone interview. ↩︎
  153. Ibid. ↩︎
  154. Ibid. ↩︎